Bio not provided
It would be interesting to see a multi-doctor style Movie. Kind of like the Avengers style, bring in as many Doctor's as you can and give it a proper 2 hour movie length to leave room to tell a story with a bunch of Doctor's! That way we wouldn't have to wait another 8 years for another one! :P
1 day, 8 hours ago on Lights, Camera, Action! Time to Embrace A Doctor Who Movie
Judging by the emails it appears we won't be getting a Doctor Who movie. Yeah Sony says they'd like to do it in an 8 year plan, but the BBC and Showrunners seem to be against it in each conversation. That implies that it won't happen, despite Sony's interest.
3 days, 16 hours ago on Leaked Sony Emails Reveals Doctor Who Movie Plans
My fear with the Sontarans is I don't want them to become even more of a joke after the whole Strax fiasco. If they were to bring them back, they'd have to be viscous brutal soldiers again, not a reel of over-played "ignorant of humanity" stuff that they throw at us every time the Paternoster Gang shows up.
5 days, 8 hours ago on 9 Foes That Are Due A Return
Eleven was amazing but they gave him too many childish silly moments. Which I get that he was created to draw more kids into the show, and some of the humor was pretty good. But when they gave Smith serious lines and speeches, he was amazing. Honestly if he got more chances to play his serious, old soul Doctor, rather than the overly hyper child of the Ponds, he would of been the best Doctor. But series 6 and especially the first half of series 7 just killed it.
5 days, 8 hours ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #3
The concept of destroying Davros before he has a chance to do anything is a bit too much re-writing of time. I know that's Moffat's go-to for plot points, but this one is too far. I mean if the Doctor was to take his life or stop him before he had a chance to become who he became, then it'd change so much of not only the Doctor's time line, but the entire universe that've dealt with Daleks. The Time War for example worked because yes they changed it from him destroying the Time Lords to saving them, but the gap inbetween the Time War and The Day of the Doctor could still play out exactly the same way (so the concept that time was never actually re-written, he just didn't know the real truth until the Eleventh experienced it.) But to even tease the idea of destroying/stopping Davros before he created the Daleks is just too much to re-write. I really hope this is just a BS story they are throwing out there to get readers going and not something that they are actually going to do.
5 days, 17 hours ago on Series 9 To Open With “Darkest ever plot”?
I was totally thrown off by that! I was expecting Smith vs Tennant right off the bat, but alas Hurt gets a shot! Does McGann get a shot since technically Night of the Doctor is a minisode for the revival? :P
6 days, 7 hours ago on Doctor of the Decade: Face-Off #2
The only way I think a Movie would work is if it was a prequel of some sorts. Like an 8th Doctor adventure to close some of the gap between the 95 movie and Night of the Doctor. Having two Doctors at once is a horrible idea and trying to convert the current show's story to a movie is also a horrible idea. While movie's are cool, they are not better than TV shows. The only other way is if they somehow made like the Christmas Special into an actual full length movie and put it in theaters, otherwise it's not worth trying to mix the mediums.
2 weeks ago on Capaldi: A Doctor Who Movie Would Be Great
Really? Night Terrors? What do people not like about that one? I thought it was pretty brilliant.
3 weeks, 3 days ago on The Bottom 10 TV Stories of the Decade
The Day of the Doctor will win because it's a multi-doctor story. It's not really fair, I mean the fact that it has two of the greatest Doctors doing scenes together alone makes it a masterpiece whether you like the story itself or not. Honestly I think the final should of come down to Blink vs Eleventh Hour. And I think Eleventh Hour could of beaten Blink!!
3 weeks, 5 days ago on Revival Face-Off: The Grand Final
Gotta say this series of polls have been some of the hardest decisions I can remember on this site!
1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: RTD Era Triple
Oh wow this is a tough choice. I think I'm going to have to go with the Orient Express because I just love Capaldi's performance in that one. 12 Really shines bright in that episode! Especially the ending where you really have to sit there and think, did he really save everyone or was that actually a clever cover? Great original monster too, it was very Doctor Who while being brand new at the same time. Easily one of my favorites, if not my most!
1 month ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #11
I find this quite easy. Eleventh Hour was a masterpiece. Pandorica was very anti-climactic for me. The Doctor had a good speech and a few cool moments, but I still am not a huge fan of the whole Doctor letting himself out of the Pandorica. Eleventh Hour is just perfect all around.
1 month, 1 week ago on Revival Face-Off: Round #6
Change is always scary but is also a good thing. Moffat has done a really amazing job with Matt Smith's Doctor and now Capaldi's, but I personally would like to see someone new take over with the next Doctor. A lot of Moffat's themes are beginning to be repetitive and recycled. I mean don't get me wrong, I still really enjoy the show, I just fear if he tries to go on for another 5 years or something the show may take a big hit in quality. Change is needed in this type of show to keep it surviving and keep it going, and it's getting about that time when we need another change. I liked RTD, I liked Moffat, but I'm curious to see what direction the next person can take the show in.
2 months ago on The Divide in New Who: One Era to Another
Interesting, is this a step closer to BBC licensing Big Finish with New Who Doctors? Lets hope so!
2 months, 1 week ago on Kate Stewart Returns in UNIT Extinction
Martha the highest companion? I can dig, she's always gets such hate because she had a crush on the Doctor and apparently feelings of any kind were forbidden before Amy. Not sure I agree with Elton being on it though. I'd almost rather of tried to squeeze in one of the spinoff characters on the technicality that they did show up in the 4th series!
2 months, 2 weeks ago on Top 12 Best Written Russell T Davies Characters
The only problem with it is the story. I mean if you do it as part of the main time line, you have to consider the time it takes to produce a full fledged movie as opposed to a Television episode. Doing something like stopping to film a movie, even just for a special event like a new Doctor, would slow the TV show down. It would make much longer gaps between seasons which isn't worth it. I mean comparing shows like Agents of Shield and Avengers to a potential Doctor Who movie is completely different because it's completely different casts, crews, and staff. To be able to intertwine the movie directly with the main story line of the show you'd have to have the same cast at the very least, which means the show can't do anything until the movie has fully wrapped.
Personally the only way I could get behind a movie is if it's a "prequel" to the show. Have RTD and a separate cast, crew, and budget put together a project with like McGann leading as the 8th Doctor on an adventure that bridges the gap of what we saw from the 95 movie to the Night of the Doctor. Hardcore fans would love it and it could essentially act as a starting point for new fans as the 8th Doctor's story is fairly blank. (I'm talking on the screen, I realize there's plenty of novels and Big Finish audio adventures) But if they started off introducing people to the 8th Doctor, it wouldn't hinder the show it'd more promote people to once they've seen it go home and watch the New Who series on Netflix while not overstepping on the show.
2 months, 3 weeks ago on Why A Doctor Who Movie Is A Good Idea
Is anyone else severely disappointed that Jack Harkness is not on this list? I mean did we all forget that he is a character of Moffat's or something, or is he really not good enough to make it above at least Father Octavian? Personally I'd put him towards the top, I'd say 12th Doctor is top of the list followed closely by 11th Doctor and then I'd put Captain Jack Harkness as 3rd followed by Amy Pond. Personally I'd put River Song a bit lower on the list too, I loved her character up until the point they revealed her as Amy and Rory's child and something just didn't sit right with me. The whole thing became much more creepy than it was before. But I've come to terms with that! But yeah the biggest thing to me about this article is where is Captain Jack?!
2 months, 3 weeks ago on The 12 Best Written Moffat Characters
If they do another companion I really hope it's a more science-friendly person like Osgood or a Liz Shaw type. Someone who could not just assist but understand things. I also wouldn't mind if it was a future companion ( I know everyone wants one from the past, but that's kind of boring, we've seen a lot of the past lately.) What we need is someone like Jack Harkness. Someone who will recognize technology like when Jack recognized the Extrapolator in Boom Town. Would lead to great dialogue between the trio on the TARDIS and would seem more like a team. I just don't want a Danny Pink or Rory or Mickey secondary companion, I mean I don't mind them having romance and emotion and love in the story, but it's been very much overused in the last 3 series so we need to get some of the sciency stuff back!
3 months, 3 weeks ago on 7 Things I’d Like to See in Series 9
@Planet of the Deaf I've always said this about scores, ratings, and reviews. I mean all they are, is someone else's opinion. One might agree or disagree with it, but still someone else's opinion. Not to mention I'm not a huge fan of "ratings" or ticket sales numbers either. Just because someone paid the price for the ticket sat down and watched it, doesn't mean they enjoyed it or that it was good. It just means they were interested enough to give it a shot. Realistically I think those numbers should be taken less seriously and they should pay more attention to the size of a show/movie's fanbase as well as whether or not the program is making money. Plenty of masterpieces have been cancelled due to low "ratings" while there are plenty of movies that look like they did well, but half the people that bought the tickets didn't enjoy the movie.
3 months, 3 weeks ago on Doctor Who Series 8 (2014) UK Ratings Accumulator
Ya know I was definitely on the team hoping she'd leave up until last night. The whole Danny Pink side-love story thing with her wasn't my favorite from series 8 and played a huge role in me wanting her to not come back. But after last night kind of pushed the move on from him thing I was pulled back to the hope she stays team and I'm glad she is now.
3 months, 3 weeks ago on Clara’s Fate & Series 9 (Spoilers)
@the666thdoctor I think that's true with everything, not just Doctor Who. I mean look at the overall ratings for all the time slots compared to last year. Less and less people are watching stuff live on TV and instead recording/downloading/streaming it at a later date.
3 months, 3 weeks ago on Christmas Day 2014 Ratings Top 10
@WiLfreduk The major difference is Robin Hood was based off a real legend, Agatha Christie and Charles Dickens are both real people. Sherlock Holmes is fictional. In the Doctor Who universe, Sherlock Holmes is a book. Now see what I've wanted to see is a different take on the "cross-over" and have the Doctor meet a young Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and have him played by Cumberbatch. But I don't think The Doctor meeting Sherlock would be a good idea or story at all.
4 months ago on Gatiss: I don’t see why people are so obsessed with ‘Wholock’
@Sharaz_Jek @Timhogan @S. Jek He may of went from young to old but he's still bringing a young person around trying to impress her. He may not be flustered or even notice her looks, but he still tries to impress her. And he still has the fatherly protective figure towards Clara, he does what it takes, even sacrificing random people to make sure she is safe. Despite what politics and extremists confusing people to think that "equality" means the "same", men and woman are different on a biological level. Different hormones create different personalities. Going from a young man to an older man is no where near on the same level of difference from going from testosterone to estrogen. It's simple biology. Even if you say it's a Time Lord and they clearly have different hormones and chemicals being produced by their body, there is still clearly a difference otherwise there wouldn't be Time Lords AND Time Lady's. On top of that the story strongly suggests Time Lords have the ability to control their regenerations (like Romana trying on faces or The Master choosing to go younger) It just suggests the Doctor was really bad at it (especially since Romana and other storylines made it clear the Doctor hadn't done well in his schooling). It also suggests that on a subconscious level the Doctor still has a say in who he becomes, (even why some fans think perhaps he has a scottish accent because his mind was dwelling heavy on Amelia Pond at the time of regenerating.) The dots are there in the story to connect for fans that can explain everything that's happened and why the Doctor in 2000 years hasn't gone female. It wouldn't make sense for him to suddenly switch over within the story. Which again to some fans, the story actually does matter.
4 months, 1 week ago on Poll: A Female Doctor
@S. Jek It would have to be story based because some Doctor Who fan's actually like it for its story? I mean the Master certainly had a story behind it, I'm not saying this is exactly how it happened but there are definitely dot's to connect. For 2000 years the Master and The Doctor have had a Love/Hate relationship and with their last meeting them walking that line it ended in a very confusing way to the Master. The regeneration easily could have been the Master's subconscious coming up with a way to mess with the Doctor by becoming a female. Also, "The Doctor didn't even react to the fact that the Master was suddenly a female." Did you not watch the same episode I watched? I mean go rewatch it and look at The Doctor's reaction to the whole thing. He is clueless who she is. Usually the Doctor know's right away who The Master is, once he realizes it's a Time Lord. After she finally tells him look at Capaldi's face. I mean he doesn't have to say it out loud, (especially since it ends on a cliffhanger which usually means little to no dialogue) but just look at his face. He is clearly pretty darn shocked. I just personally think as a fan of story in Doctor Who, I really hope they don't just do it because they want to be politically correct so look for the best female doctor for the role and then write a story around that. Usually the story comes before casting the new Doctor. I'm not saying there's not an actress out there that could probably perform in the role, I just don't see a story out there that makes sense for the Doctor suddenly switching to female.
I just don't think it'd fit the Doctor's personality. And yes, each Doctor is different and has their own personality but there are some major things in common through out all regenerations that would just not fit a female role. For example his male ego of picking up and trying to impress young woman. His over protective do-what-it-takes father figure attitude shouldn't be replaced either. And yes, I realize women can have ego's that want to impress young people and they can have an over protective motherly role, however it'd be too much a difference from the twelve we already had that it just wouldn't feel like the same person anymore, it'd feel like a reboot. It just would not fit the story at all, the only reason to make a female Doctor would be to "make a statement" which is one of the worst things a story can do. It compromises the integrity of the last 50+ years of the show and would just not fit. The Master fit perfectly because of his/her over all personality. Yes the Doctor has mentioned other instances where a Time Lord has switched, but referred to said Time Lord as a wild person so it stands to reason it fit within that Time Lords personality. I just don't think the Doctor would have any real reason story wise to be female, unless again, it was to make a statement. Which is a horrible idea.
I think realistically it is just people who miss their goofy lovable Matt Smith Doctor. in all honesty I think the show isn't dark enough yet. Series 8 was definitely a step in the right direction for that, but I personally hope they go much further with it. As much as I miss Osgood I'm glad someone important was killed and I hope it remains that way. Sure in the past people have died, but it's usually one off characters or unimportant characters (or characters that get sent back and time and get to live a full happy life together before dying of old age.) But series 8 has introduced a Doctor that doesn't seem to care as much about keeping people a live, and more about solving the problem and I really enjoy that and hope it continues down that path myself.
4 months, 1 week ago on Moffat on Criticisms that Doctor Who Is Too Dark
@ichabod @Timhogan Actually no, not at all. If you continue reading my post I went on to say that the Master is psychotic enough to use the ability to turn into a female to mess with the Doctor's head doing things like referring to him as her boyfriend and such. I didn't at any point say female's are psychotic. It was not a generalized comment but a specific one directed at the Master him/herself.
4 months, 1 week ago on Moffat: Gender is Fluid on Gallifrey
It has to fit the story in my opinion. Switching the Doctor to a female really doesn't seem to fit his personality, at least at the moment. If Moffat could come up with a good story and good reason for The Doctor to show up as a female, I don't mind it, but I'd hate to see something like that just to support feminists and not be sexist or some B.S. like that. The Master being female makes a lot of sense for the story. First off the Master has always been psychotic. Second she's had a very weird relationship with the Doctor over the years so it makes sense that she has an obsession for him. Ontop of that with their last meeting and how it went down he clearly had a messy friendship/respect/rivalry that could easily have left the Master with a warped mind and the small desire to become female to make it more of a relationship relationship but also to mess with the Doctor. I also stand by my theory about regeneration that most Time Lords can control their regeneration since you see people like The Master being able to control being younger or Romana "trying on faces." My theory is that the Doctor just never learned or was not good at controlling it in the academy (we know he clearly didn't do the best in the academy by comments Romana made.) So I think for the Doctor it has a lot to do with his surroundings and the current situations he's in, it's entirely believable that 12 got a scottish accent because he was thinking about Amy while regenerating. However I believe he has a strong subconscious of being a fatherly figure mixed with an ego that likes to impress people, specificaly young females. Therefore I think his subconscious should always keep him from regenerating into a female because while a female could still have an ego, it just wouldn't be the same type as the male ego trying to impress the female. And again Female's could be a mother figure, but mother figure's are also quite different, usually kind gentle and nurturing as opposed to the over protective doing what it takes to protect type thing. To me a female Doctor just doesn't make sense, political correctness and feminism and sexism has no place in a science fiction story. A story should only be changed by the story, not to make a statement.
I agree, story wise it wouldn't really make sense unless it was a multi-doctor story in the style of the 5 doctors and it was an earlier Donna traveling with 10. However I don't think it'd be the best idea to try to do something like that. The only Tennant companion that'd make sense is Martha Jones since she's the only one that's still running around in the right time line and universe fighting aliens and remembering the Doctor. An episode where The Doctor runs into Mickey and Martha could be a pretty fun episode in my opinion.
4 months, 3 weeks ago on Tate: Donna Return Unlikely
Daleks are good because continuity is good. There is a reason reoccuring villains exist, because it's nice to see a past threat who has a new plan. That's why The Master during 3rd's era was one of my favorites because he was someone the Doctor had to keep foiling his plans and there's something exciting about seeing something familiar. That's why to me a Dalek episodes once per series is not a bad idea at all. I mean if 90% of the series was returning or reusing monsters/villains then it wouldn't be so good, but Doctor Who tends to have a good mix of new and old. I hope they continue to have a Dalek episode every series.
5 months ago on Moffat: Daleks Are Not A Contractual Obligation
@jay91lfc I don't understand why so many people are actually saying this. The Doctor's clearly state in Day of the Doctor that until they decide they have come to an agreement they are okay with, no one in the room will remember whether they are human or zygon. The fact that they are no longer in the black archive means they must of come to some arrangement which means the Doctor's lifted the memory wipe from them. There is absolutely no reason to believe that there are duplicates still walking around, I understand that people were a little underwhelmed by the ending of the Zygon story in Day of the Doctor, but if you actually pay attention to the storyline then it makes perfect sense what the conclusion was to that and that there was a resolution.
5 months, 1 week ago on 12 Great Moments From Death in Heaven
I like Capaldi's Doctor and as much as I love Clara and think she's been a great companion I thinks he held Twelve back a lot. She was great for Eleven because of the type of Doctor he was. Kept him on his toes. But Twelve seems to clash with her too much, I'd like to see him on some solo adventures or with someone with a personality similar to Osgood. (Man, that really hit me right in the feels, especially with the whole space and time for her pocket!) But yeah there is a part of me that is really hoping that is it for Clara, at least for awhile, I'd like to see a stand alone Doctor adventure for Christmas similar to some of Tennant's adventures like Waters of Mars. Then I'd like to see season 9 start with twelve meeting a new companion, someone who isn't relationshipy and flirty and stuff, one that is more geeky and sciency and in it for the adventure.
5 months, 1 week ago on Poll: Capaldi’s Doctor – Hit or Miss?
@robinbonicel @Timhogan @BrianHirsch Doesn't really change or effect the theory much. I mean Missy was behind the whole thing. She was the one that "discovered" a way to have the cyberman be able to convert corpses which means clearly she had access to their hive computer mind. Could of easily put a fail safe in place so that if when she gave the controller to the Doctor for some reason let the cybermen attack her, there'd be a fail safe that protects her from dying.
5 months, 1 week ago on Moffat on Finale Death, Master Future
@Rani Nose Because I was referring to her at a time when she was a he.
@BrianHirsch It's obvious she's alive, but not so obvious as to why quite yet. The Doctor may not have realized it himself, maybe he suspected from the colour like yourself, but maybe he wasn't the one behind it. The Master is not a fool, she had to realize that it was possible the device may be used against her, like in Last of the Time Lords when The Doctor tried to use the laser screwdriver on him(her? I'm confused which pronoun to use at this point). Perhaps the Master had the settings/device preset to teleport herself if ever used against her. Could also be a loophole to bring Osgood back if they feel like going the normal route and not letting anyone important on the show die, just have it so the device was never actually killing anyone, just transporting them into some predetermined place by the Master or her TARDIS.
I feel like people are way over thinking this. I think it's entirely possible that Time Lords can control their regeneration. Now I know what a lot of people say to that, "The Doctor always seems surprised," well the Doctor also didn't do very well in the Time Lord academy. It is entirely possible that the Doctor just never learned to control it before he stole his TARDIS and left. As for the Master's regeneration, the onscreen regeneration that we saw seemed to indicate that the Master did have a bit more control in the fact that he wished to regenerate into someone younger like the Doctor and did. While the Doctor's regenerations seem to be a bit more instinctive and random other's that we've seen tend to not be. Romana for example who was top of her classes and even made fun of the Doctor at first for not piloting the TARDIS popular could regenerate at will to any appearance she wants. So I think at the end of the day regeneration is something that a Time Lord could learn to control, however not all of them do. As for the gender swap I think it entirely depends on the Time Lord and their personality. If the Doctor was to regenerate into a female I do not think it'd work at all because the Doctor through all 12 incarnations so far, while different, have all kept the father figure protective underlining personality. The Master on the other hand, it does make sense as his regeneration to a female could easily be because The Master thought it'd be a great way to throw the Doctor off.
5 months, 2 weeks ago on Gender-Swapping Regenerations: Why Now?
@calliarcale @Timhogan Well yeah but it's not just an everyday interaction. I mean it may of started that way but then when she called the Doctor and the Doctor questioned her about it not just in Bell of Saint John but again in Deep Breath. I mean I could understand at the time not recognizing her or remember exactly what she looked like, but once seeing her face again I would imagine that would be the, "Oh wait! That's her! That's the girl from the shop!"
5 months, 2 weeks ago on What Further Secrets do Missy & Seb Hide?
Ya know something that's been bugging me the last few days, if Missy was the woman in the shop, why did Clara not recognize her right away? I mean the Doctor in Deep Breath already made a big deal about who she was, and she's the one who gave her the Doctor's number so you'd think she'd stand out in Clara's memory and upon seeing Missy, if she was in fact the woman in the shop, she should of recognized her right away.
Ya know I'm kind of torn. I know people are upset about the change of an iconic character (isn't that what this show is based off of though?) For now I'm reserving judgement for how it plays out but going back and re watching the Missy scenes with full knowledge of who she is does make me nod in agreement that is definitely the Master. Her composure and demeanor is pretty much spot on plus the things she says and does strike me as exactly how the Master would act. As for the woman thing, I could also get behind the idea because she could of easily chose to regenerate into a girl (even on a subconscious level) just to avoid detection and to throw the Doctor off. I mean the whole conversation when they first run into each other where she pretends to be a robot is perfect for the Master in my opinion.
5 months, 2 weeks ago on Poll: The Missy Reveal
Matt Smith's acting against himself as good and evil alone puts this easily in the top 5 favorites of New Who for me. The story line itself may not be the greatest, but just seeing Doctor and Cyber Doctor play chess is worth it to me.
5 months, 3 weeks ago on Why I Love… Nightmare in Silver
So random sleep deprived thought: I think they made it seem with the whole Missy thing saying she chose well with Clara that she is the woman from the shop. But a small part of me for some reason played with the idea, what if somehow Missy is the TARDIS. I mean the TARDIS was already pulled out and put in a body once with Idris, not hard to believe that someone else could do it, and what if somehow she gets some sort of ability to use something like a transmat on people in their moment of death around the Doctor. Just a not very well thought out idea that I'd throw out there. It'd explain a lot with how she could relocate people, how she could constantly be able to watch the Doctor and Clara, and the way she speaks like the Doctor is her love.
6 months ago on Rate & Discuss Flatline
@Scootersfood has 66 Seconds to live... @Andrew_Swallow On top of that I don't think the cylinder look is the default look, but more of a storage shape for the Time Lords. After all the outer dimension is to disguise the inner dimension and as the Doctor said if the TARDIS was ever to actually land on earth it'd crack the surface so I'd imagine if there is a "default" or original shape then it is probably very very very large, not the cylinder's we saw in the scene with Clara and the First.
I find most people that call it "Clara Who" are fans that started with Matt Smith's Doctor and are just upset his era is over. I mean they weren't saying "Amy Who" during things like Amy's Choice and Girl Who Waited. I actually prefer it when the companion is more active, if it's just someone that is there to be saved like Rose was at first then what is even the point of having a companion (or lets not forget they were originally called Assistants which job description is to assist!) Realistically I'd like to see a companion that gets even more in depth and involved with the assisting part, especially with the personality of the current Doctor. I still think someone like Osgood would be brilliant for the Doctor. A bit like Jack from the first series where he understands more than the average person. I like it when the Doctor gives the assistant the screwdriver and they know what to do, because it makes sense that after traveling alongside him for so long they pick it up. Like when Martha had to use it in the Lazarus Experiment episode. To me that's just good character development and storytelling, the show would be quite boring if it's just someone there to get captured or get in trouble and have the Doctor bail them out.
6 months ago on ‘Doctor Who’ or ‘Clara Who?’
I do agree that The Long Song easily has the greatest emotional impact of all the lyrical songs. I'm not a huge fan of Abigal's song though, I mean she's a great singer just not in my top 5. Same with the Ood's song, I mean both were great just didn't blow me away. I'd probably put Love Don't Roam second and keep Foxes 3rd because I love the jazz version of that song. Song for 10 I also quite enjoy because it went along with choosing the Doctor's costume which is always a fun moment.
6 months, 1 week ago on Who Tunes: Ranking the Lyrical Songs of Doctor Who
Wonder if someone can throw up a poll on whether people think the Doctor actually saved everyone, or if that was just a cover. I'm personally thinking the Doctor did do that as just a cover to hide the fact that he only saved Clara and Perkins I think was his name.
6 months, 1 week ago on Mummy on the Orient Express Review
@Polyphase Agreed. I think the whole Clara thing was more a boiling point, since he regenerated Clara has been pulling further away and getting more annoyed with each episode and this was just a breaking point. It was more that she was looking for a reason to get upset rather than this actually being something that upset her. That's why during the conversation with Danny he said "It happened didn't it?" suggesting that they had previously discussed how she's unhappy with how things have been with the Doctor lately.
6 months, 2 weeks ago on Kill the Moon: Clara or the Doctor?
@Exalos I had a couple of the same concerns at first but after thinking more about it I found some answers. First you're right that without the moon there'd be extra effects but either way the moon was going to be gone. It was either blow it up with nuclear weapons, or it'd crack open and a creature that could or could not of attacked the planet. That was the choice, so either way the effects of a missing moon would of hit them so that wasn't really a factor in the decision, it was more a decision of whether to trust the new born creature or not. As for it laying an egg right away, that's not that surprising. There's been weirder stuff in science fiction and it's not completely out there to imagine that part of this creatures life cycle is to lay an egg upon birth. As for the decision to leave by Clara, that one had me for awhile. As I agreed this didn't seem like that big of a deal and the Doctor seemed more right than Clara in his argument. However it's the conversation with Danny after that clued me in, he said "Did it happen?" or "Did it finally happen?" something along those lines. Which leads me to believe this was not a sudden thing, that ever since his regeneration I think Clara has been pulling away and from the context it sounds like Clara and Danny had discussed the possibility of her leaving before. So this might of been the final tipping point despite her mostly being wrong on the issue.
6 months, 2 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Kill the Moon
@Romanadvoratrelundar Never really paid attention to how it works, but does the BARB ratings factor in people that DVR it too? I know lots of people that sometimes miss it due to something like work and end up having to record it and watch it later.
7 months ago on Doctor Who Series 8 (2014) UK Ratings Accumulator
Maybe I'm missing something here, but I thought the time lock was only on the period during the Time War? And even that was shown to be breakable in Day of the Doctor so it doesn't seam too unreasonable to believe that somehow they were able to break though to the Doctor's past given the situation.
7 months ago on Listen: Breaking the Time Lock?
“I have been alive a very long time, and I have yet to meet a ghost or a god that didn’t turn out to be… I don’t know, sentient gas? Or technology masquerading as magic? This is no demon. Or ghost. Or curse. And I will show you it.” - What about Satan Pit? I'm pretty sure they didn't explain him to be sentient gas or technology masquerading as magic.
7 months ago on Tantalising Details on Episodes 5-8 of Series 8