Bio not provided
I'm sad to see any episode so low, they're all great.
Can't all the 39 episodes be on the top 10?
4 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: Results (33-27)
bring back Captain Jack!
there can't be a post about him without a comment like this
4 months, 1 week ago on River Song & Captain Jack: Five Favourites
@ClaraOswald please rewatch it.
i felt just like you the first time i watched it but now i think it's a quite good episode.
4 months, 1 week ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Time of the Doctor
@Baker Street who nose?
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Day of the Doctor
@Galax i don't get it. it's flawless but it doesn't deserve a 10?
@Esterath Time flies. Never really understood that phrase.
@Antee991166 well, the sub-plots are never as interesting as the main one, that's why they are sub-plots :) and they brought Billie because many fans love her and they care about the fans, and because they needed a face for the Moment of course
i see people here laughing at the thought of Nicholas Cage playing the Doctor, i see people that would kill to see him as the Doctor and people that would kill for the opposite, so i'm feeling like i'm missing something, is there anything i should know about him?
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Weird and Wonderful
there should be a scale of spoilerness on these articles
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Major Series 8 Villain Revealed?
@DrWhoGoesThere @Baker StreetYes. It turns you into his butt with one single touch, how's that not terrifying?
4 months, 2 weeks ago on 5 Underrated Doctor Who Monsters and Villains
@Notsosmartguy the other Doctors accepted their fate (not sure if they all did, still watching the classics) so i love how this one shows something different (:
4 months, 2 weeks ago on The Actual Plot Holes in Doctor Who
@Notsosmartguy hey i loved that bit so much, i don't care if he complained and other Doctors didn't. Every Doctor's different and 10's regeneration was perfect for his character.
@TardisConverse @youshallnotpass@_DWwhovian oh come on, i was just sharing my opinion and saying i don't find that too important and maybe she shouldn't care about it either as it could have many explanations.
and i, personally, really don't care (sorry) about eras, i try to help whenever i think i can and that's all.
now, i've read my original comment again and i realize it can be misunderstood, so sorry about that, i'll be more careful next time.
@TardisConverse @youshallnotpass@_DWwhoviani would say it, it's not and ''i don't care if you don't understand'', it's an ''i, personally, don't really care how they escaped''. dude...
@TardisConverse @youshallnotpass@_DWwhovianwow i was not being rude! i was trying to help but obviously i didn't use the right words, sorry :/
@TARDISkey221B and also: people don't know what a plot hole is so when they don't like an episode/writer/showrunner they talk about plot holes.
@NiallConway actually he read Amelia's last farewell which means he can never see her again.
@_DWwhovian how could they escape? they were his past, like echoes, they weren't conscious. As for how they got out of his time stream, i really don't care that it isn't explained.
And i think River thought he would either die or create a massive paradox.
@Liana21 you always end up talking about Inspector Rex hahah
@Regenerated Catterson @The Administratorwell they had to get rid of the Ponds somehow..
@Regenerated Catterson because he read in the book about the last farewaell, so if he sees Amy and Rory, New York goes KABOOOOM
@JolomontheDalek @youshallnotpassi mean that those can be explained (just look at the replies to your comment) if you think about them and use your imagination, but i get the feeling that you don't like this episode and you're like trying to find reasons to dislike it or something
@blake_avon the article is amazing and Gustaff has put a lot of work into it
@JolomontheDalek i really believe that if you think a little more about those points you'll understand every single one of them
@Jamesss @Amy the Consulting Key Ringhe can't even see them, he read that that would be their 'last farewell' so it's a fixed point in time
@Jamesss @youshallnotpass@DavidFeetenby The Doctor explains it, whenever you take a decision you create a different universe. That means that there is one universe where Davros is the good one and the Doctor is the baddie.
@Jamesss @DavidFeetenbyone Davros in every universe, of course there are universes where he doesn't exist. Same for the Doctor. Also, it would be awesome to have a story where the Doctor meets himself from another universe.
@Notsosmartguy maybe they even make it better. We need more plot holes, Moffat.
@SteviePenny a (mr.) sweet episode? hahah
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Crimson Horror
@supermoff @Americanwhovianthey really have to give Doctor Who more money!! It deserves it!!
@Doctor What and Where @youshallnotpass i don't know man, just go to Best of Matt Smith: The Crimson Horror and read the comments. People love it.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Gatiss: Capaldi Changes Everything, Brings New Rules
@DrWhoGoesThere @supermoff when i rank Doctor Who episodes in comparison to other Doctor Who episodes, i almost always give 8s 9s 10s. Because they're all awesome.
@Maryanne123 hm... i'd say 4 all time great doctors in a row.
@Doctor What and Where many people enjoy his episodes, they are divisive indeed but you can't say he's a bad writer, he's good and probably the next showrunner (although i hope it's not him)
@Americanwhovian no doubt he'll have that too
@eddie1611 it's quite ridiculous to say that Peter, 55, is too old to play the Doctor, 2000.
these reviews make me want to read more.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Salt of the Earth Review
@The Finn @youshallnotpass@Meh Meh Meh Meh MehJust... WATCH IT!
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Bring Back… the Pure Historicals
@The Finn @Meh Meh Meh Meh Mehnah, the Romans
@Tennant_Capaldi rewatch it.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: Hide
@Lord Styro the Drashig
Part 2 of extremely huge comment
me: hehe... ''extremely huge comment''...it's not that huge, it has 2 parts.
read and enjoyed everything though =)
What's the problem with Moffat bringing his 'friends' back though? It's obviously because he trusts them, he knows what they are capable of and he wants the best for the show, remember he is its biggest fan.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Series 8: Episode 4 & 5 Writers Confirmed
@Me and Stuff @The Finn@WiblyWoblyTimyWimyMOFFATmaybe 2-3 or 3-4 is a two parter...
@Moxx no, i do because he's attacking all of the writers except Russell and especially Moffat without any reason to do so. But yeah i know it's his opinion and all that.
i won't judge a writer based on his previous episodes (although i liked Curse and Journey). Even if he was a 'bad' writer, this story could be a good one, so i'll wait until i watch it and judge later.
@Moxx that's funny, every casual viewer i know says it's getting better and better. i didn't even like moffat at first and i prefered him in the RTD era, but he's doing a really great job and i think he's the best showrunner we could have right now.
@JJ2000 this show is rubbish, it's dead? you must be trolling
@Liana21 'cause he's eviiiil
4 months, 2 weeks ago on The Speculator’s Guide to… The Next Showrunner
I think the only option that would please us all is Neil Gaiman.
Nothing's impossible right?
@Planet of the Deaf @StephenAHayes And then he reveals that the Doctor is his cousin.
This kinda worries me, as there's no option that would satisfy most of the fans...
Steven Moffat is still the best for the show at the moment so I hope he stays as long as necessary until we find a better, more obvious worthy writer to replace him.
@Clara_Oswin_Oswald i really hope it's not him
@FallenNocturne @Amy the Consulting Key Ringyou're one of those who want 5 minutes to explain everything and then complains about the conclusion being rushed.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: Cold War
@FallenNocturne @GregChipmanyou don't have to give every single story a 4, you can give 8s and 10s too.
@thehlrviper''We continue Series 7 with Cold War. All you have to do is rate the story with your score out of 10...''
@Planet of the Deaf @youshallnotpass@SonicTheHedgehogRuleshah! what? ....... where can i see mark naked?
@SonicTheHedgehogRules i don't see the problem with seeing him naked though, without the armour he was faster, more skilful and he needed to escape. it was necessary to the plot.
@ivegotkidneys @sontaran17@Galaxi hate livefyre
^ this is my catchphrase now ^
why do people hate this episode? it's entertaining, it brings back the ice warriors, it shows a couple of things about them, it demonstrates how lethal and ruthless they are. not the best but definitely not bad, it deserves a 9/10.
@JLS1138 i was about to say this. it's like being nice and kind and a great person is an important requirement to play the Doctor.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Capaldi: Matt Smith told me to look after Doctor Who
@sontaran17 @Jardi101Marry me.
4 months, 2 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Rings of Akhaten
@Baker Street I usually don't read long comments but I really enjoy reading yours because I love all that passion and work you put into them! You're a great writer and I'm looking forward to reading your articles!
4 months, 3 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Rings of Akhaten
@Amy the Consulting Key Ring You can explain practically anything and it makes sense.
I love you.
@Baker Street I love your reviews.
@Amy the Consulting Key Ring Fear her is not that bad.
@Amy the Consulting Key Ring of course that's even better but there's always people who analyze everything just to find its flaws.
@Strontium whovians when the plot is complicated: it's too darn complicated to follow!
whovians when the plot is simple: it's too darn simple, it's for kids!
@Clara Prefect aaand there's one...
@Clara Prefect praying doesn't mean you're religious. Anyway, all i'm saying is that they should have one companion talk about his beliefs on screen.
@Clara Prefect i'm pretty sure there are.
@Invictus12 What's the point in being grown up if you can't be... immature sometimes?
@The Mind Probe this one? Every single episode divides us.
@Princess Moffat @youshallnotpassit's always like that. I personally prefer to let my inner kid enjoy Doctor Who without analyzing everything.
@Princess Moffat @youshallnotpass 8,3/10 without the speech. 9,7/10 with it.
i really like the speech.
@ivegotkidneys @youshallnotpass@Amy the Consulting Key Ring i think they should have one companion to clearly say what her/his beliefs are without being afraid to say it.
@Princess Moffat well different personalities, different opinions.
i do think this speech was way better than the Pandorica speech.
@Amy the Consulting Key Ring they really should have a Christian companion though.
@ivegotkidneys @Esterath yes :/
I see people in every episode giving 1/10s and ''0/10s''... I can understand a 4/10, but a 1/10, to the series you love? I will never understand that. Oh well, I guess I'm the only one who enjoys every single episode like a kid.
@Adric the Genius I'm a Christian but I didn't feel like he was denying religion in general. He said that 'god' was not a god, it was a parasite. The Doctor doesn't defeat it because his memories were just things that happened and the leaf represented all the things that could have happened, endless possibilities. That's how I see it.
@The Genie not to mention that they don't have a sun now.
@FallenNocturne @Notsosmartguy My sister is an university student from 2014 that lives on WiFi and has no idea how the internet works.
4 months, 3 weeks ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Bells of Saint John
oh great so this comment is posted but not the one i tried to post like 30 times. that's it, screw this, i'll stop commenting
4 months, 3 weeks ago on What if… Clara had stayed Victorian?
what's wrong with this thing??