Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

"I'd just as soon get rid of the ring bearers in this little fellowship of suck." Brilliant. Love it.

8 months ago on Who to Root For: Week 12

Reply

I don't think the first half of Sunday's game was respectable at all, but I'm not ready to thrown anyone under the bus for it. A few points:

1) Didn't the Manning Colts have the same problem of playing down to their opponents?

2) Which team in the NFL this year is beating the teams they "should beat" consistently?

3) We had the bootleg covered every single time. Keenum simply avoided the pressure and made plays.

4) Maybe the Texans aren't that bad - they did lose to KC by only 1 point...(Weak argument, I know, but still).

Other than that, I must say last night is why I love being a Colts fan. Game ain't over 'till the fat lady sings.

8 months, 2 weeks ago on Monday Morning Moaner: Colts at Texans

Reply

This annoys the heck out of me: Donald Brown gets on the field, and his first run goes for 52 yards. His next play is a 9 yard reception. Why take him out? His next two plays are 9 and 10 yard runs - and then he's done. Why?

I'm just going to say it. Donald Brown outplayed TRich today. Every time he touched the ball, he gained at least 9 yards. Why the heck wasn't he in more? Where is the "go with the hot hand" mentality?

9 months, 3 weeks ago on The Colts Steamroll the Jaguars 37-3

Reply

 @Music Man I take it you mean see *Davis as a 1 or 2?

1 year, 6 months ago on Cassius Vaughn vs. Darius Butler: Looking into the Future

Reply

 @Nate Dunlevy  @EVLGNUS  @ManiacalOne Or pull a Bob Sanders during the playoffs. ;)

1 year, 6 months ago on Colts-Ravens Open Thread

Reply

And isn't the 10 yard cushion a coaching decision? Isn't it what Tim Jennings used to struggle with? What is the advantage to it??

1 year, 8 months ago on All 22 Analysis - Darius Butler.

Reply

If we're beat by 40, people won't be mad because of the defense. They'll be mad at the offense. Unless we're beat 80-40.

1 year, 8 months ago on All 22 Analysis - Darius Butler.

Reply

Despite the hard times

We Colts fans will stay loyal

Because we bleed blue

2 years, 2 months ago on Colts Haiku: Win an Autographed Andrew Luck Football | May

Reply

We have seen Greats leave

Manning as Marvin before

but one more shall rise

2 years, 2 months ago on Colts Haiku: Win an Autographed Andrew Luck Football | May

Reply

All good things must end

Too early, yes, it is true

but Luck brings us hope

2 years, 2 months ago on Colts Haiku: Win an Autographed Andrew Luck Football | May

Reply

Hmm...I wrote this, though it didn't seem to show up...

2 years, 2 months ago on Hopeful Fodder - What if We're Wrong? | Articles

Reply

 @kasey_junk  @horseshoe19 Any thoughts on resigning Gonzo? I assume he will be more than affordable, and if he sees the field, perhaps he'll fulfill the promise of his first 2 years. I never did think he got the chance last year.

2 years, 4 months ago on Five Reasons The Colts Resigned Reggie Wayne | March

Reply

@flores_salicis Not to be a naysayer, but I believe we were rooting for the Pats in the divisional round of the '06 season. Still feels wrong.

2 years, 5 months ago on Super Bowl Recap: The Giants Won. The Patriots Lost | February

Reply

Great, unbiased article, Nate. Admit it, though. If it's a coin flip, you'd much rather see the Patriots lose. ;)

2 years, 5 months ago on Super Bowl Recap: The Giants Won. The Patriots Lost | February

Reply

@matt_has Quick note: Collie was more open, but Wayne was open, too. For that matter, Garcon could have been open in a second: it's a cover-1, which means good receivers will get open. Peyton was just going to his veteran, hands receiver. The receiver let him down.

2 years, 5 months ago on Five Plays in Free Agency - Reggie Wayne Edition | January

Reply

@gizzardfanny@vbcolts Couldn't they void the deal and resign it with only the option date changed?

2 years, 6 months ago on NFLPA: 18 can't move back bonus date | Articles

Reply

I think the only option is to take Luck. People talk about "waiting 2 years for the next once-in-a-generation QB", but who's to say we will have the pick to take that person?

As they say, a bird in the hand is worth 2 in the tree. We don't know what bird Luck is, but there's nothing to say he's any worse than the next guy 2 years from now.

2 years, 6 months ago on How does Luck compare to other college QBs? | Articles

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy Oh, I totally agree. On the other hand, Andrew Luck is supposedly "very rare". My only point is that you never know what's going to happen.

2 years, 6 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Jaguars

Reply

Dear Reggie Wayne:

If Peyton comes back, you want him throwing to you. Make the contract work. Please?

2 years, 6 months ago on Wayne proud of his time in Indy

Reply

Random thought. The year Elway was drafted, there was this QB that went #27th in the draft. Depending on how you look at it, he may have been a better QB than Elway. His name? Dan Marino.

Everyone is on the "Luck, RGII or no one" bandwagon. What if there's another option that we haven't considered yet who we can pick up AFTER trading #1 or #2?

2 years, 6 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Jaguars

Reply

@brobert Does anybody like Michael Floyd out of Notre Dame?

2 years, 7 months ago on Thanks for the Memories

Reply

@Payton I think he tried to be as polite as possible. ;)

2 years, 7 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Texans

Reply

Off topic, sort of, but Ray Lewis called it when he said the Colts without Peyton are a very below-average team:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QU6tvnkkBNI&feature=related

2 years, 7 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Texans

Reply

@kasey_junk Ok, will someone explain to me why Cowher is a bad idea? I'm not contesting, I just know he seemed to do well with the Steelers...and I haven't heard the argument behind hating him.

2 years, 7 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Texans

Reply

@dmstorm22@DougEngland With regard to Tebow, that's my point. I think he's inspired the team to be something great, something Orton didn't do. He's a polarizing figure, and the team is behind him, and consequently doing well.

2 years, 7 months ago on Mythbusting

Reply

@kasey_junk@WillyDuer As a fantasy owner of Calvin Johnson, I can tell you that he can in fact be stopped. :P

2 years, 7 months ago on Mythbusting

Reply

@DougEngland As a staunch supporter of Tebowmania (Sure. He's got a D. But didn't Kyle Orton?), I watched part of the Bears-Broncos game yesterday, and Jennings played 10 yards off of the WR's, and let one get out of bounds in a 2 min drill (EPIC FAIL.) He's the same Tim Jennings.

With regards to Lacy, I remember the Titans game back in his Rookie year...he made some sick plays. I don't know what's happened since then.

2 years, 7 months ago on Mythbusting

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy Ok, just wondering. BTW, how do you watch the whole game after? DVR, or some service or what?

2 years, 7 months ago on Five plays from the Patriots game

Reply

Am I the only one who thinks the point is moot? Either Peyton won't play again and the Colts draft Luck, or he does play again..and the Colts draft Luck (barring some "no I won't play!" from either...)

Though it might be the right choice, I don't see the Colts passing up on Luck.

2 years, 7 months ago on Thursday Open Thread: Lucky, Lucky, You're So Lucky

Reply

I would like to hear Nate's thoughts on this. Since he didn't see the game, he didn't get to see how good those passes from Orlovsky were...does this article change his opinion regarding Orlovsky?

2 years, 7 months ago on Five plays from the Patriots game

Reply

@dmstorm22 Excellent point...but you missed the most important part. It would piss off those annoying Steelers' fans. :D

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: Other Ways to Skin A Cat

Reply

@kasey_junk Take comfort in the fact that, whichever sucking team gets into the SB for the AFC, they will have their butts handed to them by the Packers. o_O

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: Other Ways to Skin A Cat

Reply

Random Thought. What if the Broncos make the Super Bowl? It's not going to happen, I know. But then again, they weren't supposed to be 6-1 with Tebow. Would anyone want that to happen?

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: Other Ways to Skin A Cat

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy Definitely agree on that last point. Have you had a chance to see the replays? The one on the sideline prior to his 2nd TD was amazing.

2 years, 7 months ago on Amoral Victory

Reply

And Nate, a quick note: you keep mentioning how good Garcon has been in the last 16 games...but this last game, most of his work came in garbage time. I love Garcon to death, but isn't it a little unfair to say that Orlovsky's numbers were "garbage time" while saying that Garcon's somehow count?

Again, I love Garçon, but I just wonder if this is a consistent argument...

2 years, 7 months ago on Amoral Victory

Reply

Dear Everyone,

If you think any of our QB's are good, go back and watch the '09 Colts-Pats game.

Remember the glory? Coming back from 31-14? The thrill of Wayne's amazing catch at the end? That was a BAD day for Peyton: He had two bad throws for picks. We still won the game in thrilling fashion.

Every time I want to believe the lie that Orlovsky is good, I just have to go back and reestablish my perspective.

Dang, I miss Peyton.

2 years, 7 months ago on Amoral Victory

Reply

@DIU@pierrezombie@squirrel@mattshedd@keep_the_eraser "Painter is being replaced by Peyton Manning, who comes out onto the field in a wheelchair"

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

The fact that Matt Leinart got hurt proves that the Texans should have spent money on investing in a good 3rd-string quarterback. /s

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

@squirrel@mattshedd@keep_the_eraser Agreed. But an 80% Manning is better than Painter any day of the week. (See 2008)

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

@mattshedd@keep_the_eraser To hear Polian talk last night, 100% of Painter is better than 80% of Manning. I'm not a Polian-hater, but that's ludicrous.

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

@mattshedd True. But that only further validates the argument of keeping both...

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

Nate, a random thought I had:

If the Colts drafted Luck and kept Manning, do you think both would be willing to take a pay cut? If I'm Luck, I'd be willing to make less if I get to study under the best quarterback ever...and perhaps Manning would be willing to take less given the injury. Don't all sides win in that scenario?

Otherwise, I think you're totally right. There's no point in keeping both...and unfortunately, Luck is the smart, long-term choice.

2 years, 7 months ago on Tuesday Open Thread: The Bright Shimmer

Reply

@mattshedd I was literally yelling at the TV "GIVE THE BALL TO BROWN!!!" I'm really excited to see what Brown can do next year while people are busy paying attention to Luck/Manning. He's got some serious star power.

2 years, 7 months ago on Happy Sunday Afternoons

Reply

@javen why is Gonzo considered a goner? I would think we could keep him for relatively cheap, considering the lack of production...

2 years, 8 months ago on The Two Year Rebuild

Reply

@Fondue If Luck is all he's cracked up to be, I don't care how we get him...imagine if we skip him, and 5 years from now we're quarterbackless with Luck tearing up defenses for another team. It wouldn't feel right.

2 years, 8 months ago on Irsay prefers Manning

Reply

@Music Man Assuming you're being sarcastic, that's hilarious.

2 years, 8 months ago on The Truth is Boring

Reply

@Anonymous Lee Redemption for the number #12!

2 years, 8 months ago on We're #1!

Reply

To steal one of Nate's Favorite sayings:

Regression to the Mean

2 years, 8 months ago on 'Name that Chapter' Contest!

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy@javen@kasey_junk@cpenn31 Hey Nate, did you do an article on why you no longer like Caldwell? Cause I know you were a fan previously...

2 years, 8 months ago on Toxic Shock

Reply

@kasey_junk@Macko *polians. Gotcha. That's what I want to hear.

2 years, 8 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield -Falcons

Reply

@Macko Yeah, same here, what'd he say?

2 years, 8 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield -Falcons

Reply

@MarlaAS@jrmzt Ultimately, what it comes down to is that this is the second game we've been killed in...the other 5 have been Close, and Peyton gives us a MUCH better chance in close games. A 5-2 Colts team would be 1st in the division.

2 years, 9 months ago on The Most Humiliating Night in Colts History

Reply

@Platinum Yeah, Gee, I mean, even Jimmy Johnson had 62 points against him, and we all know how great of a coach he was!

2 years, 9 months ago on The Most Humiliating Night in Colts History

Reply

@DougEngland If he doesn't play next year, I'd love to see him coach. I can guarantee we'd go for it EVERY fourth down.

2 years, 9 months ago on The Most Humiliating Night in Colts History

Reply

Not gonna lie, I really like "the Slot Machine". Such a pity that he got hurt. :/

2 years, 9 months ago on Announcing the Winners

Reply

I see that you told the Saints blogger "41-10" and you're telling us "45-17". I don't know what to make of that...?

2 years, 9 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Saints

Reply

@invisibulman@Pied If we go 0-14, will we rest our starters for the last two games??

2 years, 9 months ago on What Does it Take to Get the #1 Pick?

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy@Jake It seemed to me that Lacy had his head at least partly turned. The ref threw the flag from the back, so he couldn't see that...so I thought the call was iffy, but in the end, it didn't matter. While Lacey got his hand on the ball, somehow Bowe still managed to catch it.

2 years, 9 months ago on Tape Study: E-Bowe the Letter

Reply

@DougEngland I tried to look at the replay, and it doesn't seem as if anyone else is open...and yes, Gonzo on a LB is a mismatch. Blatant PI, and Gonzo knew it. LB never got his head around.

2 years, 9 months ago on If Not Now, When?

Reply

@gizzardfanny@ToddSchuman I'm really hoping that Gonzo shows something here before the end of the Season. I only saw the first half of the game, and he wasn't even on the field. If Wayne is gone, I think that leaves a place for him, if he can get a chance to return to '07 form.

2 years, 9 months ago on If Not Now, When?

Reply

@pierrezombie@DougEngland I will die if we let Mathis go. If it's gotta be Wayne or Mathis, PLEASE let it be Wayne that goes...Mathis is still a beast.

2 years, 9 months ago on Eyes in the Backfield-Chiefs

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy I guess I'm referring to this specific instance...seems to be a hot button issue.

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy Hey man, keep your head up. You're doing great work, and frankly, even whenI disagree with you, I appreciate that you've got the guts to say what you think, even when it boils down to "we're not going to be good this year and our qb's suck".

Just a thought, have you considered asking some of the people who disagree with you to write their own opinion/prediction article? It's awful easy to criticize when one's own reputation isn't on the line.

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

@kc6624 And given that Painter wore pink on Monday night, it looks like we've got our choice. ;)

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

Polian talks about drafting players for their "intelligence". Collins has talked about this offense being "nothing like anything he ever played in." Perhaps that's why the Colts kept Painter, not as much for his physical skills as because he could understand the offense?

Just a thought.

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy And Nate, last week I stood up for Painter and said that he was better than Collins. I'll freely admit that I was wrong, as your article masterfully points out. Keep up the good work. :)

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy@niko_cccc Just a point on why Painter "Looks better":

I think people like Painter mainly cause he didn't appear lost. Collins fumbled a snap and a throw against Houston, and it made him seem utterly incompetent. In the next couple games he didn't do anything amazing to erase that memory.

On the other hand, Painter came in and led a meaningful TD drive against Pitt, and had two meaningful TD's against Tampa Bay. No, the 2 TD's against TB were not his own doing, but that's beside the point. Collins' dumb luck was two ridiculous fumbles against Houston, Painter's dumb luck resulted in 14 points. Though this has no real meaning, it does skew perception.

I'm not saying this makes Painter better (though I personally think he WILL improve. You can't tell me Manning hasn't gotten better since year 3.) What I am saying is that first impressions are definitely skewing perceptions. Collins came across as hopeless, and Painter came in and brought some hope.

2 years, 9 months ago on Has Curtis Painter Outplayed Kerry Collins?

Reply

Last night I realized that Freeney should be an automatic HOF. Unless I'm mistaken, he didn't record a sack last night, but it was OBVIOUS that he was creating havoc. Perhaps "Sacks" is a number that lies?

2 years, 9 months ago on Remedial School

Reply

@DougEngland I said something very similar before I read this, and I couldn't agree more. Painter didn't look lost out there, and that made the game much more interesting to watch.

2 years, 9 months ago on Remedial School

Reply

I think what makes fans (including myself) like Painter better than Collins is that he doesn't look lost out there. He points at guys, audibles, and licks his fingers, and you have to admit it makes him appear competent. Of course, in the long run he achieves the same result, a loss, so the point is moot...but at least Painter is more fun to watch.

2 years, 9 months ago on Remedial School

Reply

@blessedwhiteeyes I'm not complaining!

2 years, 9 months ago on Colts Bucs Open Thread

Reply

@Shane Curry Not that it matters, but Painter played against the first/second teams in these games, while Brandstater played against 3rd/4th teamers. This is a case where the number aren't going to be terribly accurate.

2 years, 9 months ago on What if Painter Plays Well ?

Reply

A DB once said that Marvin Harrison was the hardest WR to cover, because all his routes looked the same for the first 10 yards...sounds like Wayne learned from the best.

2 years, 9 months ago on Wayne demands respect

Reply

@DougEngland Dead on about the body language. I thought Painter "looked" good vs. Pittsburgh, probably part of the reason fans have such a positive impression of him.

2 years, 9 months ago on What if Painter Plays Well ?

Reply

@mattshedd I think Marlin Jackson should be there, just because of his interception. ;) jk

2 years, 9 months ago on Thursday Open Thread-Farewell Gary Brackett

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy 1. Again, as I pointed out below, 10 of Addai's yards were negated by a holding penalty. You make it sound as if Painter only had a measly 3 through the air, when in fact we had a first and goal at the 12 yard line, of which Addai only picked up the last 3.

2. Painter's lack of throwing skills play to his advantage here. Everyone knows that Garcon only catches if it's an impossibly bad throw. ;)

3. I'd like to point out that he started 0-3, and finished 5/8. One of his passes was into the turf on a blown screen play. And he did go into the game cold. (quoting Polian there.)

4. Three years? Are you referring to 2 games his rookie year, and then the preseason for the other two? He hasn't played with the Colts' starters except for this year, am I not correct?

Here's the thing. Since Manning's injury, Painter put up an okt performance against GB, and an ok performance against Pitt. That is marked improvement over Paintergate. Perhaps he's stepping up his game due to the insult of the Collins pickup?

Of course, one of us is going to be proven very wrong on Monday night. Long term, I hope it's me (High draft pick, baby!), but my inner Colt still wants to win every game.

2 years, 9 months ago on All the Colts Really Need is a Quarterback

Reply

@pierrezombie Case in point being that if he is truly as bad as most believe, we're one game closer to drafting Andrew Luck. If he's not, then we suddenly have a viable backup. I don't see how we can lose in that scenario.

2 years, 10 months ago on All the Colts Really Need is a Quarterback

Reply

@blessedwhiteeyes IN theory, I agree. In this particular case, I seem to remember it sailing well out of bounds: not a case of the timing being off, but the accuracy just not being there. I didn't see a replay, though, so I can't be sure that was the case.

2 years, 10 months ago on All the Colts Really Need is a Quarterback

Reply

Frankly, I have to disagree with you, Nate. (I know, I'm no football wiz, but still.)

Collins hasn't yet led us to a meaningful TD in two and a half games, while Painter did on his 4th drive, in a clutch situation against the Steelers' Defense. Collins also had the chance to lead not one, but two game-changing drives against the Browns, and we saw what happened there.

Yes, Addai, ran for 17 yards on two carries in the red zone, but recall that there was a holding penalty that set us back 10 of those. (And Painter threw two red zone completions, the second being the pass to Clark that set up the TD run.) But what it boils down to? We did, in fact, score a meaningful TD. Collins can't say that.

Thirdly, Collins missed BADLY on several throws where he wasn't even rushed. (In particular, I'm thinking of a curl route to Wayne which he threw out of bounds on the left side.) Painter also missed on 2 throws at least, but I didn't feel like either of them were nearly that bad, and both of them came on his couple drives. His two throws to Garcon on the TD drive were crisp and on target. He hit Clark in the hands on another, and Clark flat out dropped it.

Now, while I don't think that proves that Painter is any good (another fumble, seriously?), I do think it merits giving him a chance to prove himself. You mention that he has terrible pocket presence. Didn't Collins have the same problem game 1? It was clear that he fixed it games 2 and 3. Perhaps Painter just needs some time to get through the growing pains. Note that he hasn't played a game from start to finish his whole career.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think Painter will be a great QB. However, I DO think he will give us a better chance to win than Collins has. The Colts have kept him for a reason, and I think he deserves a full game to show what he's got.

And frankly, what do we have to lose?

2 years, 10 months ago on All the Colts Really Need is a Quarterback

Reply

@Nate Dunlevy Collins brought the ball forward in a throwing motion, then brought it back to the "ready" position, and that's when he fumbled. Isn't that incomplete by the tuck rule?

http://www.nfl.com/videos/indianapolis-colts/09000d5d822205f6/Texans-defense-sack-7-yd-loss

2 years, 10 months ago on Colts fall 34-7 to Texans

Reply

@BMS I, too, thought it was the tuck rule. Surprised no one else thought that...good to realize I'm not insane. ;)

2 years, 10 months ago on Colts fall 34-7 to Texans

Reply

@Shake1n1bake Thanks! It's good to watch some non-losing-to-jets Colts football...even if it is preseason...

2 years, 11 months ago on Colts Redskins Open Thread

Reply

Where can I watch the game online?

2 years, 11 months ago on Colts Redskins Open Thread

Reply