Sam in Cardiff
Bio not provided
@Whogasms knows THAT MISSY TELEPORTED, NOT DIED! Agreed. My first story with the Ice Warriors, and I absolutely loved it!
3 months ago on On Thin Ice: The Future of the Ice Warriors
@thebluetooth Cardiff Uni is great! Hope to see you there! (TCUPS Choir is great for music, though I'm yet to get them to do any of the Doctor Who choral arrangements...)
5 months, 1 week ago on The Day / Time of the Doctor Soundtrack
As brilliant as Dark Water was, I feel I'd be betraying my former 12 year old self if I didn't vote for Utopia. The Series 3 finale is still my favourite of the RTD finales, and whilst Gomez is great as The Master, I feel that Jacobi was robbed of a chance for a great role. I mean, come on. The Time War being fought by a young John Hurt and a young Derek Jacobi? Wow...
5 months, 2 weeks ago on Face-Off: Utopia vs Dark Water
@Dsjh @Sam in Cardiff It would have been nice to have a 'lesser' character to return (I even started considering Romana after the 'left me behind' line), but I'm willing to give it a chance. The only reason I can't give it 10/10 is because I feel I'd have written a different reveal of that moment, with a different outcome. Still doesn't detract from how good the episode was..
5 months, 2 weeks ago on Rate & Discuss Dark Water
@CharlieSamuelKay Sorry, but I'm not sure how Missy's reveal actually 'ruined' the character of The Master (Assuming of course that is what you are referring to). It's been established since The Doctor's Wife that regenerations don't stick along gender lines, and this gives us new avenues to explore a character (in a way which is only presented to us in a few characters, The Master being one of them)
9/10 from me. A decent episode, played brilliantly by all of the actors (special mentions to Michelle and Chris, the latter keeping me laughing and clapping through all his scenes). My only issue? The reveal at the end. It was done perfectly, but I feel it should have been someone else.
Had to go for Gaiman. Nye, Curtis, Mathieson and Harness were all great, but Gaiman was almost perfect. One of my favourite episodes of Matt's era..
5 months, 3 weeks ago on Face-Off: New Writer Debuts
@Meh Meh Meh Meh Meh is in the Secret Play! Shh! Maybe it's to do with the speed at which they enter the TARDIS. River and The Doctor were both falling, whereas in Journey, they were entering normally...
6 months, 3 weeks ago on WHOops! When Doctor Who Gets It Wrong
10/10. But I would say that just for Keeley Hawes. It was a great episode, and the addition of Keeley in the (quite good) guest cast just topped it off for me. Also, is it me or is Steven Moffat writing the Danny Pink moments?
7 months ago on Rate & Discuss Time Heist
I'm just happy to finally have a Keeley Hawes episode. I've had a huge crush on her since 2008, so it's about time I finally got my favourite actress in my favourite TV show! Next week cannot come soon enough!
7 months, 1 week ago on Next Time: Time Heist
Being a HUGE Keeley Hawes fan, Episode 5 looks like my dream episode, but the entire series looks great. Seems we were right about the Dalek episode being episode 2, and the CGI-less episode 4 looks interesting, particularly as the description makes it sound like Midnight.. Series finale looks good, especially if the rumours coming from filming are true, this looks like it's going to be a great series, possibly the best we've had. Ever.1 month to go!
9 months ago on SFX #251 Previews Series 8
@The Finn I'm sure there's likely to be a small celebration, but no big special, 'Day of the Doctor' was big because it had reason to be big.. Perhaps they'll get the 4 Doctors of the new era (or 5 if you count Hurt) for some big convention...
11 months ago on Smith Eager for Another Multi-Doctor Story
The only problem I see with this article is the reasoning behind the Daleks learning of The Doctor again in Time. It was explicitly said that they 'harvested' the information from Tasha Lem, so there may not necessarily have been many battles between The Doctor and the Daleks between Asylum and Time. Apart from that, the reasoning seems about right! Good job!
11 months, 3 weeks ago on Continuity of the Daleks
@Amy the Consulting Key Ring Neil Gaiman, Simon Nye, Richard Curtis, Neil Cross and Steven Thompson have all written episodes under Moffat but not RTD, all other Moffat writers have written under RTD aswell. I don't see your argument.
12 months ago on Peter Harness Writing for Series 8?
@Americanwhovian John Hurt? Richard E Grant? Derek Jacobi? Peter Capaldi? Oh well.. I don't think he'd be as good a Doctor, I always thought he'd be amusing to bring back as The Meddling Monk..
1 year ago on Cumberbatch Rules Out Doctor Who Role
A great actor, and truly excited for what he'll do, but as a diehard Keeley fan I'm disappointed that this now knocks her news story off the headline spot on Doctorwhotv! Roll on Series 8!
1 year ago on Ben Miller Cast as Series 8 Villain
@Me and Stuff @KingoftheOod4450 Precisely. I'd just have to think back to 10's regneration energy covering a similar, if not greater, distance during The Christmas Invasion. Or the similar looking energy from Idris at the end of The Doctor's Wife. Regeneration energy has been shown to 'pass through the sky' before in Doctor Who, there was nothing new there...
1 year ago on Why “Time” was the Perfect Summary of Smith’s Era
My voting poll seems to only go up to 10/10. Naturally this isn't enough for an episode like this. Are the admins able to add options for those of us who think it deserved more than 10/10?
1 year, 1 month ago on Best of Matt Smith: The Day of the Doctor
Sorry, couldn't resist
1 year, 1 month ago on Lego Doctor Who One Step Closer
EVERYTHING IS AWESOME!!
@EllieBanks 'Amy Pond waking up in the middle of giving birth? And later losing her child? And she is not the least bit traumatized?' You'll forgive me if I didn't bother reading the rest of your comment, as you clearly didn't bother watching Asylum of the Daleks, which clearly shows Amy being traumatised by the events of Series 6...
1 year, 1 month ago on Is Steven Moffat a Feminist Writer?
I wouldn't necessarily agree with all of these. I reckon 9 is far more heart-making than heart-breaking. The discovery of Gallifrey's survival, said by the one and only Tom Baker in such a way that it was hidden under our noses the whole episode. I wouldn't call it a heart-breaker, it's SO much more than that...
1 year, 2 months ago on 10 Most Heartbreaking New Who Moments
@smallaustralian I'm struggling to see where it 'makes light' of LGBT people. I also don't understand why this article must be judged according to the article that preceded it, it's unlikely that people are going to make a connection between the 'Spoiler Article' about the returning monster/villain in Series 8 and the immediately preceding article about the Troughton episodes, coming to the conclusion that Salamander will make a return.
1 year, 2 months ago on Honey, I’m a Whovian!
I've always thought the best episode (NuWho) to get someone into Doctor Who would be 'The Fires of Pompeii'. A good laugh, Donna's first proper trip in the TARDIS (meaning the viewer has the same experience) and answers the obvious question about using time travel very well. Throw in Davis and Capaldi and they'll be set. It's not a perfect episode, but that's not what you want to introduce people to Doctor Who. I think so many people had issues with The Time of The Doctor because The Day of The Doctor was so big, momentous (and perfect in my opinion). Show them a middling-to-good episode, then bring in Blink a few episodes later as an example of how good it can get..
I rewatched this episode in December and was absolutely convinced by it. I could almost imagine it as a classic H.G Wells or Iain Banks sci-fi novel. A brilliant idea, brilliantly executed.
Although, as with the original watch in 2010, I felt let down by the end, as it didn't really leave the Dream Lord open to a return. Which for a character I loved watching and imagining was a shame.
1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: Amy’s Choice
6/10A good episode on the whole, but when I came to rewatch Series 5 I noticed Matt Smith had a slight slump from Victory till about halfway through Flesh and Stone, so I can't mark it as highly as the previous 2 or how I intend to mark the rest of them. I appear to be in the minority who like the Paradigm Daleks though, shame really..
1 year, 2 months ago on Best of Matt Smith: Victory of the Daleks