Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

I'm not arguing they support YEC, just descent from Adam and Eve. That's not the same thing. And the population of 12,000 was much longer ago than YECs think the earth has even existed. Original sin came from Adam and Eve - that's core Catholic doctrine. If we aren't all descended from them, the Pope would have to admit that's false doctrine.

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120025/pope-francis-quotes-evolution-big-bang-are-nothing-celebrate

Reply

@CharityC The pope's position is not "intellectually respectable". It is wrong. Coyne is not "arguing from his conclusions," he is arguing from the evidence. The Theory of Evolution is accepted science.  The Catholic Church still argues that all humans descended from Adam and Eve, which DNA proves is impossible. The smallest number of humans we could have evolved from is around 12,000. If the Church fully accepted the Theory of Evolution it would have to admit there's no room or need in that theory for divine intervention.

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120025/pope-francis-quotes-evolution-big-bang-are-nothing-celebrate

Reply

As already stated above, well said. (Unusually for me) I didn't engage on this debate on Twitter, but (usually for me) I have some very strong opinions. What particularly annoys me is the stance all religions take, but Islam in particular, that if you oppose them your opposition is unfair and based on some form of prejudice, such as Islamophobia. A big part of my opposition to Islam is its treatment of women. I consider my opposition to be completely justified and I would take issue with anyone who tried to defend such treatment of women. However, this opposition is not the only problem I have with Islam, and I am opposed to anyone who considers relationship violence is OK whether religious or not, or, indeed, whether or not the victim is female.


Provocative debate is good, but imho this was a publicity stunt. Badar could have been relied upon to say something controversial, whatever the subject. FODI managed to get ahead of the ball with the topic.

5 months, 3 weeks ago on The Strange Case Of The Honour Killing Debate

Reply