Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

@Gossamer After watching Goodell's CBS interview performance, I think it's the commissioner who might be smoking dope. And the pressure is increasing by the day...I wouldn't be surprised if protesters start showing up at NFL games. While the diehard fan might think this would be quixotic, for the casual fan, guilt is a powerful emotion.


I do wish to thank you for your outstanding list of the NFL's sins; the full list would easily be hundreds of times longer. Personally, and I speak for many others, I've had it. Football is a wholly optional feature of American culture...there's other crap I could be doing. I would recommend the book written by Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference. The NFL's problems are years in the making, and for a lot of people, the fact that the commissioner wasn't also cut on Monday is a true Tipping Point.

6 days, 15 hours ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/peter-king-contradicts-nfl-statement-that-the-league-never-saw-the-ray-rice-video.html

Reply

One reads the posts on this site, extolling the virtues of smart sports journalism, then one scrolls down to the comments, and most of the comments are "shut up toots" or "Olbermann is stupid".


So my question is, why do you people read this blog?!

6 days, 15 hours ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/katie-nolan-lays-down-a-must-see-challenge-to-the-sports-media.html

Reply

@Gossamer Wow, the NFL uber alles-types are coming out in droves on the sports blogs today, in defense of their favorite sport, knowing that this video really exposes the league for what it is.

From a big picture perspective, the NFL truly has a cultural problem of pure, raw violence at its core, that is part of the game, and that can and will not be removed. The rest of American culture is slowly moving away from that mindset. This societal consensus, manifested on social media, is reacting to the endless bad behavior of players (and owners for that manner) produced by this sick culture. As a result, the NFL has had to deal with one PR disaster after another, and they are constantly scrambling to catch up with band aid after band aid. But, the shield is still falling further and further behind, with another big backwards step taken today.

The league is going to have to move faster if it wants to avoid a situation where soccer takes over in this country. One good start would be the removal of Goodell, who has shown himself to be a pathological liar. But keep up the mealy-mouthed talk, Gossamer, as casual fans, especially women and non-psychopaths, make small, individual decisions over time, such as maybe not playing fantasy football, or watching Netflix on Thursday nights. (And Giants stadium looked about half-empty for yesterday's Jets game.) An 800-pound gorilla can be killed by a billion cuts. This video is the smoking gun that people will play from now on, every time NFL fans start fawning about how the NFL will be king forever and ever, amen.

1 week, 1 day ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/peter-king-contradicts-nfl-statement-that-the-league-never-saw-the-ray-rice-video.html

Reply

Great points in these comments...being on OTA TV & the proliferation of gambling & fantasy (a form of gambling), has been great for the NFL, and they know it. That's why they hustled half of the Thursday night package to CBS. And other sports (I'm looking at you NBA & MLB) would be well-served in the long run, to do whatever it takes to get more of their games back on free TV. And the fact that NASCAR will have many more races on cable next year gives new meaning to the phrase "Out of Sight, Out of Mind". You simply just get more casual fans to tune in to games on the big networks, as opposed to making them find you on cable sports tiers. Only the diehards follow you to cable...it doesn't make the casual fan go out of their way to buy more cable channels, or call their cable company to complain about not having a specific channel, or scour the web to find where you're at.


As Deadspin put it, we're definitely at "peak-NFL", but it will take the rise of another sport to knock the king off of the mountain. I have no idea what it would be though. All of the other sports, other than college football, are showing some sort of significant weakness in their product & audience. Perhaps the success of the World Cup this summer would convince the big European clubs to play the Champions League in the US, with packed larger-than-European stadiums for every game...that would be frickin' huge.

3 weeks, 3 days ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/will-controversy-and-over-saturation-lead-the-nfl-to-reach-its-cultural-apex.html

Reply

They desperately need to get on basic cable tiers, especially to reach casual viewers, like those who follow just their local teams or one or two sports. Along this line though, what is putting channels like NFLN, MLBN, & NBCSN on the map right now? High-quality (but not necessarily high-budget) shows, focused on individual sports. For example, NBCSNj's serious coverage of the EPL has gotten good reviews. FS1 could put together a rock-solid show, not a comedy show, about the Champions League, extended highlights, focused previews, etc. They could leverage their baseball & football contracts the same way, like serious remakes of shows like Inside the NFL or This Week in Baseball.


In short, don't underestimate the ESPN-smite factor...there are tons of fans who would like to see quality sports shows, without the luggage of ESPN's "personalities" or Fox's worn-out "attitude".

1 month ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/fox-sports-1-needs-to-pass-the-dvr-test-in-year-2.html

Reply

For every outstanding post on this blog, like the one last year explaining how ESPN's provoking the conference vs. conference hatred has cost the network significant ratings in parts of the country that used to be WWL strongholds, there's a few dozen lame stick-up jobs like this post. Ugh.

1 month ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/the-most-notorious-espn-personalities-are-they-really-worth-it.html

Reply

Congratulations, Ben...you just wrote the amicus brief that the NFL will file when the FTC files its antitrust suit against Fox/TWC. The leagues want more bidders, not fewer.

2 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/the-only-real-chance-at-a-true-espn-competitor-this-decade-could-come-out-of-fox-acquiring-time-warner.html

Reply

@Pat_Pending There are excellent comments here and the poster's idea is quite good, but the localization of the sport is the number 1 issue. In most MLB cities, the baseball team is a great summer distraction until the team is out of contention, or the NFL season starts. That's bad news for the sport long-term though, and some of the other ideas about speeding up the game, and other radical on-field changes will become necessary at some point.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/rethinking-baseball-on-national-television.html

Reply

Question for the poster: are advertisers assuming that bar & other larger in-crowd viewers not considered "captured viewers", i.e., they're not watching commercials? Then, as such, I assume that advertisers don't care about those viewers, correct?

On the one hand, it makes sense that those viewers are talking to each other, ordering drinks and food, etc., during commercials. On the other hand, home viewers aren't watching commercials either (I can tell you from personal experience) and such numbers are short-sighted since these potential soccer viewers are also potential customers.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/so-about-that-out-of-home-viewing-for-the-world-cup.html

Reply

@rywalker True, except that most of the Fortune 500's in Cincinnati are mostly outsourcers for the vast majority of their tech work (and these firms are simply not known for being on the tech "bleeding edge" anyway). So, ultimately, they simply don't find their tech talent to be mission critical, especially if you're over 30.

2 months, 2 weeks ago on The best and worst of startup Cincinnati comes down to its Fortune 500s

Reply

Thank you, the three of you, for your paid lies.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/

Reply

I'm no big soccer fan, but clearly this column was just part of an organized conservative effort to bad mouth young people, whenever possible, because they're just too multicultural, and too liberal for their tastes.These conservative theorists believe that there is a cause-and-effect relationship between youth self-esteem building and attitudes among Millenials later in life that they should have a better lot in life in this country than they're currently getting. This is clearly not an acceptable attitude as far as conservatives are concerned.


Furthermore, conservatives think that injury and humiliation in old-school youth sports engender a shut-up-and-take-it attitude in adulthood. I've heard this view expressed. Hence, Coulter's continuous harping on this theme.


Ironically, soccer's dimensions are in Imperial measurements anyway, 18 yards, 12 yards, 10 yards, 6 yards, 24 feet by 8 feet, etc.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/

Reply

Or, another way of looking at it is, after 45 years of marketing, soccer has barely emerged as a "once-every-four-years-sport". That means soccer will become as popular as baseball or college basketball in the year 2150.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/what-massive-world-cup-ratings-really-mean-for-american-soccer.html

Reply

It will be interesting to see the reaction of the Kentucky fans I know. Right now, due to cord-cutting, UK games have become a communal gathering event (fans going to other people's houses, bars, lodges, etc. for games). This trend is only continuing to get bigger. If the university starts making it more difficult to watch and listen to games for this bulk of their fan base, this is going to be a PR disaster.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/university-of-kentucky-signs-15-year-210-million-multimedia-rights-deal.html

Reply

I have to say that I cannot stand the British announcers that ESPN is using...the Bad British Announcing guy on YouTube is a spot-on impersonation of the cliche-ridden spew that comes out of their mouths. As badly as the Gus Johnson experiment turned out, at least Fox was trying to find a way to raise the ceiling on soccer's appeal, beyond the hipsters who seems to love the British commentators. Hopefully Fox can develop some new, additional American talent over the next four years.

3 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/espn-is-leaving-behind-a-huge-world-cup-legacy-for-fox.html

Reply

The sport of golf sold its soul to Tiger Woods for the popularity and celebrity status he brought to golf. But he wasn't going to live forever, and now no one watches the sport anymore, just a few select celebrities. And it's hurting the whole sport. Sure, golf made a lot of money off of Tiger, but it's hurting now. It will be interesting to see when Woods retires, what happens to TV golf contracts (Golf Channel only, on sports tiers only,  except for The Masters on CBS?). And no, @stholeary, there's no cross-over appeal between golf and soccer. (?!)

3 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/us-open-ratings-tanked-for-nbc-thanks-to-martin-kaymers-blowout.html

Reply

@JimLahey25 Good point, there's no excuse for not getting a mega-number on this Finals series, given the markets involved (so much for big-market theory). And if the Rogers/CBC combo is as ugly as "ESPN on ABC" is, then Canadians are not going to be happy.

3 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/the-nhl-on-tv-in-2013-14-opportunity-in-america-the-end-of-an-era-in-canada.html

Reply

The U.S. was picked apart yesterday, like a chicken leg, and got real lucky to win. It's only way down hill from here. It will be interesting to see how your theory about soccer's popularity will hold up with the team starts regressing to the mean, so to speak, and the bandwagoneers get off the bandwagon. And this team is not trending up long-term...they'll have trouble qualifying in future years...let's see the ratings on Fox then.

3 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/espn-draws-record-audiences-for-the-united-states-victory-over-ghana.html

Reply

Holy crap, that was the stupidest f'ing video I've ever seen...the added animation with the player being flipped breaking into a thousand pieces, and the bulging eyes...I had forgotten about that, and this video should make it crystal clear what a total joke the NHL on Fox was.

3 months, 1 week ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/throwbackthursday-in-1995-fox-was-doing-fine-at-cup-time.html

Reply

Well then, goodbye WGN...truly the end of an era. I mean where would Will Ferrell be without his Carey impression? Long term, this is bad for the Cubs franchise, since there are a lot of nationwide middle aged and older fans of the Cubs that became fans watching them on WGN. Now, unless they improve the on-field product, they'll just be a Chicago curiosity, and a punching bag for the rest of the NL.

3 months, 2 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/get-ready-to-say-goodbye-to-sports-on-wgn-america.html

Reply

Wow, where to begin? Well, the WWE isn't a sport, for crying out loud. And it's been trending down in ratings for years. You're comparing apples-to-oranges, especially with NASCAR (wrestling and auto racing doesn't have the cross-over appeal it once had). The NASCAR deal looks suspect given that ESPN couldn't get rid of that hot potato fast enough, so that's an even poorer comparison.


Perhaps the macroeconomic reality, and the continued success of Netflix and their strategy of courting cord-cutters, has got the networks thinking twice about their obsession with live programming. The NBA contract negotiations might be more interesting than the bloggers here think.

4 months ago on Conversation @ http://awfulannouncing.com/

Reply

Yes, hockey fans are parochial, no question. But, NBA fans are just as defensive about their sport, because, as the old saying goes, "There's no there, there." As an fan of neither the NBA, nor the NHL, I can tell you that how LeBron James is presented in these tweets is how the rest of sports fandom feels about James and the NBA in general...a bunch of overly pampered clumsy oafs.

6 months, 1 week ago on Bad Hockey Twitter is making the sport less fun

Reply

I don't think that Francesca, even if he broadens his topics beyond New York sports, has ANY appeal outside of the Northeast. For that matter, I live in the Midwest, and I can barely understand a word he says. Big mistake for Fox Sports on this one...look for them to preempt with Champions League, etc. whenever possible as time goes on, as this will drive viewers away and the outside-NY ratings go to zero.

6 months, 1 week ago on Mike Francesa officially joins Fox Sports 1 (and 2!)

Reply

"To see the impact of television timeouts on a college basketball broadcast, I studied the UCLA-Washington game from last Thursday night that was still on my DVR so I can enjoy the sounds of Bill Walton throughout the offseason."

There are cheaper and easier ways to flog yourself, you know.

6 months, 1 week ago on TV timeouts are ruining college basketball

Reply

@adad500 You bet it's easy to despise referees...showboats who have no accountability to anyone, athletic failures in their own right thinking they're the show, and they're killing the sport of basketball, at all levels, right now. There's no sport with more blown calls (though the NFL tries to be #1 in that too), and if you want to make college basketball a whole lot better in a hurry, a clean out of guys like this would be a great place to start.

6 months, 2 weeks ago on Dan Dakich rightfully destroys Ted Valentine

Reply

This is more of a loss for ESPN, than it is a win for the fans. My local team's game was never blacked out off of cable on Saturdays, and it just sounds like some more random games for FS1. MLB is following the NBA cable-only road to obscurity. A legitimate, season-long game of the week is what every truly successful team sport has, and MLB needs.

6 months, 2 weeks ago on Everyone wins with Fox's new MLB contract

Reply

Because casual viewers are still on an NFL-hangover, NASCAR's biggest event has really good timing, but NASCAR is a "big-event" sport only at this point. ESPN's abrupt exit shows that there's no week-to-week interest. Fox & NBC are just desperate to fill the hours on sports channels they've thrown lots of money at.


As far as the NBA is concerned, there's no interest here either...there maybe some interest in the playoffs, especially the finals, but this may be because of some carryover interest among casual fans after the NCAA tournament.

6 months, 3 weeks ago on Daytona 500 rain delay outdraws NBA

Reply

Two other reasons missed in the article & other comments:


1. Geography: the U.S. is a big country with lots of wide-open rural areas. Pro major & minor league sports, by necessity and historically, are based in urban areas. For those who don't live in urban areas, what better sports branding is there than "The University of Nebraska", meaning Omaha all the way down to Podunk. College sports have always, and continue, to provide a quality sports product to a natural fan base, especially for successful teams in states with lots of rural area. This, historically then, creates #2:

2. Incumbency: the land-grant institutions are older than any pro sport except MLB (the minor leagues didn't gain traction until the 1920's). So generations of fans have placed their loyalty to their respective college teams, decades before many major or minor league sports teams marketed to these fans.

7 months, 1 week ago on Why College Sports Prevail Over Minor Leagues: Brands Matter

Reply

One of the best entries I've seen on a sports blog in a long time...another reason why ESPN & sports TV, in general, over the long-term, is circling the drain. People only have the time and the inclination to follow their local and regional teams, plus a very small number of leagues, overall. ESPN and the others' business model has become the following: build up certain conferences, teams, leagues, etc., that they have enormous contracts with, totally trash everything else ("Only losers still watch the Big 10!"), including destroying the conference system, then wonder why their ratings are decreasing and people are cutting their cable. I know a lot of college basketball fans who have only Netflix & an over-the-air antenna, and just go to the sports bar or lodge whenever their favorite team is on ESPN.

8 months, 1 week ago on Fueling the toxicity of college football fandom is a science

Reply

Sorry, but the Sports Rights Bubble is real...ask the NFL about how their pitch of the Thursday Night package to Netflix went...Netflix said, "No thanks, we make our money on all of the cord cutters leaving their inflated cable bills behind."


It was sad to hear the speaker's bald face lies, such as "People have been talking about a sports rights bubble since the first millionaire athlete." Not really. A cursory Google search shows that the first mention on the Internet was on September 5th, 2008, in the midst of the Wall Street financial crisis. The Forbes article was entitled "Europe's Coming Soccer Bubble." (http://www.forbes.com/2008/09/04/soccer-labor-europe-biz-sports-cx_pm_0905notes.html)


Between cord cutters and those ending their cable subs because they were foreclosed on, the ongoing global depression will strike the sports world, despite Mr. Ourand's giggling.

9 months, 1 week ago on AA Podcast #71 - John Ourand, Sports Business Journal

Reply

More NFL bloviating...they threatened to put the Super Bowl on Pay-Per-View about 10 years ago, until Congress stepped in. Aereo has won court case after court case regarding the legality of its service, and the NFL would lose if they tried to go to court. And, ask Baseball how their ratings have performed with their cable-only playoff games.


The trend is clear, people are tired of paying cable bills, which includes payments to local, "free" stations. It would be stupid for the NFL to get a large number of people to contact their Congressmen about moving the games of the only sport people still care about, to cable, which might backfire on the industry, and possibly cementing the legality of cheaper competitors, like Aereo.

10 months ago on MLB, NFL trying to block Aereo

Reply

The issue is that the small number of viewers who are interested in a traditional highlights show, being generally interested in a specific sport, have already migrated over to shows, primarily, on the MLB Network, the NFL Network, or the NHL Network (ESPN's not hurting for NBA viewers, cramming a Barkley interview into MNF last night). Also, Olbermann may be picking off highlights viewers with the Keithlights segment.

10 months, 3 weeks ago on Don't expect The Lights back on NBCSN any time soon

Reply

Of course Netflix doesn't want sports, and it stinks of desperation by the NFL for them to say that Netflix was interested in their Thursday night albatross. Netflix is the service for the ever growing number of people who are tired of paying ever increasing cable bills for overbloated sports right fees. It will interesting to see when the cable & satellite industry will have to start offering sports-less packages, on a large scale, to respond to Netflix & to keep the customer base intact, and what that will do to the sports industry as a result.

10 months, 4 weeks ago on Netflix says no to live sports

Reply

I have always had a liking for Olbermann, even though on MSNBC, he tended to lecture too much. I hope that he'll be able to get into some more controversial topics. Intelligent talk (something sorely missing from FS1's new show), plus highlights would be a winning combination in the long run. The problem is that ESPN, obviously struggling right now, is too much "in bed" with the NFL, college football, and the NBA, to allow anything to be reported on subjectively, by anyone, much less Olbermann.

If I were Olbermann, I would play a waiting game, bide my time, while using a reporting style similar to what Patrick does on his radio show (comedy, but occasionally serious). Over time, become an asset that ESPN can't do without, as the "screaming" style of the other shows implodes, then name my price. You have to take a long-term approach right now.

1 year ago on Keith Olbermann's brand could prove problematic over time for ESPN

Reply

Wow! I don't know what the story is here. Is it that ESPN is hurting much worse than we realize? Has Disney set profit targets that are forcing the WWL to become a mere shadow of its former self? Given ESPN's recent double-downs on the NFL & college football, and the coming upheaval in the cable industry, will ESPN look like CNN in ten years, a former giant, now weakling?

Or is it that NASCAR is declining faster than the simple ratings numbers suggest? Are there data to which we don't have access, such as the prohibitive costs of covering the sport, making it non-profitable, or that the sport's viewership isn't as lucrative as suggested in the story?

Either way, I'll be watching to see who blinks first.

1 year ago on ESPN & Turner want out of NASCAR a year early?

Reply

An NRL-version of this post would be interesting. Fox, similarly, takes the straight reporting approach. Channel 9, on the other hand, desperately needs some new blood, in fact, senile might be an appropriate description. Ray Warren, who does remind me of Keith Jackson (and should have retired at the same time), will rant about some Channel 9 show he doesn't like, or Twitter, or just about anything else for a good 3 or 4 possessions. He also occasionally sleepwalks through the action, if neither team gets into the red zone for several possessions. Peter Sterling, the Tim McCarver of Australia, is barely hanging on to sanity, and not that well. Ray Hadley is also showing his age, like Vin Scully, except without Scully's skill.

1 year, 1 month ago on The Aussie Rules Football Announcers Guide

Reply

The post is correct in that you don't bring the 800-pound gorilla in the industry down with one shot, but it can die of a thousand cuts. The apparent growth for NFLN, MLBN, NHLN, and NBCSN shows that core sports fans are looking for highlights for their favorite sports, not just the fluff that might be bringing in small numbers of casual, young viewers. Even Goldman Sachs recently downgraded their opinion of Disney stock, based on ESPN's troubles. So, there's definitely something to the changes in sports media.

Yes, Fox's programming probably won't be that good (their coverage in general is overrated), but any competition might force everyone to focus on quality. The rumor of Jason Whitlock possibly hosting a more "intelligent" format on FS1 and Olbermann going back to ESPN are good harbingers for the future. Any sports media future with less Cowherds, Baylesses, and Gottliebs is a good one, indeed.

1 year, 1 month ago on Fox Sports 1 faces the unenviable pressure of high expectations

Reply

@morganwick Butt hurt NBA-lover?

1 year, 2 months ago on ESPN says low ratings are a "rare aberration"

Reply

There's been a long-term trend, of people, in the current economic climate, of simply not having the time to follow and spend money on all of the major sports. People pick a sport or two, and only follow that. Go to NFLN or MLBN or NBCSN, watch briefly, and then go to bed. The all-encompassing jock-culture of ESPN doesn't fit well with the reality of most sports fans' lives.


The other problem is that they've bet the farm on a few sports and the big coastal markets, to the exclusion of others. The reality of the NBA is that it's a celebrity-driven league. It's like the Kardashians for young men; it's just something to tweet about. And once the interest is gone (it happens to all celebrities), or they're not dominating the playoff bracket, everybody forgets about it. Oh, and they've totally reamed college sports.

1 year, 2 months ago on ESPN says low ratings are a "rare aberration"

Reply

I do think that ESPN and the entertainment industry in general are facing huge headwinds, especially given the overall economy. In addition to the sports rights bubble mentioned, the cable/satellite industry is moving slowly, but inexorably to a la carte model. It's going to be tough for the average guy to justify spending $30/month on Skip Bayless, Stephen A. Smith, & yet another lousy Alabama, Duke, Lakers, or Yankees game. ESPN, and these sports channel in general, may never see their money back on some of these long-term deals.

1 year, 3 months ago on ESPN reportedly laying off hundreds of employees

Reply