Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

@Luna23 Yeah yeah, I know about this everyone against everyone thingy in this voting. However, we all *kinda* know that Smith is gonna win - so just a tad unfair for a Doctor that could not, in all of the centuries of his life and the mere minutes of our screen time, win anything against Smith... That's all...

1 week ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #5

Reply

Pretty unfair this one... Of course Smith is gonna win this (and overall), but it's tremendously unfair to a pretty decent Doctor, the War one. And to Eccleston. And to Capaldi.


Mr. Hurt gets my vote. Easily.

1 week, 1 day ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #5

Reply

I thought that the 10th was pretty close to what I had in mind as to what the Doctor should be. And then, came the 12th... Twelve, all the way, and the only reason not for him to be my favorite ever incarnation is a guy called Tom Baker...


DoctorWhoTV, how about a poll with all 13 faces? Smith will win it, like this one, but just for the fun of it...

1 week, 2 days ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #4

Reply

I feel glad that the ninth will get at least some votes, judging by the comments... Yes, Nine for me as well. I never cared for Eleven really...

1 week, 3 days ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #3

Reply

Ten gets a nine. He was the Doctor more that Eccleston, and in general.

2 weeks, 3 days ago on Doctor of the Decade: Rate the Tenth Doctor

Reply

Boy, some heavy shoes to fill, this guy... Again, like most things on Whoniverse, everything has  two quite different sides: The 9th Doctor can either be seen as part of the Whoniverse, i.e as just another Doctor, or as part of the real world cultural phenomenon that is the show: in charge of bringing it to a whole new generation (and some rather old ones - like myself - which was a tad more difficult) seamlessly. The bringing back thingy was not exclusive to Eccleston, but to awhole production company behind leader RTD. As far as this is concerned, he will always get a 10/10 from be, as he did an amazing job.


As for the in-universe thingy, putting him up against the previous 8 actors is certainly not an easy task. It should also be noted that, IMHO, this is the definitive concideration for this (or any) voting process. However, I was never entirely convinced that that guy on screen was "the Doctor". Great actor, yes. Great acting, of course. Great Doctor, not so much. He was not as bad as that hideous 6th, of course, but he wasn't 1st/4th/12th either. Let's get him an 8/10 - a high score indeed...

2 weeks, 3 days ago on Doctor of the Decade: Rate the Ninth Doctor

Reply

Although Listen is worthy of this award, I really don't believe it'll get it. This hideous fan-favourite Game of Thrones thingy could ruin everything...


And... The Flash pilot? How did this end up there? I can think of multiple episodes much better than the pilot...

2 weeks, 6 days ago on Listen Up for Hugo Award

Reply

Not unexpected, but tricky nonetheless... A true sci-fi masterpiece that transcends the show, and an episode 50 years in the making, with a side of a Zygon (stupid) story. One introduces the Weeping Angels, the other closes some major story gaps and/or arcs. One does NOT have Martha Jones in it, and the other has the Bad Wolf version of Rose Tyler. Wow! Tricky indeed. Will go for Blink, though, 'cause of this sci-fi masterpiece business... If you sit and examine the 2 stories of the Day episode, the Zygon part is stupid, and the 3 Doctors thingy needs some "splaining" to the uninitiated...

1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: The Grand Final

Reply

The Wife got knocked up? I mean *OUT*, knocked out!?!? Pitty... So, this DAY, the NAME is VINCENT... Easy-ish...

1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: Moffat Era Triple

Reply

@DWTV is No Thrills DWTV Oh, my... That sounds intriguingly like a threat - one of the good ones!

1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #12

Reply

Although probably not the best episode ever (or something similarly whovian-like), The Day can truly compete with only a handful of episodes/stories and have a chance to lose. Water/Death in NOT of these stories. So, The Day. Easily.

1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #12

Reply

And here I was, thinking that whenever The Doctor's Wife participates in any voting, it gets my vote, without a second (or even a first) thought. Now this is another tricky one... The only problem with the Wife, is that the addition of Rory to the original Rory-less script messed things up quite a lot. The only problem with Vincent is the blind rooster thingy. Neither of those "problems" is enough to make these two episodes anything less than pure perfection - each in its own way. However, when comparing pure sci-fi joy to pure human emotion, especially considering that the show is sci-fi, well... It gets my vote. "Wife" it is!

1 month, 1 week ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #8

Reply

When Science Fiction meets Hitchkok (or even Tarkowski - who himself got those two meet), you get Midnight. RTD at his finest for sure. Again, you gotta love a "what-if" episode, and Turn Left surely delivers. But, MIdnight it is for this one - easily. BTW, the previous vote was for Series 5 and now we're back at 4 with the voting process - I can never understand these voting thingies...

1 month, 1 week ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #7

Reply

Yeap, this IS difficult. Really, properly difficult. If you try to get pros and cons for each episode, on every possible aspect, you get similar results. For instance: Doctor-wise, they both feature the Tenth, so it's a tie. Companion wise, one does NOT feature Martha, the other features Donna - again, a tie. Scary-wise, both frightening as hell. Mythology-of-the-show-wise, one introduces the Weeping Angels and their unique physiology, the other introduces River Song, and her demise (frakk, a point for Library!). Of course, you realise that I'm trying really hard to vote for Blink here, hey? So, let's try to focus on some other aspect, i.e. the impact both episodes had outside the Whoniverse. Blink, especially being a Doctor-lite episode, can be viewed as a standalone piece of sci-fi, with no strings attached. Even the short story on which it's based upon (featuring the Ninth Doctor) is brilliant. Best episode of the revival - or the show as a whole? In a show with such a profound amount of variety, there can be no such thing - one of the best, sure. A sci-fi literature masterpiece? Hell yeah! It easily belongs up there, among such brilliant classics as "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy", "A Scanner Darkly", Scott's "Alien", "Battlestar Galactica" (the revival), "Do androids dream of electric sheep?", "Dune" and Asimov's Foundation and Robots series. And, although many things can be said about the Library/Forest, this last one cannot. So, Blink - or don't...

1 month, 2 weeks ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #4

Reply

And here is yet another difficult choice. I honestly cannot understand how this whole face-off thingy works, and how each match-up is produced, but I can never resist a vote! So: Both really upsetting and disturbing episodes, each in its own way. I 'll have to go with Planet/Pit on this one. Although a darker Doctor is always welcome (yet seldom offered), anything combining religion and sci-fi gets thumbs up from me. Oh, and there is this stupid "Gadget" robot that ruins an otherwise excellent episode.

1 month, 2 weeks ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #3

Reply

Piece of cake. The Mummy one. Excellent sequence, for an excellent episode.

3 months ago on Best of 2014 Awards #12: Pre-Title Sequence

Reply

@Beasts_a_Snarling - THE KANDYMAN'S APPRENTICE Never thought I would read this sentence from anyone, ever. I could not agree more!

3 months, 1 week ago on The Lord of the Dream: Amy’s Choice in Perspective

Reply

@Jeavons !!!!! Exactly same here! Yeap, that was it!!!

5 months ago on From 1-12: Who is YOUR Doctor?

Reply

What a complete dissapointment/what a (fantastic-brilliant-touching) episode! Oscillating between these two, was an easy task with this episode. If I were to dissect this, there are three distinct story elements. The first one is, the main story of the Master and his grand, bad scheme. Terrible! Water just making dead people cyber - what a complete waste of time. Clever, you have to grand moffat at least that, but uninteresting. The second aspect was, of course Danny and Clara. All this CyberDanny calling Clara a bitch right in her face with every single word coming out of his mouth was cruel and sad. Not uncalled for, but bitter in a bad way. Now, for the third, Moffat's treatment of the mythology of the show, something that he has excelled before and excelled once again! Now that is the Moff we know and love. I litteraly had to pause the episode when I realised that it was the Brigadier in Cyber form that rescued his daughter - I was crying like a baby... I was shocked when the Doctor claimed he'd found Gallifrey, even more shocked when we saw he was lying just to let the happy couple be happy, and again even more when Clara stuck with his assumption and lettting the Doctor believe that indeed Danny was back. She obviously does that, to let our Doctor free. And thank God for that! Clara is finally over!!!! Amen - "sing Hosanna" - and everything in between! Moffat's dialogue and Gomez' acting were the true highlights of the whole two parter... "Why don't you like hugs?" - "Hugs is an easy way to hide your face". And they both wanted to do just that...



5 months, 2 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Death in Heaven

Reply

@AlexandraShepiro Interesting...

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Dark Water

Reply

@GalaxyEyes @madscotsmandoctor @supermoff is ready for Dark Water! ...when in fact, it is CLEARLY stated that the sex can change? "The Doctor's Wife", anyone?

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Dark Water

Reply

And please, some credit to the amazing score? Once again, Murray Gold has done an excellent job...

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Dark Water

Reply

People, relax. Just keep in mind that this "manifestation" of the Master could easily be one before John Simm's/Professor YANA's, or even Delgado's. Who's to say that Delgado was the first Master? Maybe he was the third (the first being a male version the Doctor knew, and the second being Missy), or the fourth, or the 13th. The ONLY (and I mean the ONLY) point that bugged me in this episode was the fact that the Doctor did not realise that he was dealing with a Time Lady. Aren't they supposed to somehow sense each other?

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Dark Water

Reply

@RiseOfBread  "The Bible never says, "Hate all gays." ". No, it doesn't. It just instructs Christians to kill them. That Leviticus 20:13 thingy is, well, there for all to see... When speaking about LGBT rights issues, it's always wrong to add religion to the talk, any religion, since any religion will tell just that in one way or another.







6 months, 3 weeks ago on Doctor Who and Sexuality

Reply

@Leslaeus The problem word here is "Conspicuous". I have never seen any straight people get attacked when they indulge in 'conspicuous' behaviour. And another thing: You say "Aside from less developed nations like those in Africa, the world is very tolerant of homosexuality". I'll just let the immortal words of Amelia Williams (nee Pond), be my comment on that: "Are you from another planet?"



6 months, 3 weeks ago on Doctor Who and Sexuality

Reply

Again, two sides to this coin. Yes, this show has the potential to be extremely dark and adult (not Torchwood adult, think more like the Alien movies adult). However, it would lose its status of a "family" show. And, no matter what we fans say (I, for one, would love the show to turn to adult sci-fi - but I am an adult), the BBC want the entire family to sit and watch the show. Besides, especially when compared with the classic era, it is dark enough - kids these days can handle (or maybe are allowed to handle?) a lot more adult and dark themes and storylines than I remember from the time when I was a kid (some 30 years ago). The "behind the sofa" thingy is surely a thing of the past...

10 months ago on Should Doctor Who Adopt a Darker Tone?

Reply

Again, we should all be reminded that the John Simm Master could be in his second reincarnation, making YANA the first Mster, or Delgado's could be the fourth, or the TV movie's "Master without remaining lives" could be the Master that has used his third set of regenarations... The fact remains that we don't know anything about the Master's regenerations, apart from the one (or two, counting the movie - Tremas is not actually regeneration I think) we've seen on screen. And maybe, just maybe, it's better this way...

10 months ago on The Master’s Moffat Plan

Reply

No.

11 months, 1 week ago on The Theme – Time for a Change?

Reply

If the Doctor's wife hadn't made it into this list, I would lose my faith in the human race or something...

1 year ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off Results: Dream Run (Episodes 1-8)

Reply

Well, another easy one. The God Complex.

1 year ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 11

Reply

Oooh, a VERY difficult one! And I cannot stress this strongly enough! All of these (and yes, I'm including 'Love and Monsters') are actually brilliant episodes, each for its own reasons. 


As always, the final vote is heavily dependant on how one chooses to categorise the episodes. For instance, they can be divided in 2 broad categories, the arc/whole show important (the last two), and the mostly stand-alones (the rest). Another way to divide the list, is a weird one. You have those that you must know of the whole show in advance in order to get what's going on, and the others that knowing you are dealing with a show that goes on for 50 years is unimportant - they could be simply broadcast as mini-movies, with just a minor introduction to the characters and the TARDIS. The latter category includes "Vincent...", "Blink" and "Midnight" - all you had to know for these was that there's a guy named the Doctor for some weird reason, and he can travel in space and time.


Phew! What an unfair comparison!!! This ongoing, unfair, and agonising voting process, now asks for the perfect episode ten, which implies that you are dealing with a whole show, and not some sci-fi chunks - therefore, by my previous last reasoning, I have to exclude the best 3 of the list!!! And yes, I 've been a fan of the show for over 25 years now, and that's how I 'm suposed to vote. But I 'm also a huge sci-fi fan. So, I 'll follow my heart.


"The Doctor Dances": weird title. "Love...": clever story, stupid monster. "Vincent..."/"The Girl...": perfect drama, easy tears. "Journey...": Did not deliver, but gave an huge insight on the who-is-clara, and what's-the-secret thingys. Down to two...


If you ask me "What is your most favorite episode of NuWho", 9 out of 10 I'll say "Blink". But, when I see this list, I have to go with the Hitchcockian "Midnight". "Blink" is a perfect slice of sci-fi literature history. Boggles the mind with its timey-wimey (Moffat's best feauture), offers a chilling alien threat (along with the opportunity to teach kids what quantum physics is all about), and features great one-off characters and actors.


"Midnight", however, transcends the boundaries of a 'simple' sci-fi show, and it touches primal fears and insticts. It goes to show what you can (and can't) do with a handful of great actors, a 'plain' 'room' as a setting and a great story. Simple perfection - any way I cut and slice it. 


Sorry, "Blink", this one goes to "Midnight".



1 year ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 10

Reply

Hey, an interesting one! This actually is pretty fun! The "splits are not counted" thingy is still pretty stupid, but here is a vote from Greece:

All stories are spooky , so that's easy. One of them is a second in a two-parter - so no counting this one. Night terrors was pretty dull, there's one out. "The Satan Pit" felt incomplete (well, it really was, but "The Empty Child" was far more complete, even if it was, yet again, a two-parter), "The Family of Blood", was a not-so-interesting-as-Blink Doctor-lite story, "Hide" had that hideous Clara in it, so that's out.

Yeap, "The Empty Child" it is!!!



1 year ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 9

Reply

When a poll arises and contains "the Doctor's Wife", well, it's pretty much a dead end.

The Doctor's Wife, nuff said.


1 year ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 4

Reply

Now, I really hoped that I wouldn't vote on any of these "face-off" thingys, but then again, there's "School Reunion". Although it featured K-9, a weak excuse for a companion even in the old days, Mickey, another bad excuse for a companion, it also featured that shocking moment, when Sarah Jane stumbles across the TARDIS, followed by her and the Doctor meeting again - for the first time. Shocking! Really!


It also featured "the missus and the ex", the swimming pool confrontation, current companion's realisation of being "the latest in a long line", or the Doctor just leaving them behind... All sorts of cool stuff for an old-timer like me. Hey, even a brand new K-9 to kick-off a spin-off...


-Ah, it's not goodbye...

-Say it, please! This time. Say it...

-Good bye, my Sarah Jane.


1 year, 1 month ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 3

Reply

Marks introduction states that "Reintroducing the show to the audience after a long time off-air is no easy feat." If you agree on this, and I probably do, then where is "The Bells of Saint John" episode? Shouldn't it be considered a series opener? Granted, it officialy was not, however, if the remark by Mark is taken as a (sort of) definition, then it is.

What I'm trying to say is that this particular poll is not as clear as it could (or could not) be. What I'm ultimately trying to say is that all these polls are... Meaningless? Useless? Without-a-point? Something of the sort.

When considering the list of episodes presented here, as a list of episodes that for some reason are up for voting against each other, then my vote would go to "Asylum of the Daleks". But it isn't. So, no vote.






1 year, 1 month ago on Series 1-7 Face-Off: Episode 1

Reply

Yes, we will all find some oddities here and there - that's is just the voting process kicking in. And yes, for me the widow could be a little higher, say around 6,5.


What I find bizarre, is that the lowest score of all 39 'episodes' ('stories' would be a better word), is actually pretty high, considering there are 38 more of them to come. Could it be that we 'll see a grade of a 'perfect' 10 on the top spot? Mind you, a 9,899 and above could be considered as a perfect ten as well. And another thing - just for the sake of it, maybe doctorwhotv could give us any nymbers on the votes?


1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: Results (39-34)

Reply

And the time has come. The Day of the Doctor is up for vote. Actually, 2 stories in one, with the Zygon thingy being stupid as hell, and the Time War business being just excellent. Tennant was completely out of shape, and the Daleks shooting each other is plain rediculous. Another unfair comparison, this time with itself.


However, "DaftDalek" below, just sums it up beautifully: "None of this matters", he/she says, and this could not be more true in this case. A perfect 10/10 for this one.

1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Day of the Doctor

Reply

@Wimsey  Let's not forget that we haven't seen all 13 incarnations of the Master. It could be an incarnation even before Delgado's... However, it is an interesting idea, all this time-lock thingy and the "End of time" events, after the Day of the Doctor...



1 year, 1 month ago on Major Series 8 Villain Revealed?

Reply

And, yes, like everything else in life, this "moment has been prepared for". All the episodes of the show, it seems, lead up to these three episodes: Name, (Night and) Day, Time of the Doctor.



The problem with the Name of the Doctor, though, is that it differs from every other episode in a major way: it cannot stand as a 'standalone'. Rather, it concludes some major arcs. Another difference with, say Pandorica/Big Bang, is that the arcs closing have an impact to the show as a whole. And I honestly don't know how can we see it as anything else...


So, how can one rate this bugger? Production-wise, it's excellent. Just plain simple old excellent. Story-wise? Well, there is no story here. Arc-wise? IMHO, Moffat delivers. The ultimate arcs are explained, a brilliant cliffhanger (although it was spoiled from the depths of the Internet), some old viewer eye-candy in the form of previous incarnations of the Doctor... It has everything.


Having to rate this particular episode, is just unfair to every other. However, as an old fan (well, not that old), I give it a perfect 10/10 - an unfair grade, no matter how it may be justified.

1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Name of the Doctor

Reply

If compared with Gaiman's previous story, it sure is a lot lesser. Of course, when comparing "The Doctor's Wife" to any episode, well... You get the picture. However, I really dislike comparisons of this (or any other) sort. So, as an episode, it really reserves a 10 out of 10. Well paced, nice story, excellent acting and so on and so forth... Even the title is awesome!!!!

1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: Nightmare in Silver

Reply

Yes, the episode of the stupid questions: "How could they breath?" "Is it a star or a planet?" If you just relax and watch this amazing show, without trying to find flaws everywhere, then you 'll probably enjoy this truly amazing episode that has everything: Clara off to explore on her own, cheeky Susan reference for the older fan, story eating aliens, a speech, cool baddies (monsters?) of all sorts, brilliant music, visual effects, the leaf... Really, what's not to like? A 10 out of 10 for this one!



1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Rings of Akhaten

Reply

Yes, another perfect one. 10 out of 10, just like that - plain and simple!

1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Snowmen

Reply

@Galactic Yo Yo  Exactly my thoughts! 5/10 for this one...

1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: A Town Called Mercy

Reply

Pretty average (and yes, that means a 5/10). The story was average (apart from certain highlights, like the Doctor's price tag or the bad guy) and truly non-interesting, featuring two entirely non-interesting characters (that I thought were even unnececcary). This was probably a story that fell victim of the whole blockbuster-of-an-episode thingy that Moffat had going on. The only thing that stood out, was the scene when Rory's father sits on the doorstep of the TARDIS, enjoying a cuppa watching the Earth from above... A magical scene, that truly belongs to an (imaginary of course) anthology of magical moments of the whole show...




1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: Dinosaurs on a Spaceship

Reply

I never quite got the reasons all those people believe Moff is a sexist. I could never see it. In fact, what I see form Moffat is an equal representation of the two sexes, both of them being naughty or nice or anything in between...

1 year, 2 months ago on Is Steven Moffat a Feminist Writer?

Reply

Not sure about this one, even after all those months of first watching it. Probably an 8 out of 10. High, just because of the crazy sci-fi element, low because I didn't particularly like the elements that Moff included in the show's universe.


Yeah, that's about it then.

1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Wedding of River Song

Reply

Just perfect - 10 out of 10.

1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: The God Complex

Reply

Not a big fan of Gatiss here, and this is not an exception.  A really indifferent episode, not even worth of a scond chance... 3 out of 10, just for the effort...

1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: Night Terrors

Reply

Now this is Moffat at his best! The trick was to promote the episode with a 'shocking' title, which turned out to be a really big and fat red herring. The dialogue is absolutely brilliant, the story, well, it had its ups and downs (don't they all?), all the actors at their best, and the direction was just splendid! It makes you forget about the easiest of solutions, the deus-ex-machina (quite literally) of the Teselecta, it makes you furious that no info is given on the Silence, and it leaves you with one of the saddest timey-wimey of them all: The Doctor leaves the blue "spoilers" diary to River - the beginning of the end, or whatever this means. An easy 10/10.






1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: Let’s Kill Hitler

Reply

Now, this is a tough one. As all the series 6 arc episodes, it is important. When one looks at it that way, it is not such a big deal - maybe a 6 or 7. However, it is not important for the arc alone, but for the whole mythology of the show. As a fan of the show as a whole, I tend to regard it in the latter way. So, a 9 out of 10...




1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: A Good Man Goes to War

Reply