Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

"a caretaker QB" Hey, at least we're beating caretakers now. Last week, one (Stanton) beat us. "Hey- there is a future for Eli in the West Coast Offense!" Like many UNYG readers, I can't help but wonder how much more competitive we could have been (at least in the non-championship years) if we'd switched to it years ago. Meanwhile, Jennings is a player. Remember, not a starter until last year, he's a young 29.



1 hour, 26 minutes ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/sept/nyg-30-hou-17.html

Reply

@jfoster Exactly, JFoster: Unleash those corners and start Washington over Randle.

1 week, 6 days ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/uncategorized/det-35-nyg-14.html

Reply

@ultimatenyg Re whether or not JPP shows up or not -- I kind of wish the Giants took a flyer on Michael Sam before the Cowboys did.

2 weeks, 5 days ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/predicting-the-giants-season-record-in-2014.html

Reply

Yeah, Nassib's eyes were roving the field. Super psyched about Andre Williams (please don't get injured, please don't get injured).

1 month, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/nyg-17-buffalo-13.html

Reply

@Arthuro Give Holliday the opportunity to fumble away his job. Eli has long been at a disadvantage to other QBs -- and this is seldom talked about when evaluating his play -- not just because of underperforming OL in recent years, but because kick returners gave him poor field position.

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/training-camp-begins.html

Reply

Hate to see Jernigan's talent wasted. He might be better off on another team. On another note, wonder whether UNYG readers agree that McAdoo is heir apparent to Coughlin (unless, of course, he f**ks up). 

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/training-camp-begins.html

Reply

"'3' of size is important in the NFL." 3″ of size is important to Eli Manning, who needs a tall receiver like few other QBs. Encouraged by Cosell's report, even if Beckham seems redundant with Giants already well-stocked with receivers his size who are quick (Cruz, Randle, Jernigan, Manningham).

4 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://ultimatenyg.com/2014-articles/odell-beckham-selected-in-round-1.html

Reply

@CommanderShepard @RussWellen1  Interesting idea, Commander. If worst comes to worst, I'd still watch the NFL, though, even if it became a flag-football league.

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Mark Cuban Echoes UltimateNYG

Reply

Makes me wonder if some of the owners and some in the league office fear head trauma will be the death of the NFL in a generation and they just want to milk it for all they can while it exists, like, say, the oil business.


Like the site's new blog format.

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Mark Cuban Echoes UltimateNYG

Reply

@Paddlepedal  Too bad we don't have the money to go after Desean Jackson, who's leaving the Eagles. Big sigh of relief, though, that we don't have to face Foles-to-Jackson in the future. 

6 months ago on DRC signs 5 yr Deal with the NY Giants

Reply

Eclipsed by DRC signing, Giants also signed sensational -- if somewhat fumbly -- kick returner Trindon Holliday. Imagine Eli starting close to mid-field on a regular basis?

6 months, 1 week ago on DRC signs 5 yr Deal with the NY Giants

Reply

Kenny Britt: too talented to pass up. Guys generally shape up when they come to a class organization like the Giants. Nicks may have been the only attitude problem they had in years.

6 months, 1 week ago on SLAM DUNK SUCCESS FOR GMEN THRU 2 DAYS OF FREE AGENCY

Reply

Happy to hear about Schwartz. Nice Jewish boys (who can play) always welcome on a metropolitan NY-area team. Meanwhile, if Giants find a center, will Boothe, if he stays, go back to utility man? As always in the past, he'd see a lot of time filling in for injured players (like Snee?). On another note, trying not to panic about losing Beason. Can't handle if it D goes back to playing like it did before Giants got him.

6 months, 1 week ago on Giants New Signings, Joseph Signs with Vikes

Reply

First, great point, dbs50, about Eli and no-huddle.

Re Sherman: People are disposed to be sympathetic to him because of his story: straight outa Compton to Stanford. Thus, they're especially disappointed.

Also bear in mind he plays the second-most high-pressure position besides QB. TDs and long pass completions can kill a cornerback's confidence. He's constantly trying to artificially pump his ego. On top of that, CB's have to deal with pass interference penalties, which only add insult to injury with their false assumption that every pass interfered with would be caught. 

Cornerback: they may be well compensated, but they put up with hell. 

8 months ago on Richard Sherman

Reply

Nice work as a media watchdog, Andy.

8 months, 2 weeks ago on 10 Years of Coziness with Kevin Gilbride

Reply

It's over. What do we do now that we won't have Gilbrown-Killdrive-Gilblight to kick around anymore?

8 months, 3 weeks ago on Gilbride Rumored to be Fired

Reply

As for Redskins interviewing Perry Fewell for head coach, that's more than just the obligatory minority interview 'cause they're also interviewing Jim Caldwell.

8 months, 3 weeks ago on Gilbride Rumored to be Fired

Reply

Re dbs50's comment, here's what Gary Myers reports:

“I think our offense is broken right now and we need to fix that and we need to make some improvements on defense, too,” Mara said. “But obviously the offensive side of the ball we’ve got to improve there and we can’t go into next season with the same personnel.”

Mara said he doesn’t think the situation would ever come to forcing change on Coughlin, but said Coughlin coming back with the same staff needs to be talked about.

“That’s obviously one of the main topics of discussion that we’re going to have at the end of the week, and until we have that, I don’t want to comment on it,” he said. “Certainly there are some changes that need to be made within the entire organization and whether that ends up being one of them or not, I’d rather wait until we have those discussions first.”

The Bucs fired head coach Greg Schiano on Monday, which means offensive coordinator Mike Sullivan, who spent 2004-11 on Coughlin’s staff, the last two as Eli Manning’s QB coach, could be a potential replacement for Gilbride. Coughlin is so loyal to Gilbride he might fire him only if he was absolutely forced to by Mara and Reese.




8 months, 3 weeks ago on NYG 20 WAS 6

Reply

Thanks for all your hard work during a difficult season, Andy. I'm sure there will be plenty of changes to chronicle in the off-season, too

8 months, 3 weeks ago on NYG 20 WAS 6

Reply

@ultimatenyg @frank43  Re: "I actually have more evidence of the 'telegraphing' than even I can share on this blog." Presumably you're afraid that someone like your Eagle-blogger friend will read it and disseminate it on his blog, where it might become common knowledge and Eagle coaches will pick up on it. 

8 months, 3 weeks ago on The Case for Replacing Kevin Gilbride with a new Offensive Coordinator

Reply

Looking ahead to next season, some positives:

• Strong defense. Especially loaded at safety, between Rolle and Hill, with Mundy as reserve and possible return of Stevie Brown. Of course, Rolle might leave.

• Sudden emergence of Jernigan, who had, until yesterday, struck me as the essence of mediocrity. Glimmerings of chemistry between him and Eli.

• The heart of an untalented O line. The extent to which they limited the damage of the vaunted Lions D line was nothing short of amazing.

9 months ago on NYG 23 DET 20 OT

Reply

dbs50 wrote: "How much of this offense is Coughlin's and how much of it is Gilbride's?" And, what I always wondered is: how much input does Eli have? Or is he comfortable with Gilbride because Gilbride, on his own or at Coughlin's behest, is disposed to the longer passing game that Eli (not to mention many QBs) might be partial to?

Re Gilbride: once again I bring up his son coaching the receivers, who have seriously underperformed (even Cruz isn't as dependable as usual). Can Giants at least consider replacing him?

9 months, 1 week ago on SEA 23 NYG 0

Reply

Re "changes are coming," more and more I'm seeing thoughts like this expressed (by Gary Myers today): "Kevin Gilbride’s antiquated offensive system, which relies too heavily on deep passes when the rest of the league is taking advantage of the hands-off rule by going to short passes and crossing routes."


Just need for that to go viral and Giants may feel pressure, as politicians do, to act.



9 months, 1 week ago on SEA 23 NYG 0

Reply

A couple of belated stray observations . . .


• More cause for optimism, Commander Shepard: Stevie Brown may be back. (Are Giants loaded at safety or what with Rolle, Hill, Brown, and even Mundy, not to mention hybrid cornerback-safety Thomas, who tackles like a safety?)


• For those of us fed up with Kevin Gilblight (sorry, couldn't resist), remember, the problem is compounded because there's two of them: his son is the receivers coach. Think about the receivers' problems this year -- maybe Gilblight junior is the greater part of the problem!



9 months, 2 weeks ago on Giants 24 Redskins 17

Reply

Once Fewell decided to use a four-man pass rush on that final drive, our fate was sealed. Such a helpless feeling sitting at home watching that, along with Gilbride failing to call for passes up the middle. 

9 months, 4 weeks ago on DAL 24 NYG 21

Reply

Re Jacobs: He may not have the explosiveness he had when young, but he's learned to keep low -- remember how upright he always ran? -- and, for the most part, plow straight ahead. Few runs around the end, where, with his poor balance, he could get tripped up by a finger, like an elephant at the mercy of a mouse. Outstanding complement to Brown, who, if he can remain uninjured, figures to be one of the great Giant backs, along with Barber, Hampton, Anderson, Morris,and Ron Johnson

10 months, 1 week ago on NYG 27 GB 13

Reply

Thanks, Rich. I've never before seen an array of images that illustrate so well the obstacles a good running back faces on a team that doesn't block well for him. Truly enlightening.

10 months, 1 week ago on Andre Brown Continues to Push Through Obstacles

Reply

Thank you, Steve. Theoretically, Brown's success on the ground should have opened up the passing lanes. But that doesn't work when the OL pass-blocks so poorly.

10 months, 1 week ago on Giants Third Straight Win Keeps Sliver of Hope Alive to remain on The Road to Metlife

Reply

Commander Shepard wrote:

"Philly may be a bigger threat than Dallas at this point."

Who among us, no matter how much we love Eli and are confident he'll round back into form (even if it's next year), isn't looking at Philly with a little envy over its hot young QB?


10 months, 2 weeks ago on NYG 24 OAK 20

Reply

Return of Andre Brown would go a long way to resolve Red Zone deficiency. He has that rare combination of strength and the ability to knife through defense that makes a good scorer. You can no longer count on power alone, as we know from Jacobs's struggles at goal line in years past, to cross the goal line. 

That said, as Peyton Hillis shows, there's still room for the old-fashioned straight-ahead, push-the-pile runner, a la Larry Csonka. His inability to catch on with a team earlier this year suggests GMs no longer think that model is viable. May not be able to score in Red Zone that way much anymore, but it moves the chains.


10 months, 4 weeks ago on NYG 15 PHI 7

Reply

Re Coughlin as a good, not great, coach . . . I've always wondered how good he is with the x's and o's. Would a head coach who was stay with a limited coordinator like Gilbride -- would it kill Coughlin to give him some suggestions? -- or hire an incompetent one like Sheridan? I'm aware of Coughlin's background as a receivers coach, so he must know something about the technical aspect of the game. But how much? Googling reveals nothing.

Rich H.: Thanks for the LT-Parcells story. Priceless!

11 months, 1 week ago on Making sense of 0-6

Reply

During the conservative Parcell years, whoever thought we'd be complaining about a mad-bomber offense. Watch out what you wish for, I guess. 

11 months, 2 weeks ago on When the Tide Goes Out

Reply

As an analytical, not statistical, observation, the D looks pretty good: they're just suffering from overuse syndrome.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on Backs to the Wall

Reply

Thank you, Tom Jackson. Eagles fans are lucky to have you.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on Q&A Exchange with Eagles Eye

Reply

Giants secondary got better when Ross left. Then it got better when he came back. Then it got even better when arguably top DB, Stevie Brown, went down. Typical for Giants: makes no sense whatsoever.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on Week 4 Loss Proves to be More of Same for Big Blue

Reply

At least they're building a strong foundation with the defense, which begins with stopping the run, at which the Giants have been outstanding. As far as enabling the run with blocking, it seems every other team's OL gets some push at least some of the time. As for pass blocking, I wish Reese could appreciate the artistry of, say, the Eagles LT Jason Peters, who presents pass rushers with a puzzle they seldom solve. We're stuck with Beatty, who needs to go in serious search of his lost mojo.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on KC 31 NYG 7

Reply

Arthuro wrote:

 "I'm pretty knew at football"

Talk about quick studies.

12 months ago on Snee, Beatty and Pugh Stand Out in Week 3 Disaster

Reply

Yes, Ross has been playing his man tight, as has Akumara. How'd the Steelers let Mundy get away? Weird that he seldom even started there.

12 months ago on Secondary Proves to be Bright Spot on Big Blue D

Reply

Smart guy like Blackburn maybe a future coach.

12 months ago on Chase Black-burned

Reply

Andy is laying off Gilbride, but his failure to adjust was frustrating. My kingdom for a screen. Or just some dink and dunk. 

Worst part was, even though Andy explained how poorly he's been playing, Beatty's implosion. Especially when his holding nullified TD (okay, it wouldn't have happened without the hold) by Wilson, arguably playing with more heart than anyone on the team. Don't know what's wrong with Beatty, though he mentioned struggling to shake off first sack he gave up yesterday. Hurt?

I was contrasting Giants OL with push the Jets OL were getting yesterday. When was the last time Giants OL drove a DL back on a run play? Run blocking a problem since 2008 when Brandon Jacobs and Derrick Ward each ran for 1,000 yards. Remember the holes the OL used to open up, and for Tiki before that? Oh, for those halcyon days of yore.

12 months ago on CAR 38 NYG 0

Reply

Easily the best Giants receiver ever. (Okay, VC is pretty good, too.) And I started watching Giants when they featured Del Shofner and then Homer Jones.

1 year ago on A Closer Look at Hakeem Nicks' Return to Form

Reply

Inability to run-block fouling up everything. Lack of screens, as Banks noted and Andy always does, doesn't help, and, as Andy has noted, Wilson needs to be thrown to in space. Feeling good about defense though despite late breakdown. Is it my imagination or does presence of Terrell Thomas on field change everything? Lest we get too pessimistic, you have only to watch Philly and Washington to see how weak their defenses are.

1 year ago on DEN 41 NYG 23

Reply

Re Nassib: Few teams enjoy one great QB succeeding another, like Rodgers and Favre. If Giants keep Nassib, I'd be happy if he's even a serviceable QB succeeding a great one in Eli. Also, t would also be pretty cool having an Arab QB. (I don't really know that, but it's possible he's of Lebanese descent. Google turns up nothing.)

1 year, 4 months ago on Round 3 recap

Reply

I still don't get why only killing OBL as an absolute last resort wasn't a priority. Perhaps it was, though I know government feared a circus trial, or hostages taken to secure OBL's release (though that hasn't happened with others the U.S. have captured). Such a failure of imagination: picture him in a room with KSM and seeing what if anything they had to see to each other or how they interacted?

1 year, 6 months ago on Esquire Is Screwed: Duped By Fake UBL “Shooter”

Reply

This is pretty big. Didn't figure that the actual shooter would be talking.

1 year, 6 months ago on Esquire Is Screwed: Duped By Fake UBL “Shooter”

Reply

The strange thing about this trend is that a coach can't tailor his team's plans to it. If he did, by resting healthy players, say, he wouldn't even win 10 games. The championship success of 10-game-winning teams will always be a happy accident.

1 year, 6 months ago on What does it take to win an NFL Championship?

Reply

Seems like only yesterday we were all "Bradshawholics." Will miss him. (Thanks for finding clip of fumble recovery to which Coughlin paid tribute, Rich.)

1 year, 7 months ago on Casualties of the Cap: Bradshaw, Boley, Canty

Reply

Thanks, UNYG, for another great year (of blogging, if not football). Hardest for me to watch was:1.How soft run defense in the middle was.2. Lack of gap integrity when it came to end runs. So tired of seeing backs and QBs not being contained, especially on the left side of the defense. 

1 year, 8 months ago on NYG 42 PHL 7

Reply

Jack wrote: "I'm actually better adjusted then he is." As Jack's uncle by marriage, I'm here to say . . . believe it or not, that's true! (Just bought the paperback version.)

1 year, 8 months ago on Happy New Year: Target Deck Released Today!

Reply