Livefyre Profile

Activity Stream

[Geordi surveys the competition, then goes back to the holodeck to make himself another girlfriend]

1 month, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://whygavs.com/july-2014/game-105-pirates-5-giants-0.html

Reply

I understand the reasoning thinking that the DH is inevitable, but somehow I just can't see organizations like the Cubs, Cardinals, and Giants simply rolling over and agreeing to play a different game after more than 100 years.  I think it'll be a more protracted argument.

2 months, 3 weeks ago on Conversation @ http://whygavs.com/june-2014/game-78-rays-5-pirates-1.html

Reply

@wkkortas Ah crap, I'm going to take the bait.  Florida and Florida State play regularly, Clemson and Georgia both schedule Clemson.  LSU's schedule in the last few years has included Wisconsin, TCU, Oregon, and UNC at neutral sites as well as home-and-homes with West Virginia, Washington, and Arizona State.  Please don't make me defend Auburn or Alabama.  Point is, I think there was a time this was true, but hasn't been so for a while.


Anyway, I think we can all agree that we miss the Astros.

3 months, 1 week ago on Conversation @ http://whygavs.com/june-2014/game-66-pirates-4-cubs-0.html

Reply

Coming down Bigelow at 11:30 tonight I saw they had all the lights on in PNC Park.  I'm pumped, let's go!

5 months, 4 weeks ago on Heyman: Pirates agree to extension with Starling Marte

Reply

Still the best baseball writer around.  Thank you, Pat.  Thanks for being the voice of Pirates fans, for Pirates fans.  Thanks for giving us a place to celebrate and commiserate.  Thanks for making it easier to be a Pirate fan.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on Thank yous and programming notes

Reply

Today feels a little strange.  No more baseball.  Up until the 27th out last night there was still a chance the Pirates could win the championship.  Now, no chance.  And we're looking at 355 days and 162 games to even get back to this point.  I'm sure soon I'll smile about the Astros running into each other, Pedro bombs out of the stadium, the ball ricocheting off the pitcher's glove and into outfield in the Cardinals doubleheader, what should be an award-winning season from McCutchen, Cole putting it together in September, a sea of black across the Clemente bridge.  And I know I'll smile a long, long time about "Cueeeeetoooo".  But today?  Still disappointed that it's over.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 5: Cardinals 6 Pirates 1 (and so much more)

Reply

Where did Matt Adams go to college?

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 5 Preview: Gerrit Cole vs. Adam Wainwright with an NLCS berth on the line

Reply

So... would you say it's time for us to crack each other's heads open and feast on the goo inside?

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 5 Preview: Gerrit Cole vs. Adam Wainwright with an NLCS berth on the line

Reply

Alright, it's going to take at least three runs to win the game.  Gotta get Wainright out of the game somehow.  Get some hits, work some counts.  Something.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 5 Preview: Gerrit Cole vs. Adam Wainwright with an NLCS berth on the line

Reply

Aaaaagh, three more hours!!!

11 months, 2 weeks ago on The end is the beginning is the end

Reply

In the player introductions before the wild card game and NLDS game three, AJ got among the loudest ovations.  There have been times where his performance has lead to some hand wringing, but I don't think there's any question how much value he has had to the team.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on On Gerrit Cole

Reply

Beautiful day, huge game, and I can't get away from work.  I'm just going to spend the next five hours doing the "I'm missing the chili cook-off" dance in my office.

http://i.imgur.com/Dg5VyGw.gif

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 4 Preview: Finish it today (Charlie Morton vs. Michael Wacha)

Reply

@wkkortas Sure, there were a lot of hard hit balls off of Liriano that found gloves.  But did the Cardinals really do that much that you would say they deserved to win and not the Pirates?  I'd call it a close game that could've gone either way, happened to go our way.

11 months, 2 weeks ago on NLDS Game 3: Pirates 5 Cardinals 3

Reply

@JeffreyMccartney @mwr505 @LastingsMilledgeville All good points here.  Maybe I shouldn't be so critical about attendance for a Thursday afternoon regardless of the situation.  However, isn't their complacency a mark _against_ the narrative that they're the best fans in baseball?

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2: Pirates 7 Cardinals 1

Reply

@LastingsMilledgeville Out of curiosity I checked on Stubhub the other day before the start of the series.  St Louis had tickets available for $20.  Standing room only for the first game in Pittsburgh is $190.  I don't expect Cardinals fans to be as excited about the division series as we are; but really, twenty dollars??

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2: Pirates 7 Cardinals 1

Reply

Was there any doubt about that?

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

Any chance we'll see Gaby Sanchez?

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

Darn.  That was a nice swing

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

Time for the three-run homer from Cole....

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

@wkkortas Don't question it, just go with it

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

@wkkortas @Eephus I'll take a single.  It's just nice to have one pitcher that isn't an automatic out.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

Time for the three-run homer from Cole....

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 2 Preview: Don't Panic (Gerrit Cole vs. Lance Lynn)

Reply

Better dead than red.  Go get 'em, Bucs!

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NLDS Game 1 Preview: AJ Burnett and Adam Wainwright

Reply

Just got back.  Leading a standing ovation in the upper deck for Byrd coming out to warm up.  "Let's go Bucs!" drowning out the Reds' introductions.  Cheering like we won the World Series after Liriano's first strikeout; knew it was his night by the end of the first inning.  Byrd homers.  Cueto drops the ball.  Cueto serves up another homer.  "MVP! MVP!"  Shouting down a guy who wanted to start the wave with "Liriano! [clap,clap, clap clap clap]" The crowd refusing to get down whenever any of our pitchers got into trouble.  Piling on the runs.  Grilli locks it down.  Everyone just stands and cheers for another five minutes before we even think about leaving.  Amazing night.


(Cueto dropped the ball!)

11 months, 3 weeks ago on NL Wild Card: Pirates 6 Reds 2

Reply

@LastingsMilledgeville -1 minute.  Liriano throws one into the opposing dugout during warmups.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on Do the do

Reply

Better dead than red.  Go get 'em, Bucs!

11 months, 3 weeks ago on National League Wild Card Game preview: This is what we've been waiting for

Reply

The old system pitted the wild card team against the best team in the league on equal terms for a best of five series.  Was it fair in 2011 with the 90-win Cardinals against the 102-win Phillies, first one to three games?  Your argument against the new system is valid, but I think the old system might've been less fair, since it's treating teams with a higher win disparity as equal.

Really I find the obsession we have with playoffs is ridiculous.  In European soccer leagues, you play every team twice, once at home and once away.  Absolutely fair.  Also has the chance to have the winner decided a month before the season ends, but that's the price you pay.

11 months, 3 weeks ago on The one game playoff is ridiculous

Reply

@Carnegie Chip Agreed.  If we finish third then we're ecstatic that there's another wild card now, right?

Actually I'm pretty much ok with the wild card playoff game, assuming you want to make it "important" to win the division.  Every American sport says that's their goal, only baseball has now succeeded.  Just look at the level of intensity over the last three weeks as all three teams were terrified of the wild card game, followed by the race to at least host the game.

12 months ago on Game 159: Cubs 4 Pirates 2

Reply

Back in June it became clear that September/October would be the best time for my vacation.  I made sure the flight back was on September 30.  Sad to miss the stretch run, but so, so happy to buy playoff tickets.  Congrats to everyone wearing black and yellow today.

New goal for the team, Cutch gets to play the day after his birthday.

12 months ago on The Pirates are going to the playoffs

Reply

@MattGajtka @mwr505 @Eephus Yeah, I might not remember back that far, but I don't think we were ever "natural rivals" with Cleveland.  They were playing Cincy, Baltimore playing DC and Philly, which left us with no one.  Detroit works out in a "let's compare our post-industrial economies" way.  And I actually think the four-day, two-city series was ok.  It's a long season, gotta do something different once in a while.

1 year ago on Game 145: Pirates 7 Rangers 5

Reply

@mwr505 Houston moving to the AL meant that MLB's schedule makers had to throw out all the models they had previously used and design something from scratch, including year-round interleague play.  So we got a four-game series spread across two cities, 3-weeks straight with no off-days in April and again in September, four off-days in the three weeks leading to the All-Star break, and not seeing a division opponent for three and a half months (out of a six month season).  No conspiracy, just a new situation that they didn't quite figure out how to deal with.  I haven't looked too hard at next year, but hopefully they've fixed a few things.

1 year ago on Game 145: Pirates 7 Rangers 5

Reply

Memo to Mr. Hurdle: However many innings you think AJ can go, subtract one and plan accordingly.  Thank you.

1 year ago on AJ Burnett tries to finish off a sweep in Arlington

Reply

I moved to this fine city around the start of the Littlefield era, went looking for Pirates blogs a couple years later when I started really following the team and also wondering why they seemed to be stagnating.  WHYGAVS has always been the home of solid baseball analysis, but more importantly, some of the most honest emotion you'll find on the internet.  Reading the comments section it always seemed more like group therapy than a bunch of people talking about baseball.

So thanks to Pat for sticking it out for so many bleak years.  Congrats to you, and all the others who have found the time to write a few words in the threads.  wkkortas, bwzimmerman, savage beast, carnegie chip, nick juneau, mornacale, azibuck, miniplen to name a few, I'm happy you all got to experience 82.  Here's to October.

1 year ago on 82 wins

Reply

@TomBrenholts @Eephus Eh, everyone gets to have their own feelings.  And one of the things I've harped on in my time here is that the good moments are the good moments.  Even if this season ends poorly, everyone gets their own personal catharsis tonight, and no one can take that away.  The end of 2011 really sucked for me, but I'll always have the Honey Badger's punt return against Arkansas when the noise of 92,000 fellow fans felt like it was crushing in my skull.  Now every Pirate fan will have the look on Darvish's face as the ball off of Alvarez's bat sailed over his head, McCutchen with his arms raised to the heavens after the final out, and the number 82.

1 year ago on Gerrit Cole and Yu Darvish face off as Pirates look to snap losing streak

Reply

What's the proper response to this?  Is there an improper response?  I was thinking about running up and down the street yelling at the top of my lungs, but went with a quiet fist pump instead.  As our esteemed blogger reminds us, there's still work to do.

1 year ago on Gerrit Cole and Yu Darvish face off as Pirates look to snap losing streak

Reply

You there!  Alvarez!  Hit a home run!

1 year ago on Gerrit Cole and Yu Darvish face off as Pirates look to snap losing streak

Reply

@mwr505 Keep in mind that the Pirates won the season series against the Cardinals, and are currently winning the season series against the Reds.  Undeniably they're limping now, but I'd say that's mostly due to pitching injuries and a streaky offense currently in slump mode, rather than being pretenders.  You could make an argument that the Pirates are, top-to-bottom, the least deep team in the NL playoff field, but they are still a team that deserves to make the playoffs.  And once in October, the made-for-TV schedule means you don't have to have the deepest team to win it all.

1 year ago on Game 142: Cardinals 9 Pirates 2

Reply
@wkkortas I kinda want them to run Cumpton or Gomez out there tonight to try to steal the sweep, leaving a rested Liriano waiting for the Cardinals on Friday night.

1 year ago on 81 wins

Reply

@AtomK13 @whygavs It's become pretty clear this year he should drop the whole bio-chem-whatever-it-is-he-does and get a PhD in baseball writing.  Wouldn't be much extra work because, in the time-honored tradition of grad school, he could just take previous work and package it up as a thesis.  We could round up, oh... how about Keri, Neyer, and Verducci as the committee.  Maybe pick up Bill Barnwell or Chris B. Brown if we need an external member.  Say the word, Pat.  We can help make this happen.

1 year ago on 81 wins

Reply

@DouggieB The one thing that really bothers me about the negative posts following a loss are people telling me how I should feel as a Pirates fan.  The direct way, telling people not to get their hopes up (as if missing the playoffs is a foregone conclusion somehow).  The more indirect statements, like the Pirates are worse than the Diamondbacks and the Pirates are going to get swept by the Rangers, which is just extreme pessimism presented as incontrovertible facts.  It just annoys people and ends any possibility of a real discussion.

So, glad to see the change of heart.  I hope you'll find that enjoying the wins (78 of them before the end of August!) is a lot more fun than anticipating the losses.

1 year ago on Game 134: Pirates 5 Cardinals 0

Reply

According to Baseball Prospectus, the probability of the Pirates winning the World Series is 5.3%, while the probability of not making the playoffs is 2.3%.  To everyone who comes here after every loss to tell us that the collapse is nigh and everyone should be as depressed as they are, I say my biggest dream is still more likely than your worst nightmare.

The 2013 Pittsburgh Pirates are a pretty good baseball team.  They have what it takes to make the playoffs, and from there anything can happen.  To those who think like me, let's keep the faith.  Maybe it won't be rewarded, but I'd rather spend the next month hoping for something big than wallowing in misery like a few people here.

1 year ago on Game 133: Brewers 4 Pirates 0

Reply

You know who's worried about a collapse?  Clint Hurdle.  For a few months there he was letting the hitters hit and the pitchers pitch; the wins stacked up and the Hurdled hashtag basically disappeared.  Then one bad week in the heartland, it looks like he got spooked, and now he's trying to manufacture wins again.  Whatever it was in the late spring that turned him into a completely different (and much better) manager, he needs a reminder right now. 

1 year, 1 month ago on Game 122: Diamondbacks 4 Pirates 2

Reply

Let's go.... Cubs?   Let's go.... Brewers??  Being in contention in August does strange things to the brain. 

1 year, 1 month ago on Game 121: Pirates 6 Diamondbacks 2

Reply

@wkkortas [ Dad voice ] : PAAAAAAAT!  BE NICE TO YOUR READERS!!!

1 year, 1 month ago on An attempt for some Friday morning context

Reply

Ooh, better yet.  How about HBP-SB, "The Marte Double"?

1 year, 1 month ago on The biggest series (part two)

Reply

Any chance we can get that named "The Marte Walk"?

1 year, 1 month ago on The biggest series (part two)

Reply

@nickjuneau24 Over at Bucs Dugout they're counting down the number of wins to 82, and since 20 wins left to go they've been revisiting the roster of each team in the streak.  But this win total thing puts it in an even harsher light.


I'm not from here originally and only started following the Pirates around '03 or '04.  Looking at these lists and seeing it all in gory detail, I have to wonder why I started.  What was wrong with me?

1 year, 1 month ago on 70 wins

Reply

Whenever the Pirates get to their opponent's bullpen down by two or less, I think to myself, "they got this".  This is ridiculous.  I'm frequently right, though.  This is also ridiculous.

1 year, 1 month ago on Gerrit Cole and Jose Fernandez: The Rematch

Reply

@wkkortas @mwr505 Pretty sure we're talking about the "Da Vinci Effect" here.  Leonardo left a formula for predicting the fate of major league pitching prospects hidden in the Mona Lisa.

1 year, 1 month ago on Tuesday morning links

Reply