Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

@the great dick tater @MScottEiland  I think that if he was going to be used on short rest, Mattingly should have committed to taking him out after a short pitch count (as, to his credit, he did the prior year).  It would still have been a bad and risky idea, but at least it wouldn't have been criminally stupid like letting him go on after what happened to him the last start was.  CK doing better than Haren would have for six innings only matters if there were going to be no negative consequences going forward--consequences which were readily predictable and which came to pass.

12 hours, 1 minute ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

@DBrim  "Put out an APB on Alvin Dark.  And let Maury Wills know there's going to be a muddy runway today."  :-)

12 hours, 7 minutes ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

@the great dick tater @MScottEiland  If the bullpen is good enough to be trusted, it should be trusted to backstop Vogelsong rather than a diminished Baumgarner start.  Bochy seems to agree with this.  Starting him on short rest would imply lack of trust in the bullpen (and would likely be a bad idea even then--see "Kershaw, Clayton" for how this can blow up in the manager's face).

12 hours, 8 minutes ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

@the great dick tater @MScottEiland  If you don't trust your bullpen (which the Giants don't--at least as much as much as Yost does his), why would you create a situation where your ace has to pitch on short rest and probably come out earlier, increasing the stress on that bullpen while burning that ace?

12 hours, 18 minutes ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

Ooops.  Typo.  That should read ". . .manages to *not* abuse. . ."

12 hours, 21 minutes ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

Amazing how a two time World Champion manager manages not to *not* abuse his ace starter in a panic move short rest start when he's got to get performances out of the rest of his staff to win the series anyway.  It's part of my birthright to hate the Giants, but they certainly have a better manager than we do.

12 hours, 23 minutes ago on 2014 Dodgers in Review: C Tim Federowicz

Reply

@The Monocle  Can I go off the board and call up Hoyt Wilhelm with a séance?

1 day, 11 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

@Purple Drank @DodgerDodger  Oh, you and your wacky actual familiarity with the events of the season!

1 day, 11 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

@Guitar  Bob Brenly actually won a World Series, and he's dumber than most plant life.

1 day, 12 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

@Purple Drank  And Frank Lary was a better pitcher than Don Newcombe, since Lary beat the Yankees like a drum when they were winning the WS almost every year, while Newcombe was getting smoked by them (spoiler alert:  he wasn't).

1 day, 13 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

Gotta admit, the idea of this many reporters being this wrong lends to the appeal of DM getting the axe.

1 day, 13 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

@Purple Drank  Give him a fungo bat and tell him to scoot over on the bench.  Problem solved.

1 day, 13 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

@Tymathee  Kiss of death.  :-)

1 day, 13 hours ago on Joe Maddon is now a free agent, are the Dodgers next?

Reply

How about everybody just take a flying BABIP at the moon?

4 days, 8 hours ago on 2014 World Series Game 1: Giants @ Royals

Reply

Anyone want to bet against this guy on the mound for the Royals getting far less crap for being utterly worthless than Kershaw got for pitching brilliantly for six innings twice?

4 days, 9 hours ago on 2014 World Series Game 1: Giants @ Royals

Reply

That is good news, since DM doesn't seem to be heading out the airlock just yet, but I have to say that a system that doesn't care who is behind the bunter and what the likely consequences of the bunt are (good hitter gets walked to face atrocious one) is not a terribly useful one.  The thing that has us livid about some of DM's moves are the *specific* ways in which they are stupid and destructive, not just the general "stop bunting because it is stupid in general" complaint.

1 week, 1 day ago on An Area of Improvement for Don Mattingly

Reply

@P_F_P  Let's just call this the "World War II" rooting strategy--hope that the one we hate the least wins, then hope they lose horribly immediately afterwards.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@I Digesti @mostly exciting potato @ tomato  He's 21.  Look at what a long list of GOAT candidates had done by 21, and feel foolish at implying that Harper is a failure, or somehow behind schedule.  He's injury prone, and that has slowed his development.  Which makes what he has accomplished in spite of that by 21 all the more amazing.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@DodgerDodger @MScottEiland @mostly exciting potato  Combining a no hit catcher with a (proposed) no hit shortstop is going to put a serious crimp in the offense.  CK's ridiculous record was partially due to the fact that he won basically every time he gave up two runs or less (which hadn't always been the case in prior years).  If the catcher/SS combo is AJ and Rojas/AE next year, I predict CK will lose at least three 1-0 or 2-1 games unless there is a large offensive upgrade somewhere else.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@DodgerDodger @ABSmileBunch  The weakness of the bullpen was partially concealed by the fact that CK was going eight or more innings a ridiculous amount of the time this year.  This also made it worse when CK finally did need rescuing in the seventh inning in the postseason.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@DodgerDodger @davstein48  Disappointing, but not remotely a "losing season."  Let's not go all Crimson Tide fan or--even worse--Yankee fan here.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@YadierMolinasOedipalComplex @DodgerDodger @ tomato  There is a certain amount of historical evidence to support the proposition that the tradeoff can be worth it or at least more so than one would think.  Ray Oyler got about 250 PA for the World Champion 1968 Tigers in spite of having an OPS+ of *20* (.135/.213/.186).  Rojas won't be remotely *that* bad.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

@mostly exciting potato @MScottEiland  I'm not too concerned that he might be somewhat overpaid, as long as the contract isn't too long--anything over three years for a catcher in his thirties is problematic.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

Offhand, I'd say that upgrading to Russell Martin at catcher would be worth losing a draft pick in addition to any reasonable contract the Dodgers can sign him to.  Anyone disagree, or have caveats?

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

The nice thing about Ned is that he left some rather clear benchmarks of stupid on his record (along with, admittedly, some moves that were actually good and others that just blew up at least partially due to bad luck [the Jones and Schmidt contracts, which at least were relatively short, come to mind here].  If Friedman starts doing things that look like the Pierre contract, that *will* piss me off--as will anything that resembles the legendary historical trading disasters in relatively recent Dodger history (Sid Fernandez for two sacks of crap, Pedro Martinez for Delino "sack of crap" DeShields).  Indulging further DM stupidity and petulance is also going to have me think he's screwing up.  Otherwise, he should be given some space to try stuff, some of which will inevitably not work.  GMs are human, but that is not a blank check for repeating mistakes that the last guy (and his predecessors) made.

1 week, 2 days ago on Andrew Friedman Is Going To Do Something That Infuriates You

Reply

Friedman could convince me he's a genius even if he keeps Mattingly--if he hired a coach whose sole job is to scream "STOP BUNTING, YOU IDIOT!" or something similar every time DM is about to do something stupid.

1 week, 3 days ago on What About The Next Joe Maddon?

Reply

@Anime Ethier  Hope you specified "pounds sterling" or you might end up with a lot of sacks of crap as your compensation. 

1 week, 3 days ago on Ned Colletti was a lame duck GM & Andrew Friedman now moves the Dodgers forward

Reply

@Tymathee @MScottEiland  No, because that would imply that he has improved, as opposed to simply moving on to different and equally horrifying ways demonstrate his status as living proof of the utter incompetence of sports columnists in general (since he keeps winning awards for his single sentence paragraph spewing drek).

1 week, 3 days ago on Ned Colletti was a lame duck GM & Andrew Friedman now moves the Dodgers forward

Reply

A reminder that the issues regarding Ned were around for a long, long time:


http://www.firejoemorgan.com/2006/08/best-ever.html


"The guy who watched a bunch of Maddux starts and filed the reports on him?" Colletti asked. "That was him."


Because, as Ken Tremendous asked:  "You are telling me that you needed to hire someone to tell you that Greg Maddux might be a good pitcher?"


1 week, 3 days ago on Ned Colletti was a lame duck GM & Andrew Friedman now moves the Dodgers forward

Reply

MOAR BUNTING!!!!!!!!

1 week, 4 days ago on Baseball Twitter reacts to Dodgers’ hiring of Andrew Friedman

Reply

@P_F_P @MScottEiland  He was left in longer than any pitcher reasonably would be if the manager had confidence in his bullpen.  I blame Mattingly less for Game One than Game Four, but if the bullpen were remotely competent CK would have been out after the first few hits in Game One.  Game Four was just DM abusing a starter working on short rest, and is on him primarily.

1 week, 4 days ago on Baseball Twitter reacts to Dodgers’ hiring of Andrew Friedman

Reply

@P_F_P @Disgruntled Goat  There's a reason that a quality start is "six innings or more"--a competent bullpen can pick up the slack when the starter starts to tire in the seventh.  The Dodger bullpen isn't.  That's on them, and on the man who assembled it.

1 week, 4 days ago on Baseball Twitter reacts to Dodgers’ hiring of Andrew Friedman

Reply

@P_F_P  Clayton Kershaw pitched well for six innings twice, then was left in too long after starting to get hit in Game One because the bullpen sucked, and was sent out for the seventh inning after 94 pitches on short rest in Game Four because the bullpen sucks.  Making your take on 1 and 5 a bit silly.  The rest I agree with.

1 week, 4 days ago on Baseball Twitter reacts to Dodgers’ hiring of Andrew Friedman

Reply

@P_F_P  I always thought the Juan Pierre signing was utterly unforgivable, both for simply throwing money away to a below average player for *five* years *and* because it led to the Jones debacle *and* delayed the development of Ethier and Kemp--and in a way that was utterly predictable:  Pierre continued being the player he had always been, only older and therefore gradually worse (except for the brief uptick in 2009 that let the Dodgers unload him far more cheaply than would otherwise have been the case).  That's a bit different from Andruw Jones suddenly becoming fat and worthless once he pulled into the Dodger Stadium parking lot--and at least that was only a three year contract.

1 week, 4 days ago on Welcome To Town, Andrew Friedman

Reply

I'm hoping that nine years of further development among stat savvy fandom will help provide a defense for Friedman if Mr. Single Sentence Paragraph Douchebag starts up with his "Google Boy" crap or something similar again.

1 week, 4 days ago on Welcome To Town, Andrew Friedman

Reply

@BlueMarvin  Do you think that AJ would be likely to get a starting job somewhere else?  Being the caddy of the best pitcher on the planet (and presumably being the overall backup catcher for the highest price roster in MLB) ain't such a bad fate for someone who just spent a season below the Mendoza Line.

1 week, 4 days ago on Welcome To Town, Andrew Friedman

Reply

@BlueMarvin @Anime Ethier  No, it's just Australia:  "Hi, I'm Australia and I'm trying to murder you.  G'day!"  ]:-)

1 week, 4 days ago on Welcome To Town, Andrew Friedman

Reply

@foldamort  Is his name Friedman or Heisenberg?  :-)

1 week, 4 days ago on Welcome To Town, Andrew Friedman

Reply

*Evil Willow voice*  "One down. . ."

1 week, 4 days ago on The End Of The Ned Colletti Era

Reply

@Hendrixfan1145 Current evidence suggests that the Steelers suck donkey balls, which would explain how Tampa Bay did so well against them.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@Purple Drank But his failure to get out of the fifth inning in the postseason is in no way a character flaw, whereas Kershaw's failure to be pulled out when having problems in the seventh *is*--signed, The National Baseball Media and some scumbag named Bayless

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@Mike Petriello @MScottEiland Except that he might do it again.  And that impacts his value to the team going forward.  Which is a thing the fans do have a right to know.


OK, I've said my piece.  I can't lay it out more clearly than that, and I'm weary of shadow boxing.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@capnsparrow  @MScottEiland @Mike Petriello When Greinke came out and said that he was done after seven, I accepted that--so your statement is provably wrong.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@Mike Petriello @MScottEiland It's not just curiosity if it impacts both Puig's value going forward *and* DM's competency as a manager.  Those *are* things the fans have a right to know.  You're also ignoring that whatever kept him out of the starting lineup and for use as a pinch hitter let him be used as a pinch runner.  I have yet to see a plausible scenario for how that could be a real situation, particularly since they would have no reason not to cite an actual injury or medical condition without mentioning how he got it.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@capnsparrow  @MScottEiland @Mike Petriello If Puig was benched due to "this looks bad," I want DM (and Ned for allowing it) not only fired, but blacklisted and ruined.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@Mike Petriello @MScottEiland So, if CK had been replaced with Haren two hours before Game One, we should have just accepted the "the best team on the field" BS?  That's ridiculous. 

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@Mike Petriello @MScottEiland Well, then we're full circle here--it's on the surface a dumb move, and one he refuses to justify in a plausible manner.  Fired.  Now.

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply

@BIah Otherwise known as "the Bill Plaschke business model."

1 week, 6 days ago on You Just Watched The Best-Hitting Outfield In Los Angeles Dodgers History

Reply