Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

Hi again!

(So excited for Flatline)

6 days, 22 hours ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

@The Living Angel / is Regenerating *cough*The Fourth Planet Cybermen*cough*

6 days, 22 hours ago on Details on Episodes 9-12 of Series 8

Reply

In the Forest of the Night, for sure. Cottrell Boyce, a surreal setting, and a title that inspires plenty of imagery... I'm set!

3 weeks, 1 day ago on Poll: Your Most Anticipated Series 8 Story (Eps 7-12)

Reply

Easily one of my favorite companions. Easily one of my favorite Who actresses. She was an integral part of so many classics, and brought an unprecedented feeling of warmth to every play she was in; The Pirates, Jubilee, Arrangements for War, Thicker than Water, A Death in the Family, The Marian Conspiracy, The Spectre of Lanyon Moor, My Own Private Wolfgang... all stories I would happily listen to over and over again. Quite simply, there was no one like Evelyn Smythe and no one like Maggie Stables. 


For someone who was born without living grandparents, such a presence felt like listening to a grandmother, almost. To me, even more than the ubiquitous Peri, Evelyn is the Sixth Doctor companion, and a great part of his audio success. Rest in peace, Maggie; you will be missed.



3 weeks, 1 day ago on A Whology: Maggie Stables

Reply

Coming from a Moffat critic – wow. Some parts were iffy, definitely, but wow. Instant classic, far better than anything Moffat's done for the show since The Empty Child

1 month, 1 week ago on Rate & Discuss Listen

Reply

@GoodYear92 I've had a friend who read the scripts spoil the story for me – I WON'T SHARE SPOILERS, HONEST, CROSS MY HEARTS – but from what I hear it's definitely going to be on par (in public opinion, at the very least) with Blink. However, there is one sequence which may prove to be controversial for some fans – that entirely depends on the type of fan, though. 

It's a very Moffat story, though. It has the same feeling of his RTD episodes, I think, rather than his Matt era stuff. 

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

@DrOswald @Iris Wildthyme @Calebxy Oh, alright! Sorry I didn't know.

2 months, 4 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

@TARDlSkey @Iris Wildthyme

–McGann could have filled this role. McGann's Doctor would have been fascinating to see as a trapped, desperate Doctor–– a character once so romantic, crushed by a never-ending war. And I might have given more thought to the War Doctor had we seen him commit these terrible acts, rather than shoot NO MORE into a wall. It just seems like an ill-conceived way to round out the regenerative cycle, rather than take an already-existing character and do interesting things with his development.


–[opinions may differ on the following statement] Who says the 50th had to have purpose? Or even be big and epic? I'd much rather have an intimate, more character piece-type story that doesn't need to go into established continuity to find a story. There was no reason to undo Gallifrey's destruction; I'm sure writers could find ways to write story arcs that don't involve Gallifrey, and its destruction, tragic though it was, created a fascinating part of the Doctor's characterization that is now lost.


–I'm talking about the disparity between the Tenth Doctor of TEoT (who was horrified to hame the Time Lords/Gallifrey back) and the Tenth Doctor of TDotD, who was happy and seemed to forget the fact that the society was corrupt and incredibly dangerous.


–Opinions will always differ on Rose. I, for one, love her (much more so than Amy/Clara); regardless, it's undeniable that Billie and David have fantastic chemistry, so having them be separate for (IIRC) nearly the whole story is a questionable decision at best. And, exactly. "For the sake of having Billie there." Why not, if we were going to include Billie just because, have her be where she usually was, in one of the most popular companion-Doctor duos ever (say what you like about Rose, she's not exactly faded into obscurity)? It seems like a poorly judged way to include an actress in the special.


–Yeah, but the children were never part of it before. Beforehand, it was all about how Gallifrey was literally a danger to the rest of the universe because they had the means to destroy everything in order to survive. Now it seems we're ignoring that for the sake of the children. I mean, the point of the LGTW and the fall of Gallifrey was that the Doctor is a complex character who is willing to take drastic measures for what he sees as the greater good of the universe. That's a dramatically satisfying character –– as we saw with Nine and Ten, it provides plenty of opportunity for in-depth character exploration and a much more interesting reaction to antagonists/events/etc. Now that complexity is getting erased because he's the Doctor and he could never. When the point was... he could.


–I've already argued about QE1 enough on other sites, so we'll leave it that some wanted the "resolution" to what was a simple gag and others didn't care (like the ending of Blink, when he and Martha were going off to a migration or something). 


–I mean, I felt that the story was fairly cluttered as is. But it's just my opinion that celebrating the show doesn't involve undoing past bits of important continuity that, in turn, lessens the dramatic potential and complexity of the show's main character.


...and that's why I don't like Day.

2 months, 4 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

@Esterath @Iris Wildthyme Ooh, lots of things. 

–The War Doctor (for many, MANY reasons)

–Rewriting of the Time War

–Mischaracterized Tenth Doctor

–Unnecessary Zygon subplot

–LGTW being just a regular war with shooty things and lasers 

–Rose not being, um, Rose

–Making Gallifrey all about the children (as opposed to the twisted, evil thing it had become in the LGTW of the RTD Era)

–The idea that the Doctor has always been "going home", which ignores the central facet of the character that he is constantly running from his home as an outsider (plus his home = very corrupt, stagnant, etc; everything he isn't)

–The fact that, at the end of the day, there was no need for Gallifrey to come back

–The fact that we had to unearth the (tired and boring) gag of QE1 for the Tenth Doctor's subplot


It should have been a fun runaround with Ten/Donna, Eleven/Clara, Eight/??? (Fitz?), and Nine/Rose (if possible). Instead, we got something that kind of changed previously established continuity for no particular reason.

2 months, 4 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

Just rewatched Series 7B (specials included).

The Snowmen – 6/10

The Bells of Saint John – 8/10

The Rings of Akhaten – 8/10

Cold War – 6.5/10

Hide – 8.5/10

Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS – 4/10

The Crimson Horror – 7/10

Nightmare in Silver – 3/10

The Name of the Doctor – 6/10

The Night of the Doctor – 6/10

The Day of the Doctor – 3/10

The Time of the Doctor – 5/10

Average: 5.91/10


Didn't realize how much I disliked this run until I rewatched it. 


2 months, 4 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

I mean it's not just a "fannish" thing to do, it's just easier. I'm not demanding that they start calling them the Eleventh/Twelfth/etc Doctor in-universe; there'd be no reason to other than in the rare multi-Doctor story. But in fanfiction and the like, using a well-established numbering system just makes... sense


3 months ago on Moffat Questions “Twelfth Doctor” Title

Reply

Good choices; I especially agree with Fearmonger, Chimes, Pirates and The Kingmaker. I feel that The Next Life is a tad continuity-heavy (i.e. the Divergent Universe arc) to be chosen, and I really disliked TLATE. Regardless, this is pretty much all MR picks, and my top 15 would probably include some 1st Doctor Companion Chronicles as well.

3 months ago on Happy Birthday, Big Finish! 15 Picks for 15 Years

Reply

Iris Wildthyme's Top Ten EDAs –– updated!

10. EarthWorld

9. Father Time

8. Vampire Science

7. The Blue Angel

6. The Shadows of Avalon

5. Fear Itself

4. The Tomorrow Windows

3. The City of the Dead

2. The Year of Intelligent Tigers

1. The Scarlet Empress

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

Ah, yes. RIP Jon Pertwee. Of his (televised) stories, I'd go with Spearhead from Space, Inferno, The Curse of Peladon, Carnival of Monsters,  and Frontier in Space. If anyone's looking for Third Doctor expanded universe stories, I'd recommend: The Blue Tooth, Old Soldiers, The Prisoner of Peladon, Find and Replace, The Last Post, Ghost in the Machine, The Scorchies, and The Mega on audio. Book-wise, I'd go with Catastrophea, Verdigris, Rags, and Interference.

3 months, 2 weeks ago on The 3rd Doctor: Five Favourites

Reply

Another day, another moment where I wish desperately that I lived in Wales. 

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Series 8: Watch Deep Breath First

Reply

@SteviePenny While I think they are overused, the real problem isn't their appearance in every series (or frequently in Big Finish audios), it's that the writers don't know how to do anything original or interesting with the Daleks. Give me a story like Jubilee/Dalek and I'll happily enjoy the Daleks.


3 months, 2 weeks ago on Series 8: New Teaser Trailer “I see into your soul, Doctor”

Reply

Surprisingly enough (I say this as someone who's been disliking the Main Range as of late), every release in the rest of the 2014 lineup (Breaking Bubbles, the Seventh/Ace/Hex trilogy, and the Peri/Six trilogy) all look set to be cracking stories. I'm just glad that we're getting the Rani at last; maybe a Fourth Doctor Adventure is in order?




3 months, 4 weeks ago on Meet the New Rani

Reply

@Gustaff Sorry for the late reply–– probably not, as I'm more keen to do a sort of series of mini-reviews about the essential books or Companion Chronicles. So if you'd like to review the set, be my guest!

4 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

On the contrary to Gustaff, I rather liked the New Adventures box set. It's nothing major, nothing world-shaking, but it's good stuff, particularly Random Ghosts. The Revolution is the major dud for me, mainly because it tonally doesn't fit with the rest of the box set. It's best to treat the next three as one major story, which I thought had some nice character exploration for Bernice (which is rather amazing considering the amount of time she's been around). 

As for the other Big Finish releases this month (I haven't gotten Masquerade as I'm not a fan of Fifth Doctor/Nyssa)...


Second Chances was a good, if not great, ending to the Companion Chronicles. It's a downer for sure, and needs some light fare to follow it up, but it's good. The symmetry between the episodes is very nicely done. 7/10


Destroy the Infinite was bad. It's everything I dislike about Nick Briggs's Doctor Who, and its charmless first episode could have been condensed down to ten or so minutes. Another dud for the FDAs, I'm afraid. 3/10

4 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/062014/

Reply

@TheOncomingStorm Very much so. The Scarlet Empress (his strongest work, in my opinion) is one of my favourite Who stories of all time.

4 months, 1 week ago on Comparing the Different Arcs of the Revival

Reply

If we want to talk about soapiness/soap-opera-esque elements in storytelling, I'd look no further than the familial antics of the Ponds ("She's our daughter!" "She's grown up with us the whole time!" "She killed the Doctor!" "No, she killed his robot clone!"). Now, while I like both eras, it's hardly fair to criticize the RTD era for having soap opera elements when Moffat's has its own fair share.

4 months, 1 week ago on Comparing the Different Arcs of the Revival

Reply

I don't want a companion to be a challenge; I want a companion to feel genuine. The other greatest mistake in her characterization (aside from turning her into a cypher) was not retaining the memories of JttCotT. 

4 months, 1 week ago on Clara Oswald – A Question of Perspective

Reply

@MrRazza Trust me, the companions do much better once they're off the screen. If you want your mind to be changed about the Sixth Doctor's companions, get Peri and the Piscon Paradox for Peri and The Fires of Vulcan or The One Doctor for Mel. Note that The Fires of Vulcan is a Seventh Doctor story, but it's a great dramatic showcasing for Mel; The One Doctor is out-and-out comedy, and it's perfection. And most people credit Peri and the Piscon Paradox as not only Peri's best story, but also one of the best Big Finish stories ever (and it was written by Nicola Bryant's boyfriend!).



4 months, 2 weeks ago on The Sixth Doctor: Five Favourites

Reply

Not to be a broken record, but I'd like to extend five audio favourites for the Sixth Doctor, because (in my opinion) that is where he really gets to shine. Those would be The Marian Conspiracy, Doctor Who and the Pirates, Davros, Jubilee, and The Wormery. They are, in order, a fantastic historical, a hilarious tragedy (and my favourite Doctor Who story... ever), a gripping character piece, the darker cousin of Dalek, and a hilarious piece with great atmosphere that pits Colin Baker against the cosmic bag lady herself, Iris Wildthyme. All must-buys, in my opinion.




4 months, 2 weeks ago on The Sixth Doctor: Five Favourites

Reply

Nah. If they had brought her back early on in Eleven's era, then maybe; I feel it's been a bit too long. Plus, I doubt that Moffat had any grand designs on the character when he requested for her to be brought back; I imagine he was in the early stages of forming what would become the arc for the Eleventh Doctor and thus was toying with the ideas of another author.

4 months, 3 weeks ago on Bring Back… Jenny, the Doctor’s Daughter

Reply

Ah. NSAs. Well. I'll get the Richards one, maybe the Goss as well (I've loved his CCs). As for Tucker, I'll have to see.



4 months, 3 weeks ago on First 12th Doctor Novels Detailed

Reply

@LGwalchmai95 Byronic amnesiac with a wig.

4 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

@The Mind Probe Doctor Who and the Pirates is a Sixth Doctor audio that is a musical. In my opinion, it's the best piece of Doctor Who of all time. 

4 months, 3 weeks ago on Foxes Cast in Series 8

Reply

...Can't say I'm surprised.

4 months, 3 weeks ago on The Top Stories & Doctors (According to DWM 2014)

Reply

@supermoff Yes, but you could hardly call "Rain" a full trailer. They're both teaser trailers.

5 months ago on Weird and Wonderful

Reply

The Rain trailer is miles better than the official one, if we're being honest. And watching Chris Eccleston's eyebrows rise to astronomical heights as he morphed into David Tennant was hilarious.

5 months ago on Weird and Wonderful

Reply

That's Frontios finished. Quite grim, although no major side character dies (I was very much expecting Norna or Plantagenet to bite the dust). Interesting central conceit (very Utopia, in some manners), but the Tractators aren't particularly convincing nor compelling villains. Tegan really doesn't do much and Turlough mainly gets to access his "ancestral memory" through screaming and looking pretty in the background. I wish this TARDIS team didn't always get split up in stories, and I wish characters like Norna were given less screen time, simply to give characters like Tegan something to do. 6/10.

5 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

...AAAND more procrastinating on revising with The Awakening. Another lovely story, very solid; my only criticism was that the plot of the Malus was a bit hard to follow during the story (I worked it out all right with a minute of research), and that Tegan and Turlough didn't actually get that much to do. But that said, a lovely Fifth Doctor story; 7.5/10. I think I'll continue on with this TARDIS team and go onto Frontios.

5 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

Just watched Carnival of Monsters. Great little story, hilarious most of the time; the only problems were the getups the Lurmans were in (what was the design team thinking?) and the horrendously acted and conceived Inter Minorians. Honestly, every scene with the "conspirators" was just dreadful. So, overall, 8/10. Absolutely bonkers, and the sequences in the Miniscope more than make up for the dreadful scenes outside.

5 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

I don't think I ever made a post after I finished the Compassion arc (Interference to The Ancestor Cell). So, here goes.

I can break it down into one sentiment: I love Compassion, I hate how she was handled. To go story by story...


Interference. Well, it's Larry Miles. It's all a bit bonkers, and Compassion's somewhat sidelined what with the canon-shifting events contained within, but she's competently introduced, as is the chilling idea of Anathema/the Remote.


The Blue Angel. Compassion is sidelined, but I didn't care as I love this book to bits. 


The Taking of Planet 5. While I really don't like this book, as it's nigh-on impossible to read, Compassion gets some very interesting things to do. All the hints towards her future identity are very well structured in this novel.


Frontier Worlds. Another interesting outing for Compassion, as she and Fitz are the stars of this book. She's at her most ruthless and therefore most fun here. Nothing groundbreaking done with her character.


Parallel 59. Dull book for Compassion and the Doctor; brilliant material for Fitz. She does get to dabble in revolution and there's a fun, if grim, escape sequence.


The Shadows of Avalon. HALLELUJAH. While Compassion herself doesn't actually do all that much (her first chapter is, however, a lovely idea; the Doctor forcing her to spend time alone on Earth in order to become more human), this is the book where I finally saw her full potential. The ending sequence is absolutely fascinating.


The Fall of Yquatine. This really is Fitz's book, as the Doctor makes some awful blunders and Compassion darts in and out of the action. I'm INCREDIBLY uncomfortable with the relationship the Doctor and Compassion have here; whatever Nick Walters and Stephen Cole were thinking, I have no idea. While I adore this book, the Compassion/Doctor dynamic turns unnecessarily violent.


Coldheart. Boring. Compassion has some nice character development down in the caves, and... that's about it. 


The Space Age. Don't get me started on The Space Age.


The Banquo Legacy. I love this book, its atmosphere, and its style of storytelling, but the authors wanted to tell a 19th century story, so they shunted Compassion to the sidelines once more. The way they did so is interesting, but it does nothing to further her character arc.


The Ancestor Cell. I'm in two minds about this book. Mainly, I hate it, and Lawrence Miles should have written it. Granted, he's bonkers, but he's good bonkers. Anyways, it's the last we see of Compassion in this continuity (she turns up in the Faction Paradox novels, I believe), and she gets to destroy some War TARDISes and run away from responsibility with Nivet. 


So, of her ten books, Compassion gets to shine in Planet 5, Frontier Worlds, Avalon, and The Ancestor Cell. 4/10, and two of them are badly written. Her concept is so fascinating, her initial characterization so brilliant, that it makes me so frustrated that nothing was actually done with her. If I had been range editor, I would've cut Parallel 59 to have Avalon happen sooner, cut Coldheart and The Space Age, and use the three empty slots to tell interesting stories with Compassion, Fitz, and the Doctor.

This era was wasted potential; we'll never have another Compassion, I don't think. C'est la vie.

5 months ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

@TardisBoy ah, missed that part. My apologies :)

5 months ago on 5 Could Have Been Companions

Reply

Sorry to make an incredibly fannish correction here, but Idris was not entirely the first time we had something like her. Compassion, an EDA character who first appeared in Interference, released in 1999. Compassion's arc later had her turn into a TARDIS in The Shadows of Avalon, and the Doctor and fellow companion Fitz then traveled around, ah, in her. While Compassion definitely didn't live up to her potential (there were plenty of interesting stories waiting to be told with her), this wasn't the first time we had a living TARDIS. However, Compassion was the "mother" of the Type 103 TARDISes, which were living beings; maybe a rival Time Lord (with Gallifrey's return) could be Idris/Compassion's spiritual successor?





5 months ago on 5 Could Have Been Companions

Reply

For anyone who's interested: Dalek was adapted from a Big Finish audio story, Jubilee, which I think is far superior to the televised story. It's only US $3.00 for a download, so I'd recommend picking it up.

5 months ago on Dalek or Cold War?

Reply

I'm glad they interrupted him before he could watch any more of The Sensorites, to be honest.

5 months, 1 week ago on Frank Skinner Cast in Series 8

Reply

Oh, Paul. He became the book's "event" writer, aside from Lawrence Miles. He wrote one of the opening Timewyrm novels; Love and War, which introduced darling Benny Summerfield; Happy Endings, which saw off Benny it a fabulous novel filled to bursting with continuity; and The Shadows of Avalon, one of the most imaginative Doctor Who stories ever, which did what was perhaps the most inventive thing in Who's history with Compassion. Not only that, but he wrote the Bernice Summerfield audio Death and the Daleks with its companion anthology, Life During Wartime; two of the hardest-hitting pieces of drama ever released by Big Finish. What I'm trying to say is, Paul Cornell "Gets" Doctor Who, but he doesn't let that knowledge restrain him. Which is why I'd be more that chuffed to have him back.



5 months, 1 week ago on Bring Back… Paul Cornell

Reply

**Edit: I'd also put Sara-Steven as one of my top First Doctor teams, and Fitz-Anji as one of my top Eighth Doctor ones. Oh, and also Izzy as well for Eight.

5 months, 1 week ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

List time! Let's see, Enemy-Doctor pairings. As in, which enemy do I automatically associate with each Doctor.

First Doctor: The Daleks

Second Doctor: The Cybermen

Third Doctor: The Master

Fourth Doctor: Sontarans

Fifth Doctor: The Master

Sixth Doctor: The Forge or the Valeyard

Seventh Doctor: The Elder Gods/Eldritch Abominations/etc.

Eighth Doctor: Faction Paradox

Ninth Doctor: Daleks

Tenth Doctor: The Time Lords

Eleventh Doctor: The Silence


...and THEN favorite TARDIS teams for each.


First: Ian-Barbara-Vicki

Second: Jamie-Zoe

Third: The UNIT Family OR Sarah Jane

Fourth: Sarah Jane OR Romana II

Fifth: Peri-Erimem

Sixth: Evelyn

Seventh: Ace-Hex

Eighth: Fitz-Compassion OR Lucie OR Charley 

Ninth: Rose-Jack

Tenth: Donna

Eleventh: Amy (solo)

5 months, 1 week ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

So, after some searching last night, I was finally able to download all 20 of the old Doctor Who annuals. I've paged through several already, and it's... unsettling how completely different they are from the show. A personal favorite is the Third Doctor/Liz adventure entitled "A Universe Called Fred". 

5 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

Other writers to have back: Jacqueline Rayner of the audios/books; Rob Shearman of the audios and Dalek; Kate Orman of the books; Paul Cornell of the books + Human Nature/The Family of Blood; Lloyd Rose, another fantastic female book author; Mags L Halliday, of the Faction Paradox novels and History 101; Paul Magrs (my darling) of the audios and books and Iris Wildthyme; Jonathan Morris of the books and audios; and many more who may have not been related to Who. I just listed several that have written for the show's media before in memorable, powerful books.

5 months, 2 weeks ago on Bring Back… Helen Raynor

Reply

Short answer: yes. I've listened to dozens of Big Finish audios and feel that a Tenth Doctor series would definitely boost their sales. We'd replace the Lost Stories range with them, and then we'd have the Monthlies (5th-7th), the Early Adventures (1st-3rd), the EDAs (8th), the FDAs (4th), and the TDAs (10th).

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Is it Time to Give Big Finish the New Who Licence?

Reply

@Gustaff I'm very sporadic with my main range buys, so I got 9 titles. The Settling, No Man's Land, Red, Memory Lane, 100, Time Works, Faith Stealer, Terror Firma, and Night Thoughts. I just listened to The Settling today; it was absolutely incredible.

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

Did anyone else who listens to Big Finish audios get something during the May Day sale?

5 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/discusswho/012014/

Reply

I love Rose. Rose is without a doubt one of the realest companions of both Classic and New Who; an affirmation that even the most ordinary person is, in fact, extraordinary. Now, is she up there with the likes of Sarah Jane, Jo Grant, Donna, Ace, Evelyn Smythe, Lucie, Fitz, Compassion, etc etc etc? No. But that doesn't stop her from being a fantastic character and very worthy companion.


5 months, 3 weeks ago on A Bad Wolf or Just Plain Bad? Addressing Rose Criticisms

Reply

@Creepy_Ghoul I mean... why? Most of the stories of Big Finish are better suited to audio, either because A) they were designed that way or B) because they use the advantage of not having sets to create enormous, dynamic settings. And I hate to be a realist here, but any situation where any of these suggestions would occur seems really economically inviable for all parties involved. And lastly, you don't need visuals to make a story good, in my opinion.


5 months, 3 weeks ago on How About A Retroseries Spin-off?

Reply