Bio not provided
@LaraHarris @Polyphase Robert Holmes never gave a monkey's for continuity, in fact he gleefully tore into it at times. And he's probably the most celebrated Doctor Who writer of them all if you don't count Douglas Adams :)
3 days, 16 hours ago on Rate & Discuss Mummy on the Orient Express
@allythomson903 Of course they wouldn't, I mean it's not like they've cancelled Doctor Who before or anything... ;)
1 week, 1 day ago on Doctor Who Series 8 UK Ratings Accumulator
@Zeldazelda Like Susan, for example? ;)
1 week, 3 days ago on Is Courtney Woods a Companion?
@VictorWong1 Sure you mean 'Barnable'? And where does one draw the line in terms of 'a long time working with the Doctor'? Does it mean 'travelled in the TARDIS'? :)
Lowest overnights of the series for the best episode of the series. There is no justice.
2 weeks, 1 day ago on Doctor Who Series 8 UK Ratings Accumulator
I loved the fact that it wasn't a 'known' event for once and I really had no idea how it was going to turn out, and then it surprised even more at the end. Ladies and gentleman, just my opinion, but I think we've just seen the debut of a potentially great Doctor Who writer :)
2 weeks, 2 days ago on Rate & Discuss Kill the Moon
@Unibot I've been watching Who for 33 years and I'm so relieved someone else feels the same way I do. I am really enjoying this series, but that one just hit it out of the park for me :)
In The Forest of the Night... "the only water in the forest is the River"? ;)
2 weeks, 5 days ago on Poll: Your Most Anticipated Series 8 Story (Eps 7-12)
@LGwalchmai95 I felt it went too far also. There was genuine contempt and disrespect for Danny on all levels to a degree that went beyond general disapproval. And based on what we know of Danny so far, he didn't deserve it. Particularly the repeated PE sniping. Possibly as unlikeable as I can remember the Doctor being (and I generally like Capaldi)
2 weeks, 5 days ago on Examining the Doctor’s Attitude Towards Soldiers
@Chronos the Fannibal "More caring" are you kidding? He was outright nasty towards Danny virtually the entire episode - it wasn't friendly bantering, it was deliberate contempt, almost hatred. The whole "PE" business really got up my nose, it was childish, playground bullying. And I say that as someone who has thoroughly enjoyed Series 8 so far.
3 weeks, 1 day ago on Rate & Discuss The Caretaker
@ Notsosmartguy The new Caretaker. Because this is Doctor Who, the show the fans love to hate ;)
@DDBlue Do you actually have a clue what you're talking about? Whereabouts was it stated that Courtney is 'precocious'? Even if they did, it's only your opinion that it was "a failure from all perspectives". Also, why shouldn't the show make efforts to relate to younger viewers? Newsflash, DW isn't just being made for adults ;)
@Beasts_a_Snarling Amazing the number of people who confuse opinion with fact :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling To a degree perhaps, but I still found it jarring.
3 weeks, 2 days ago on Rate & Discuss The Caretaker
The Doctor's antipathy towards Danny makes no sense, and he wasn't just larking around, he was repeatedly outright nasty. Has he completely managed to forget the Brigadier, one of his oldest and dearest allies, who was not only a soldier but on retirement became a Maths teacher? Am I missing something here, or did the Doctor's attitude jar? Otherwise, interesting episode.
@RUAZ I felt it went too far as well, I just felt it went beyond comedy bickering into serious contempt, hatred even, from Capaldi. Why? The Brigadier was one of his dearest allies.
@Handles Absolutely. It wasn't just comedy bickering, it was nasty, spiteful stuff from The Doctor, and Danny doesn't deserve it so far imho.
That was in many ways brilliant... but there's no getting around it, the Doctor was a vicious, nasty bastard to Danny... and nothing we know about Danny suggests that he deserved it. Really struggled with that. Edgy Doctor is one thing, focussed nasty is another. Not sure what I think as a result of that. I mean, in some ways it was a tremendously complex and emotional episode.
"Danny shares something in common with the Krafayis" - so did he torment Vincent Van Gogh too? ;)
3 weeks, 2 days ago on The Caretaker – 12 Hints & Teasers
@Florian Irwin Who cares if it does? Doctor Who has always nicked stuff :)
3 weeks, 2 days ago on Kill The Moon Clip
@StephenAHayes Lol maybe Stephen but you wouldn't be saying that if you grew up on the old series. I remember the Myrka! ;)
@ Notsosmartguy The new Caretaker. @Switcharoo Because people love to moan, and on evidence I've seen, a sizeable proportion of them like parroting the criticisms of others and don't bother to actually think these things through for themselves. I wouldn't go so far as to call SM a feminist writer, but I certainly wouldn't call him sexist either. It's 'fashionable' to bash SM though (as opposed to intelligent criticism) and regrettably I doubt it will pass. Being in charge of Doctor Who these days requires as thick a skin as being England football manager.
3 weeks, 6 days ago on Time Heist Review
While admitting Time Heist wasn't perfect, I can't agree with this review. I wasn't expecting some deep, finely-wrought masterpiece. It's Doctor Who does Hustle, and to that end I thought it worked admirably in the same vein; I never watched Hustle as anything other than escapist entertainment and Time Heist fell squarely into that category. Better than Thompson's previous efforts; I did at least actually want to watch this one again. So no classic, but as filler goes, a perfectly entertaining way to spend 45 minutes.
@Jawsey When did Eleven break the fourth wall in actual stories? I can't remember.
4 weeks, 1 day ago on Rate & Discuss Time Heist
@YaelMoise @bringmeknitting I'm good with that too. I think the bottom line for me is that I don't take Capaldi's words to mean he is 'actively' jealous - i.e. that he wants her for himself. A highly entertaining rejoinder Yael, and yes I can actually think of at least one situation where I have thought like that - it's basically an ego moment, no? I don't think we're clashing here in any case, my point is simply that Capaldi is not going to start snogging Clara or anything of that kind, and for me personally that line does not give me the squirms. No Papa/Nicole :)
@DasManiac Another illuminating critique from DasManiac. 4/10 :P
@MrRazza, Latest Result: Mr Pink is Human I really enjoyed reading this review and I also appreciated the positive mindset you clearly have; recognising the flaws in the episode as you see them, but finding ways to enjoy nonetheless. Thanks :)
I've let the initial wave of response to "Listen" to abate before throwing my oar in. There was so much to treasure in this story in my opinion. Firstly, I truly believe that the opening scene with Capaldi's monologue in the TARDIS will in time go down as an all-time classic Doctor Who moment on its own. The Danny/Clara scenes are very reminiscent of the style of "Coupling" and I suspect for many your enjoyment or not of them may rely to a degree upon whether you liked that show. Personally I did so I didn't have a problem. In terms of the story, I loved the notion of a tale purely rooted in the Doctor doing some research, not trying to save a world. Why shouldn't he do research? a good Doctor is always seeking to learn more, surely? Likewise, the whole concept of the monster (or not) is a very typical Moffat trope, and by the same measure as earlier will appeal more if you like Moffat tropes. Personally I do, I think much of the most frightening material is derived from fears that we know ourselves. I also felt that the 'moral' at the end, Clara's speech to the scared young Doctor, was very moving and truly beautiful - a love letter to every child of whatever age telling us it's okay to be afraid. To those who feel Clara is being made too important in the Doctor's personal narrative, all I can say is look at Doctor Who's long history, the rich and diverse tapestry of writers, producers, actors and crew. All of them have shaped and moulded Doctor Who for their time and tastes. In any case if the next show runner doesn't like it, time, as we have seen over and again, can be rewritten :) I was all prepared coming in to be underwhelmed by "Listen"; too much hype telling me it was an instant classic before I'd even seen it. It had a huge amount to live up to. But today, for once, I feel able to hand out a rare 10/10 to all involved and say well done everyone!
4 weeks, 1 day ago on Rate & Discuss Listen
@YaelMoise I noted your earlier comments regarding the final scene Yael and I'm rather glad on coming back that I found this recent post of yours before replying since I see you are feeling more sanguine about the offending line.
It doesn't add much I guess, but I've watched Time Heist twice now, and regarding the line in question I felt FWIW that Capaldi was emphasising how much more exciting robbing a bank was than going on a mere 'date', in that it was a much more satisfying way to spend time. The wry expression on his face suggests to me a lighthearted attitude when saying such a line, and I honestly didn't think "ew does that mean he fancies her" at all. Capaldi comes across in interviews as an intelligent, thoughtful, mature man who is very aware of issues like this and I truly believe him when he says he wants "no Papa/Nicole" moments. As much as anything because he knows how controversial they might be.
I say that having watched a second time and paid particular attention to the moment in question following your comments last night. Thanks for raising it though - I think when we intelligently debate the meaning of moments like these, I feel we in a way actually pay tribute to the production team - because they think about stuff like this too :)
@simon delafield Well at least you voted with your feet, rather than watched it simply to moan about it. Fair play to you :)
@thepeterjoy It does feel a little weird without Matt when I hear it. But I prefer to see little things as further little kisses to the past... like the use of "Rose in Peril" from series one on the "Listen" trailer :)
1 month ago on Next Time: The Caretaker
How I'd LOVE a William Russell cameo. You can almost picture it: "Ah, I remember you... Chesterfield? Chesapeake? Chessene... no not Chessene that's ridiculous, she was a female Androgum... now where's my 500 year diary... it's a mistake to clutter your pockets, Chessington..."
@Thomas Thomas It would seem a bit of a waste without, wouldn't it? That is, assuming WR was available and well enough to do it. Let's hope :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling With that cynical entry point, I don't see how this episode can possibly be anything but depressing disappointment for you. Mind you, DW is a unique series in that it has some 'fans' who simply tune in order to find more things to moan about ;)
@Beasts_a_Snarling Now you're just looking for things to moan about. It's getting trivial.
@Beasts_a_Snarling There's a world of difference between 'some added brilliance' and 'perfect'. No balanced thinking Moffat fan would suggest he's perfect. Who suggested he was the 'god' anyway? ;)
@Beasts_a_Snarling Coal Hill School. As in where the whole series started in the first place. To many, many fans an iconic location and one I heard many say they wanted to see more of. Not one episode has actually been set in the school yet. A moment's flashback in Deep Breath. The opening scene of Into the Dalek. Doesn't appear at all in Robot if I remember... or Listen? Momentary glimpse in Time Heist. Not exactly flogging the horse there. Please try to understand that your idea of repetitive and boring is not necessarily shared by everyone, nor should you expect it to be.
@Beasts_a_Snarling Empty imagination? Ouch. And how many stunningly original works of literature have you produced, that you sneer down on Gareth Roberts's deficiencies?
@Beasts_a_Snarling And there again I agree. I really like Listen, but I might have liked it even more had I not had the world and his WOTAN screaming "it's a classic!" at me before it even aired ;)
@Beasts_a_Snarling Now here's something we agree on 100% :D
@Beasts_a_Snarling No, you're frustrated because people aren't simply agreeing with you the way you want. Why can't you just accept and respect that? It makes you sound about 14. Yes, Tomb of the Cybermen is a classic story. Why should the Cybermen dominate every story they're in? You might love them, but for others such as myself I think they're over-rated and a bit rubbish. The last great story they had in my book was The Invasion - six years before I was even born :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling Why? By whose law?
@Beasts_a_Snarling Yes, let's go back to endless quarries pretending to be Queeglezog 7, cos we haven't nearly enough of those over the years :P
@Beasts_a_Snarling Whereas many would say the Pertwee era grew very repetitive and predictable. Surely Doctor Who should be a mix of all these things. It's not going to move away completely from Earth stories because that's the world people know and can identify with more easily. The production team aren't making it just for diehard fans with their set ideas and agendas, they're principally making it for the general public of all ages to enjoy on a Saturday evening.
@Beasts_a_Snarling I've not seen you put any context to it. All I'm reading are superficial and inaccurate generalisations.
@Beasts_a_Snarling You are wasting your time indeed, because you're generalising and pretending it's a powerful argument to cover the fact you just don't like modern Doctor Who. You might as well get with the program or watch something else, because they're sure as hell not going to change it exactly to the way you want it :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling I could point to many stories set away from Earth that are spectacularly generic and cliched. It's not where you are, it's how you do it. You're making crass generalisations again. The world is not black and white, my snarling beastie fellow fan :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling The Classic series had plenty of boring, repetitive episodes and companions it was hard to have much emotional investment in because they didn't exist apart from the Doctor. I have great affection for the Classic series, don't get me wrong I've been watching for 33 years, but to start suggesting it was some shining, perfect, cohesive monolith is frankly a load of old Daleks :)
@Beasts_a_Snarling By that reckoning why should anyone's story other than the Doctor's matter?
@Huknar Now you're just looking for things to pick at ;)