Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

My Top 10:




The Girl Who Waited (11)

Curse of Fenric (7)





The Big Bang (11)

Englightenment (5)

Genesis of the Daleks (4) 

City of Death (4)

Silence in the Library/ Forest of the Dead (10) 

Amys Choice (11) 

The War Games (2) 

The Name of the Doctor (11)



16 hours, 44 minutes ago on Doctor Who: Fifty-One Favourites (Part 1)

Reply

This is not a list I can endorse

End of Time, Unicorn and the wasp and voyage of the damned are all in my bottom 20

19 hours, 21 minutes ago on Doctor Who: Fifty-One Favourites (Part 1)

Reply

@Romanadvoratrelundar is looking for Gallifrey @ElyotWren Not a positive contribution I'd say. Barbara Clegg (the first woman to *actually* write a script, rather than receiving credit) produced one of my all time favourite scripts in the form of Enlightenment however. 

Her contribution stands out as truly unique in the Davison era and a is great argument for the benefits of a more diverse writing staff. 

2 days, 11 hours ago on Torchwood’s Catherine Tregenna Penning Series 9 Story

Reply

The title is misleading. YOUR Doctor, is not always your first Doctor. He's just more likely to be. My first Doctor is Sylvester McCoy. I really loved the show (I was very young). When it went off the air I went back and watched old episodes and it was Tom Baker that HOOKED me on the show. 

Matt Smith deserves a mention as I'd not much enjoyed the new incarnation (despite how excited about it's return I'd been), and it was Smith and Moffat together and the outstanding series 5 that turned me from an ex-fan with fond memories to a currently active member of the fanbase.


3 days, 7 hours ago on From 1-12: Who is YOUR Doctor?

Reply

The last paragraph says it all about the fanbase really

6 days, 9 hours ago on Moffat on His Series 8 Worries

Reply

It'd be fun if the site could support drag down options so we could give each episode a ranking out of 10 to allow a direct contrast with the DW.tv teams list. Non devisive episodes that are largely enjoyed won't be well represented by this method.

1 week, 1 day ago on Finale Face-Off (Series 1-8)

Reply

I don't have a problem with the team providing their own averages, but the line "a mean was beginning to emerge" is a bit out of place. Clearly there is more bias here to the RTD scripts than the general public. Taking the dynamic rankings site (which claims to have 8943 votes rather than 10) I think we get a better idea of public opinion, certainly more in line with what I would expect.

#22 The Name of the Doctor

#27 The Pandorica Opens / The Big Bang



#28 Bad Wolf/ Parting of the Ways

#51 Army of Ghosts / Doomsday

#60 The Stolen Earth / Journeys End

#89 The Sound of the Drums/ The last of the Timelords

#105 The Wedding of River Song




1 week, 3 days ago on New Who Finales in Perspective: Series 7

Reply

Well is the Big Bang isn't topping this list then it's fair to assume the two top spots aren't moving... Which is horrifying. Series 3s finale made me actively dislike RTDs tenure

1 week, 5 days ago on New Who Finales in Perspective: Series 5

Reply

Look at all the comments calling this the best finale! 10 votes of connected individuals is clearly not enough.

Whatever the connection between people, their views are always more likely to fall in line with eachother over an unbiased mass vote.

Let us vote. Let us vote!

1 week, 5 days ago on New Who Finales in Perspective: Series 5

Reply

@The Finn @MicahMahaffey How on earth did it not work out? It's one of the most highly regarded serials.

1 week, 6 days ago on Moffat Mulls Future Companion Not Being Another Earth Girl

Reply

@ar2261 @TheEleventhWheatley Thing to remember is there are people on both sides of the fence there. I was over the moon when Dr Who came back to our screens... but the farting aliens had me worried and Big Brother in space clinched it for me. This wasn't "my" show anymore. 

Clearly it was yours.

Despite growing up with the classic show Series 5 is probably my favourite of the shows long history.

My advice to you (and in particular to Mr Selby) is to bare this in mind - as I try to. I can't have my ideal series without someone else enduring their worst nightmare of one. I struggle to think of anything worse than series 2 and season 24, but both have their fans.

2 weeks ago on 2nd Opinion: Death in Heaven

Reply

@TheEleventhWheatley Especially odd given the generally positive reaction to the episode in the fanbase. Not quite so universally loved as Dark Water but still. I'm especially tired of David Selbys reviews. He long since gave up the pretence of trying to be fair and has simply dropped into "it's by that showrunner I hate so it's going to be awful. Let's re-list all the reasons I think Moffat scripts are terrible and then spend a little time on this one". Not to mention the need to praise an RTD script thrown in there. 

I can't imagine what was superlative about the series 2 finale... Cybermen vs Daleks with smack talk. It struck me as the worst kind of fanfiction.









2 weeks ago on 2nd Opinion: Death in Heaven

Reply

@DawnTime At worst it was average, the bottom two on the list earned their spot.

2 weeks, 2 days ago on Your Verdict on Dark Water & Episode Ranking

Reply

Can't agree at all. And incomplete? There's nothing more frustrating than a forced happy ending. Look how many superb movies were utterly ruined by studio changes to "tie up loose ends". Blade Runner is an obvious one, but there's been many others such as the Butterfly Effect and the alterations to the novels ending for the LotR movies. This bittersweet parting was beautiful and apt.

2 weeks, 3 days ago on Death in Heaven Review (Part 1)

Reply

Tough one... I mean Utopia brought him back more out of the blue (with some superb casting that only lasted 5 minutes). Dark water introduced a Master (well, misstress) that I want to see a lot more of, and was a better episode.



2 weeks, 6 days ago on Face-Off: Utopia vs Dark Water

Reply

@LiamMorkham I always find Game of Thrones overly manipulative. It's a little too obvious that it's trying to push the audiences buttons and hence I never could get immersed in it.

3 weeks ago on Doctor Who Battling Game of Thrones

Reply

My point is that, whilst I stopped watching in the RTD era (around series 3), which as a lifelong fan shocked me, and yes I could attribute this to the showrunner scripts (I find RTDs writing very lowest common denominator and that irks me no end, every character seemed to constantly be explaining their present state of mind either to someone else or sometimes even the camera, every alien world felt totally unexotic and just like earth in the 21st century as if the audience were too stupid to cope with anything outside their frame of reference etc etc)...

...my complaints would be the same, week after week. As Me Selbys have become

3 weeks ago on 2nd Opinion: Dark Water

Reply

@The Genie @onetruepurple It does raise the question of why you continue to review his episodes. They become a bit one note. 


If I were to review RTDs episodes I imagine my views would be the same. I only enjoyed midnight. I can think of no other writer whom I have a comparably low opinion of in the shows history; I can even make room for 1 of Pip and Jane Bakers scripts. 




I'll criticise RTD as a writer in general, but being a guest contributor reviewer would be a mistake as every episode my complaints would be the same - as you say yourself, it's not the episodes I take issue with, but his entire writing style. So why would you want to review the episodes when you can't get past that?



3 weeks, 1 day ago on 2nd Opinion: Dark Water

Reply

Wow... couldn't disagree more with these reviews if I tried.

3 weeks, 1 day ago on 2nd Opinion: Dark Water

Reply

85 seems low to me for such a superb episode... even if it is the best this season. Really goes to show how the popularity of the Doctor, not the scripts, is what impacts public opinion. Tennant and Smith were generally more popular than Eccleston and Capaldi and the AI reflects that. The script only changes the score 2 points either way.



3 weeks, 3 days ago on Doctor Who Series 8 UK Ratings Accumulator

Reply

Very very happy! She is so much better in the role than John Simm.

3 weeks, 3 days ago on Poll: The Missy Reveal

Reply

Obvious? Most people were saying Rivet. Dark Water, a virtual world where the dead can continue to live. "My boyfriend", he thew in enough red herrings that I and many others thought IT was river.

3 weeks, 3 days ago on Poll: The Missy Reveal

Reply

Couldn't disagree more, in fact series 1 in my view is by far the worst arc. Even at the end of it you're left thinking "what was the point of scattering those words through time?"

Series 5 about nailed it for me, the build up was superb, it didn't interfere with any episodes.

I also don't see the problem with the best bit about a bad episode being the arc? I dislike chibnalls episodes, the hungry earth was never going to be a favourite of mine, but thanks to Rory's demise I left with a very positive tase in my mouth. Your view seems very pessimistic (not odd for Dr who fans I'll admit), no matter how I read your article it sounds like you are complaining that the arcs ELEVATE bad episodes, how is that in any way bad?

Call me a foolish optimist but that strikes me as a good thing.

The danger is when the writer doesnt have a satisfying conclusion. Popular opinion would say series 6 was such a time and I won't argue with the majority.

3 weeks, 5 days ago on The Trouble with Story Arcs

Reply

@Beasts_a_Snarling is in some... Dark Water..... I'm a huge Moffat fan, I only dislike two of his episodes... that Christmas special is one of them. Oh boy is it

4 weeks, 1 day ago on 2nd Opinion: In the Forest of the Night

Reply

John found flatline dull? DULL? Bizarre. Actually, I don't massively like in the forest of the night but dull is most definitely not a word I would select for it either. Ohwell what would the world be if we all agreed. Skaro, that's what.


4 weeks, 1 day ago on 2nd Opinion: In the Forest of the Night

Reply

I love the rankings. It's nice to see people appreciating the same episodes as me :) Hopefully means we'll get more of them

1 month ago on Your Verdict on Flatline & Episode Ranking

Reply

@MerieliaZ @no_tweeter It had science so bad I felt certain it's going to cause a whole generation of kids to fail GCSE physics.

1 month ago on Rate & Discuss In the Forest of the Night

Reply

1. Flatline 10/10


2. Listen 10/10



4. Into the Dalek 9/10

3. Mummy on the Orient Express 8.5/10


5. The Caretaker 8/10

6. Time Heist 7.5/10




7. Deep Breath 7/10

8. In the Forest of the Night 7/10


9. Robot of Sherwood 4/10

10. Kill the Moon 4/10

1 month ago on Rate & Discuss In the Forest of the Night

Reply

@MerieliaZ How bizarre. All my favourite episodes are in your bottom 4... and Robot of Sherwood at #3? 


1 month ago on Rate & Discuss In the Forest of the Night

Reply

@Deus_Ex_Machina Most people drift towards people who share their views. "I know lots of people who agree" is never a good argument for anything. I know no Doctor Who fan who doesn't adore the Doctors Wife... but that doesn't mean anything either.

1 month ago on Neil Gaiman on Hopes for Capaldi Episode

Reply

@SulaymanKhan Evolution of the Daleks two parter was HORRIBLE, and the Sontarn 2 parter no better.... I'd hapilly have Jacqueline Rayner write an episode though. Her Big Finish Doctor who work is superb.

1 month ago on Neil Gaiman on Hopes for Capaldi Episode

Reply

@Polyphase The hair band clara used in place of Rigsy to accelerate the train. It's a bit of self-deprecating humor.


1 month, 1 week ago on Flatline Review

Reply

Absolutely amazing. My favourite episode in a long long time. All the dissapointing build up and positive reviews for Kill the Moon led me to all but give up hope. Fortunately this episode restored my faith.


1 month, 1 week ago on Rate & Discuss Flatline

Reply

@JamesStroud Got to disagree, for me so far it's: Series 5, Series 7, Series 8, Series 6, Series 1, Series 4, Series 3, and then the just plain terrible Series 2

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Thoughts on Series 8 at the Halfway Point

Reply

@77Serenade I think you put emphasis on the wrong word there...

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Flatline Official Synopsis

Reply

@Polyphase Which way do you think it would change? My view improved with second viewing, but that often happens with Moffat episodes for me - I'm curious is others are the same or if others enjoy the first viewing more. I always see the holes first, and not the brilliance, some of my now favourite episodes were only 8/10s for me on first viewing and I have no idea why. I must be too negative.

2 months ago on Your Verdict on Listen & Episode Ranking

Reply

@Polyphase @Romanadvoratrelundar There are many grotesquely shaped humans

2 months ago on Your Verdict on Listen & Episode Ranking

Reply

@joshtong11 It's a time loop, like Blink, the Big Bang or Time and Space.

2 months ago on Rate & Discuss Time Heist

Reply

@YaelMoise @Gustaff Not really, if every week you offer a positive and a negative view then the reviews becoming meaningless. A good episode deserves extra praise.

2 months, 1 week ago on 2nd Opinion: Listen

Reply

@Planet of the Deaf That already happened before with Tegan. If you play those metaphores too closely you end up with a very dull and repetative show.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on A Surprise Ending for Clara?

Reply

Surprising, I enjoyed it more than Deep Breath and (if only due to the ending) more than Dalek... still if everyone thought alike the world would be no fun; and I must confess it was retreading old ground (but I would say fixing mistakes along the way).

2 months, 2 weeks ago on Your Verdict on Into the Dalek

Reply

@Antee991166 @ Notsosmartguy  @no_tweeter Oh absolutely, that wasn't my question. My question is why don't the AI's, a representation of the viewiership at large, and the online fandom viewpoint ever seem to match up? Personally I've felt Moffat was flawless as a standalone writer, and is now variable. Series 5 and 7 were superb, but aside from the opening two parter his episodes weren't a highlight of series 6 for me (but going by the AI they were for the average viewer). I didn't enjoy the series 6 christmas special or Deep Breath at all, and I certainly don't begrduge anyone their opinion, but from a psychological standpoint I'm curious why negative views so often bubble to the top of the fanbase.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on Don’t Worry, We’re Listening

Reply

Where do all these Moffat haters come from. Given the AI's for his episodes are almost invariably the highest of each season.... there are always a lot of people writing comments and editorials and comments accusing him of having totally lost it (I've personally only not enjoyed 2 of his episodes... unfortunately one of them was Deep Breath which makes a bit worried for Listen). Genuinely serious question here - is this a difference between the fandom, is he appealing to the masses,Joe Average with his BEEB box, or is is there something in the psyche of fans which makes them more likely to voice their opinions when they are negative rather that positive? In any case I do find it tiring to have every third article start off with "I don't like Moffat"... Personally I don't like RTDs writing, or Justin Bieber but then I'm not inclined to write about something I *don't* enjoy. Most people don't enjoy 2% of the books, shows and films out there, it's not something remarkable. Loving something is a rare gift. Something not being to your tastes is a matter of statistical probability else there would only be one or two active authors at a time and a couple of serial TV shows.          As for listen I know little, so my expectations are non-existent - I'd preferr not to make up my mind in advance based on zero information.



2 months, 2 weeks ago on Don’t Worry, We’re Listening

Reply

Hmm tough one. Into the Dalek corrects a lot of my issues with Dalek (in particular the ending), but it does so with the benefit of hindsight and can't make the same claims to originallity. I'm going with into the Dalek as I think I'm more likely to come back to it, but it's not really a fair comparison.



2 months, 3 weeks ago on Face-Off: Dalek vs Into the Dalek

Reply

I thought it was absolutely superb. Not that convinced by deep breath but by the end of into the Dalek I was a lot more confident about the new direction.

2 months, 4 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Into the Dalek

Reply

@Trex in the Thames Oddly I like all of his episodes except for the Crimson Horror and Night Terrors.

3 months ago on Robot of Sherwood BBC Synopsis

Reply

@MeglosProductions Well... it is my second least favourite Moffat script. 

3 months ago on Deep Breath UK Ratings

Reply

@JojajeVovave Hehe. Love is boring. You are such a stereotypical sci-fi fan. You've genuinely tickled my funny bone today. Thank you.


3 months ago on Rate & Discuss Deep Breath

Reply