Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

Daleks are good because continuity is good.  There is a reason reoccuring villains exist, because it's nice to see a past threat who has a new plan.  That's why The Master during 3rd's era was one of my favorites because he was someone the Doctor had to keep foiling his plans and there's something exciting about seeing something familiar.  That's why to me a Dalek episodes once per series is not a bad idea at all.  I mean if 90% of the series was returning or reusing monsters/villains then it wouldn't be so good, but Doctor Who tends to have a good mix of new and old.  I hope they continue to have a Dalek episode every series.

1 week, 3 days ago on Moffat: Daleks Are Not A Contractual Obligation

Reply

@jay91lfc I don't understand why so many people are actually saying this.  The Doctor's clearly state in Day of the Doctor that until they decide they have come to an agreement they are okay with, no one in the room will remember whether they are human or zygon.  The fact that they are no longer in the black archive means they must of come to some arrangement which means the Doctor's lifted the memory wipe from them.  There is absolutely no reason to believe that there are duplicates still walking around, I understand that people were a little underwhelmed by the ending of the Zygon story in Day of the Doctor, but if you actually pay attention to the storyline then it makes perfect sense what the conclusion was to that and that there was a resolution.

2 weeks ago on 12 Great Moments From Death in Heaven

Reply

I like Capaldi's Doctor and as much as I love Clara and think she's been a great companion I thinks he held Twelve back a lot.  She was great for Eleven because of the type of Doctor he was.  Kept him on his toes.  But Twelve seems to clash with her too much, I'd like to see him on some solo adventures or with someone with a personality similar to Osgood. (Man, that really hit me right in the feels, especially with the whole space and time for her pocket!)  But yeah there is a part of me that is really hoping that is it for Clara, at least for awhile, I'd like to see a stand alone Doctor adventure for Christmas similar to some of Tennant's adventures like Waters of Mars.  Then I'd like to see season 9 start with twelve meeting a new companion, someone who isn't relationshipy and flirty and stuff, one that is more geeky and sciency and in it for the adventure.

2 weeks, 2 days ago on Poll: Capaldi’s Doctor – Hit or Miss?

Reply

@robinbonicel @Timhogan @BrianHirsch Doesn't really change or effect the theory much.  I mean Missy was behind the whole thing.  She was the one that "discovered" a way to have the cyberman be able to convert corpses which means clearly she had access to their hive computer mind.  Could of easily put a fail safe in place so that if when she gave the controller to the Doctor for some reason let the cybermen attack her, there'd be a fail safe that protects her from dying. 

2 weeks, 2 days ago on Moffat on Finale Death, Master Future

Reply

@Rani Nose Because I was referring to her at a time when she was a he.

2 weeks, 2 days ago on Moffat on Finale Death, Master Future

Reply

@BrianHirsch It's obvious she's alive, but not so obvious as to why quite yet.  The Doctor may not have realized it himself, maybe he suspected from the colour like yourself, but maybe he wasn't the one behind it.  The Master is not a fool, she had to realize that it was possible the device may be used against her, like in Last of the Time Lords when The Doctor tried to use the laser screwdriver on him(her? I'm confused which pronoun to use at this point).  Perhaps the Master had the settings/device preset to teleport herself if ever used against her.  Could also be a loophole to bring Osgood back if they feel like going the normal route and not letting anyone important on the show die, just have it so the device was never actually killing anyone, just transporting them into some predetermined place by the Master or her TARDIS.

2 weeks, 2 days ago on Moffat on Finale Death, Master Future

Reply

I feel like people are way over thinking this.  I think it's entirely possible that Time Lords can control their regeneration.  Now I know what a lot of people say to that, "The Doctor always seems surprised," well the Doctor also didn't do very well in the Time Lord academy.  It is entirely possible that the Doctor just never learned to control it before he stole his TARDIS and left.  As for the Master's regeneration, the onscreen regeneration that we saw seemed to indicate that the Master did have a bit more control in the fact that he wished to regenerate into someone younger like the Doctor and did.  While the Doctor's regenerations seem to be a bit more instinctive and random other's that we've seen tend to not be.  Romana for example who was top of her classes and even made fun of the Doctor at first for not piloting the TARDIS popular could regenerate at will to any appearance she wants.  So I think at the end of the day regeneration is something that a Time Lord could learn to control, however not all of them do.  As for the gender swap I think it entirely depends on the Time Lord and their personality.  If the Doctor was to regenerate into a female I do not think it'd work at all because the Doctor through all 12 incarnations so far, while different, have all kept the father figure protective underlining personality.  The Master on the other hand, it does make sense as his regeneration to a female could easily be because The Master thought it'd be a great way to throw the Doctor off.

2 weeks, 4 days ago on Gender-Swapping Regenerations: Why Now?

Reply

@calliarcale @Timhogan Well yeah but it's not just an everyday interaction.  I mean it may of started that way but then when she called the Doctor and the Doctor questioned her about it not just in Bell of Saint John but again in Deep Breath.  I mean I could understand at the time not recognizing her or remember exactly what she looked like, but once seeing her face again I would imagine that would be the, "Oh wait! That's her! That's the girl from the shop!"


3 weeks ago on What Further Secrets do Missy & Seb Hide?

Reply

Ya know something that's been bugging me the last few days, if Missy was the woman in the shop, why did Clara not recognize her right away?  I mean the Doctor in Deep Breath already made a big deal about who she was, and she's the one who gave her the Doctor's number so you'd think she'd stand out in Clara's memory and upon seeing Missy, if she was in fact the woman in the shop, she should of recognized her right away.

3 weeks ago on What Further Secrets do Missy & Seb Hide?

Reply

Ya know I'm kind of torn.  I know people are upset about the change of an iconic character (isn't that what this show is based off of though?)  For now I'm reserving judgement for how it plays out but going back and re watching the Missy scenes with full knowledge of who she is does make me nod in agreement that is definitely the Master.  Her composure and demeanor is pretty much spot on plus the things she says and does strike me as exactly how the Master would act.  As for the woman thing, I could also get behind the idea because she could of easily chose to regenerate into a girl (even on a subconscious level) just to avoid detection and to throw the Doctor off.  I mean the whole conversation when they first run into each other where she pretends to be a robot is perfect for the Master in my opinion.

3 weeks, 2 days ago on Poll: The Missy Reveal

Reply

Matt Smith's acting against himself as good and evil alone puts this easily in the top 5 favorites of New Who for me.  The story line itself may not be the greatest, but just seeing Doctor and Cyber Doctor play chess is worth it to me.

4 weeks, 1 day ago on Why I Love… Nightmare in Silver

Reply

So random sleep deprived thought:  I think they made it seem with the whole Missy thing saying she chose well with Clara that she is the woman from the shop.  But a small part of me for some reason played with the idea, what if somehow Missy is the TARDIS.  I mean the TARDIS was already pulled out and put in a body once with Idris, not hard to believe that someone else could do it, and what if somehow she gets some sort of ability to use something like a transmat on people in their moment of death around the Doctor.  Just a not very well thought out idea that I'd throw out there.  It'd explain a lot with how she could relocate people, how she could constantly be able to watch the Doctor and Clara, and the way she speaks like the Doctor is her love.

1 month, 1 week ago on Rate & Discuss Flatline

Reply

@Scootersfood has 66 Seconds to live... @Andrew_Swallow On top of that I don't think the cylinder look is the default look, but more of a storage shape for the Time Lords.  After all the outer dimension is to disguise the inner dimension and as the Doctor said if the TARDIS was ever to actually land on earth it'd crack the surface so I'd imagine if there is a "default" or original shape then it is probably very very very large, not the cylinder's we saw in the scene with Clara and the First.

1 month, 1 week ago on Rate & Discuss Flatline

Reply

I find most people that call it "Clara Who" are fans that started with Matt Smith's Doctor and are just upset his era is over.  I mean they weren't saying "Amy Who" during things like Amy's Choice and Girl Who Waited.  I actually prefer it when the companion is more active, if it's just someone that is there to be saved like Rose was at first then what is even the point of having a companion (or lets not forget they were originally called Assistants which job description is to assist!)  Realistically I'd like to see a companion that gets even more in depth and involved with the assisting part, especially with the personality of the current Doctor.  I still think someone like Osgood would be brilliant for the Doctor.   A bit like Jack from the first series where he understands more than the average person.  I like it when the Doctor gives the assistant the screwdriver and they know what to do, because it makes sense that after traveling alongside him for so long they pick it up.  Like when Martha had to use it in the Lazarus Experiment episode.  To me that's just good character development and storytelling, the show would be quite boring if it's just someone there to get captured or get in trouble and have the Doctor bail them out.

1 month, 1 week ago on ‘Doctor Who’ or ‘Clara Who?’

Reply

I do agree that The Long Song easily has the greatest emotional impact of all the lyrical songs.  I'm not a huge fan of Abigal's song though, I mean she's a great singer just not in my top 5.  Same with the Ood's song, I mean both were great just didn't blow me away.  I'd probably put Love Don't Roam second and keep Foxes 3rd because I love the jazz version of that song.  Song for 10 I also quite enjoy because it went along with choosing the Doctor's costume which is always a fun moment.

1 month, 1 week ago on Who Tunes: Ranking the Lyrical Songs of Doctor Who

Reply

Wonder if someone can throw up a poll on whether people think the Doctor actually saved everyone, or if that was just a cover.  I'm personally thinking the Doctor did do that as just a cover to hide the fact that he only saved Clara and Perkins I think was his name.


1 month, 2 weeks ago on Mummy on the Orient Express Review

Reply

@Polyphase Agreed.  I think the whole Clara thing was more a boiling point, since he regenerated Clara has been pulling further away and getting more annoyed with each episode and this was just a breaking point.  It was more that she was looking for a reason to get upset rather than this actually being something that upset her.  That's why during the conversation with Danny he said "It happened didn't it?" suggesting that they had previously discussed how she's unhappy with how things have been with the Doctor lately.

1 month, 2 weeks ago on Kill the Moon: Clara or the Doctor?

Reply

@Exalos I had a couple of the same concerns at first but after thinking more about it I found some answers.  First you're right that without the moon there'd be extra effects but either way the moon was going to be gone.  It was either blow it up with nuclear weapons, or it'd crack open and a creature that could or could not of attacked the planet.  That was the choice, so either way the effects of a missing moon would of hit them so that wasn't really a factor in the decision, it was more a decision of whether to trust the new born creature or not.  As for it laying an egg right away, that's not that surprising.  There's been weirder stuff in science fiction and it's not completely out there to imagine that part of this creatures life cycle is to lay an egg upon birth.  As for the decision to leave by Clara, that one had me for awhile.  As I agreed this didn't seem like that big of a deal and the Doctor seemed more right than Clara in his argument.  However it's the conversation with Danny after that clued me in, he said "Did it happen?" or "Did it finally happen?" something along those lines.  Which leads me to believe this was not a sudden thing, that ever since his regeneration I think Clara has been pulling away and from the context it sounds like Clara and Danny had discussed the possibility of her leaving before.  So this might of been the final tipping point despite her mostly being wrong on the issue. 

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Kill the Moon

Reply

@Romanadvoratrelundar Never really paid attention to how it works, but does the BARB ratings factor in people that DVR it too?  I know lots of people that sometimes miss it due to something like work and end up having to record it and watch it later.

2 months ago on Doctor Who Series 8 UK Ratings Accumulator

Reply

Maybe I'm missing something here, but I thought the time lock was only on the period during the Time War?  And even that was shown to be breakable in Day of the Doctor so it doesn't seam too unreasonable to believe that somehow they were able to break though to the Doctor's past given the situation.


2 months, 1 week ago on Listen: Breaking the Time Lock?

Reply

“I have been alive a very long time, and I have yet to meet a ghost or a god that didn’t turn out to be… I don’t know, sentient gas? Or technology masquerading as magic? This is no demon. Or ghost. Or curse. And I will show you it.”   -  What about Satan Pit?  I'm pretty sure they didn't explain him to be sentient gas or technology masquerading as magic.


2 months, 1 week ago on Tantalising Details on Episodes 5-8 of Series 8

Reply

Perhaps it was one of the Silence, after all, they seem to be masters of hiding.

2 months, 1 week ago on Poll: Listen – Was there a Monster or not?

Reply

@social_crime @Mythel452 Pretty much, if anything it was more of a reassurance.  I mean clearly if he was outside crying because he didn't want to be a soldier he already had those views.  The speech Clara gave him was more just comforting him and saying it's okay to feel the way he does.  I wouldn't label that as creating him because I'm sure plenty of people reassured him throughout his life.  I saw that scene as nothing more than just someone trying to make a crying boy (that happened to be the Doctor) feel better.

2 months, 1 week ago on Rate & Discuss Listen

Reply

I really want a nerdy sciencey type companion.  Osgood from UNIT is pretty much exactly the person I'd want with this kind of Doctor and I think it'd work out very well.  Someone who instead of walking into the TARDIS and being startled and bewildered and saying "It's bigger on the inside?!" Have someone walk in and say something like, "Ohhh WOW amazing!  What, is it some sort of secondary dimension disguised in a blue box?" And the Doctor himself be a bit baffled having expecting the usual bigger on the inside comment.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on Taking a ‘Journey’ Into the Future: The Next Companion

Reply

Man I started off on the other side of the fence with this episode mostly because I had a delusional hope that Tom Riley being cast as Leo Da Vinci would of been pretty awesome not as a cross over, just a nod to the other show.  But seeing him as Robin Hood is pretty amazing so I have a feeling I'm going to love this episode. 

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Robot of Sherwood Clips

Reply

Ya know kind of irrelevant to this and somewhat spoilerish(well they are rumors/wondering  not really fact) but with the rumors that Jenna might leave at the end of this season and the BBC synopsis's and people thinking something bad may happen to Clara and the whole Missy thing and everything (Wow that sentence got away from me) I'm wondering if Clara will "die" and go to "heaven" with Missy which will cause the confrontation between Missy and The Doctor.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Robot of Sherwood Pics

Reply

@CooperKing Agreed.  Eccleston was serious but kind of goofy.  Tennant was fiery with a goofy side.  And Smith was mostly goofy with a slight arrogance that made him have some awesome moments.  But now Capaldi has went a complete 180, if he is goofy, it's in that awkward sort of way.  Like while everyone is screaming flying down the tube into the human in this past episode, the Doctor is going "wwweeee." But mostly he's serious, he's direct, he doesn't get distracted.  Walks with a sense of "control" for lack of a better word.  Still 2 episodes in, one of my favorite parts about Capaldi's Doctor is how casually he flies the TARDIS.  No "HOLD ON" *flings the switch and camera starts shaking.*  It's just a nonchalant stride to the console, flips the lever and they are off. 

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Your Verdict on Deep Breath

Reply

I dunno I still prefer Capaldi myself.  While I love Smith and think he did a great job, his Doctor at some points had too many childish moments that were over the top.  I really dig how Capaldi is very serious, using people's deaths to his advantage and not giving it a second though.  I like how casual he struts around the TARDIS as well as his posture most of the time.  Maybe it's just that Capaldi is new and totally different that's making me think that, but I'm just loving it.  Easily the most impressed I've been with the first two episodes of a series in a long time.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Your Verdict on Deep Breath

Reply

I'm really liking this change.  It's the small things that do it to me, how casually Capaldi flies the TARDIS is one of my favorite parts.  I mean the last few Doctors stumble around like the TARDIS is crashing but it makes sense for the younger Doctor.  Like the kid who takes his dads car out and drives insanely reckless.  I really am liking how age seems to affect him, the chair in the first episode.  The way his posture is while walking around the TARDIS and the clean flying.   Also something I like is his speech patterns which slightly remind me of Sherlock.  Like when he walked onto the ship with Clara for the first time and "introduced" gun girl and guy in charge who may of been her Uncle or something he thought up while bored.  Just struck me as a very Sherlock-y thing to say.  Overall I thought the episode itself was pretty decent, I liked the Doctor and Clara's dialogue again.  Still not the greatest Dalek story, but then again they gotta be running pretty dry on stories to tell about the Daleks.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Into the Dalek

Reply

I am extremely torn on this.  On the one hand I really liked Eleventh Hour's story a lot better, I think it flowed a bit better and had a better bad guy/solution imo.  Not to mention the whole "Is this world protected?" speech was pretty brilliant.  On the other hand Capaldi was amazing.  Rewatching it on my DVR I notice so many subtle things that just make me already in love with the 12th Doctor.  The way he casually flips the lever on the TARDIS control panel to bring Clara "home" and then does the quick spin and flips the jacket back and puts his hands in his pockets.  That moment right there just made go, "Yes sir, he is most definitely the Doctor." And a different one at that.  I think I'm going to fully enjoy Capaldi and I hope he stays on for at least the standard 3 series.

2 months, 4 weeks ago on Face-Off: The Eleventh Hour vs Deep Breath

Reply

Honestly Jenny's outfit while she was "posing" was more surprising to me than the kiss.  I mean the kiss made sense, especially with the story.  I mean her race has bigger lungs so she shared some air with someone she cared about.  It's not like the music turned on "Bow chica-bow-wow" and they started undressing while making out or something, I think there's just way too overly-sensitive people on the subject these days.

3 months ago on Addressing the Deep Breath Kiss

Reply

@TheIdleIdol Still, at least those Daleks weren't real Daleks.  I mean even their own objects wouldn't recognize them as Daleks anymore, they were so watered down by all the spare parts they had to build each other off of so it made sense they were acting a little human in being undercover.  The entire parliament of Daleks begging the Doctor to save them is just horrible.  I just never understood why they couldn't go down.  Nano field won't turn a Dalek into a Dalek, that'd be redundant.  Then even if they were insane, not very likely they are going to attack another Dalek seeing as they were surrounded by other Daleks.  The entire storyline of the Daleks needing the Doctor to go down because they were afraid was just a disgrace to everything that is Dalek.

3 months ago on Next Time: Into The Dalek

Reply

@The Finn @Exxilon5 @supermoff Well, as long as they aren't screaming "SAVE US DOCTOR," then it at least won't be as much of a letdown than last series Dalek episode.

3 months ago on Next Time: Into The Dalek

Reply

I would say it seems like Missy is going to turn out to be the girl from the shop and the person who placed the ad but at the same time I feel like Moffat likes to play those red haring games so there's probably a much grander yet simpler explanation.

3 months ago on 12 Great Moments From Deep Breath

Reply

I thought it was a good scene, I like when they acknowledge the past.  That was something that irked me a teeny tiny bit about Eleventh Hour until the very end where he does the "Is this planet defended?" scene.  But I loved all the subtle kicks to the past, one of my favorites was, "Times like this I miss Amy."  "Who?"  "Nothing!"

3 months ago on Moffat on THAT Deep Breath Cameo

Reply

Definitely some good parts, I almost couldn't believe when he said, "It's times like this I miss Amy."  I had to chuckle.  Very well written stuff for the new Doctor, can't wait to see how Capaldi turns out.  Only down side is I wasn't a huge fan of Vastra and Jenny in this episode for some reason.  Either they've been used too much or their scenes just felt forced, something about it just didn't sit well.  The Clara and Doctor scenes were brilliant.  And the Doctor pouring a drink for him at the end was just a fantastic sequence.  Exactly what I was hoping for with his Doctor, someone who is willing to do what it takes to get the job done, whatever that may be.

3 months ago on Rate & Discuss Deep Breath

Reply

@stargazer0118 Very true.  I mean even if they use the fact that it's 9's first story that we see, then technically wouldn't Day of the Doctor be on the list somewhere?  I mean the War Doctor was a doctor and that was his first story we see post-regeneration!  Why doesn't the War Doctor ever get any love on these Doctor lists?!

3 months ago on Top Post-Regeneration Stories (5-1)

Reply

I agree with her, it's more exciting not knowing.  Personally I wish they could somehow not announce even the Doctors leaving until we actually see it, but I realize there is no way to stop those leaks.  As to whether she should leave or not, well, can't really judge that for now.  I really like her as an actress and companion, but who knows where the story will go!  Perhaps it will be time for her to exit.

3 months ago on Coleman on Exit Rumours: “I don’t want to tell you the truth”

Reply

People accuse him of killing off characters?  Who has he even really killed? I agree with him more when he says he doesn't kill nearly enough people.  Granted my favorite fiction tends to come from people like Joss Whedon who is known for actually killing people, but still.  Every time Moffat "kills" people in Doctor Who, it either doesn't seem to stick (Like Rory Pond for example) or it has some lasting happy ending (Like River Song getting to live in a computer or the Ponds getting to live to old age just separated from the Doctor, not killed.)  I mean he killed off Solomon which was the only one I actually count and think it was a really great moment in Doctor Who.  Not saying it's Moffat alone either, RTD didn't kill people too often too and if he did, it wasn't really someone important.  I realize it's a kids show and showing death to kids is a bad thing these days or something, but we definitely need an modern Who Adric.  Someone who actually matters to the show, having a sudden and tragic death.  Death in fiction is important because then when there is danger, it actually has some sort of excitement rather than, "Well we know they will get out of this somehow." 


3 months ago on Moffat on Death: “There are dark times ahead”

Reply

Hmm we need a Video Editing-savvy Whovian to string all these together tomorrow when we get the final teaser!!  Also nice to see the Psychic paper make an appearance, I feel like 11 only used it like twice.  Only times I can think of is Vampires in Venice and Nightmare in Silver.  Maybe in Night Terrors, but I can't remember for sure if he did or not.

3 months ago on Series 8: 2 Days Teaser

Reply

Too early to tell if this is good for the story or not.  It will be sad because I like Clara, but who knows where the story will be after Series 8 so it might be time by then.

3 months, 1 week ago on Jenna Coleman Leaving at Christmas?

Reply

Well I know they used the reason of Sherlock being a fictional character in the Doctor Who world like he is in ours, but I always thought it'd be pretty interesting if instead of him going back and Cumberbatch playing Sherlock Holmes, he played a young Arthur Conan Doyle.  He'd just have to grow a mustache!  Though one of my favorite parts of the Snowmen episode was when the Doctor did his little Sherlock bit and they used the music and everything.  But yeah I feel like a full blown real crossover as much as I like both shows would not really work well for either.  I mean Sherlock is based on a very realistic world, can't really have a TARDIS showing up wouldn't be very logical.  And as stated before in the Doctor's world Sherlock's just a character from a book so it'd be weird if he's suddenly walking around.

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Moffat Would Do ‘Wholock’

Reply

I mean I do sort of agree I feel like the story did kind of reach a conclusion with the whole End of Time thing.  But at the same time it wouldn't be hard to make him an enemy again with a new story.  I still think that when it gets near the time of Gallifrey to actually return the Master pops up trying to stop the Doctor thinking now he's the hero trying to stop the Doctor from making a terrible decision of bringing them back.

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Moffat on Why the Master Won’t Be Back

Reply

I hope Clara comes back for the 9th series as well.  As well as another addition or two, just hopefully not "love interests" for either.  They've assured us that the Doctor won't be all lovey and flirty, but I'm still hoping this Danny Pink fellow isn't a love interest of Clara.  We don't need another Mickey/Rory!

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Capaldi Signed Up For Doctor Who Series 9?

Reply

@The Administrator @JackArtaganMackenna But as we know time is very wibbly.  It reminds me of the Matrix when the Oracle tells Neo "What's really going to bake your noodle later is would you still have broken the vase if I hadn't said anything?"  Kind of the same thing here.  Perhaps the whole reason Nine was drawn to Rose in the first place is a distant piece of lingering memory from the War Doctor remembered the Moment and felt a sense of similarity.  I mean Nine was fresh off killing his entire race (or so he thought) and very brooding and also had a very low opinion of the "stupid apes" of humans.  So perhaps the whole reason he decided to take Rose with him was subconsciously he felt a sense of familiarity!!

3 months, 3 weeks ago on Capaldi’s Familiar Face Addressed in a Low-key Way

Reply

@ChrisMcMillan @Timhogan @Malohkeh It kind of would.  I mean The Doctor is never that accurate with precise moments, it'd be way too risky in the off chance he happens to miss it by a couple seconds, causing a gap in the time-line allowing the Daleks to move in and destroy Trenzalore which would undo the future regenerations the Doctor gets, not to mention two of the same TARDIS trying to land at the exact same moment at the exact same time at the exact same place is something that we've learned is a big no-no in Doctor Who, otherwise bad things tend to happen.  If the 14th Doctor wanted to enlist the help of his past selves, why would he choose a moment that is so dangerous that the slightest miscalculation could cause the universe to explode, when he could just as easily choose a point that has absolutely no danger what so ever.

3 months, 3 weeks ago on The Future of Multi-Doctor Stories

Reply

@microbat98 I don't know if you could really count Clara either.  Because yeah she showed up in Asylum which was a surprised, but we knew at that point she was the new companion and that was put in place as a set up for Clara's companion story, whereas Amy and Martha played 2 entirely different characters.

3 months, 3 weeks ago on Capaldi’s Familiar Face Addressed in a Low-key Way

Reply

@Malohkeh @Timhogan Well it's not really a question of him remembering it, that's not the problem.  Even if he was gone for only a minute, that breaks the stalemate he had for the entire time he was on Trenzalore.  That's the problem.  It'd make much more sense to pick a time when the Eleventh was off traveling all over the place on off-screen adventures like we knew he was doing before Trenzalore.  Like how Tennant in Day of the Doctor came from the time he was traveling before End of Time.  There's plenty of moments they could choose from and do the standard memory wipe when the time-lines corrected themselves.  I just think taking an aged Eleven from Trenzalore would cause much more of the "plot holes" they are trying to avoid than if they took Tweed Matt and Amy during their off-screen adventures.  Or even Clara and The Doctor because it also seems like they may of had some off-screen adventures as well.  I think the main reason for the Trenzalore idea is to explain any aging shown by Smith, but again, in 9 years from now I doubt he's going to look like an old man.  He'll only be what, 40 years old?  He also doesn't seem the type that's going to age poorly, he'll probably be like McGann and while looking a bit older, won't be hard for him to throw back on the Tweed and a wig (if necessary) to look like his old self.

3 months, 3 weeks ago on The Future of Multi-Doctor Stories

Reply

I take your point but I don't really agree with this personally.  From what I gathered during the time jumps of Time of the Doctor, he remained on Trenzalore the entire time.  For one, his TARDIS wasn't there (which I like to use as an explanation for the aging because the Doctor tends not to show any age unless he's separated from his TARDIS, even when the master blasts Tennant.  5 in Time Crash could be explained because he's in a different version of his TARDIS, and from Time of the Doctor it showed Hartnell's Doctor stole the TARDIS already aged which is why he was so close to his old age regeneration.) and back to Trenzalore.  Reason number 2 would be that even if say the 14th Doctor was to show up and get 11 to come into his TARDIS, then that'd break the stalemate that the Doctor had with the Daleks his entire time on Trenzalore which would hurt the continuity way too much.  I mean it's only 9 years from now, Smith is fairly young, I doubt he's going to age poorly either.  I'd much rather see a version of The Doctor with Amelia from all the random adventures they went on off screen that we didn't see.

3 months, 3 weeks ago on The Future of Multi-Doctor Stories

Reply

15 years of excellence.  Now the only thing they need is the license for new who Doctors!  

4 months ago on Happy Birthday, Big Finish! 15 Picks for 15 Years

Reply